• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Natural selection in action: three types of selection

Identify stabilising, directional and disruptive selection from graphs and scenarios, and separate Darwin's theory from Lamarck's and from the modern synthesis.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Knowing the word 'natural selection' is not enough at the practice level. Questions give a curve or a short story and ask which kind of selection is acting, or they list statements and ask which belongs to Darwin, to Lamarck or to the modern synthetic theory. This lesson shows how to read a selection graph in seconds and how to sort theory statements by their key words.

Reading the bell curve

For a trait such as body size, most individuals are near the average and fewer are at the extremes, which gives a bell-shaped curve. Selection changes the shape of this curve in one of three ways, depending on which individuals survive and reproduce best.

TypeWho is favouredEffect on the curveTypical example
StabilisingThe average individualsPeak stays in place, becomes narrower and tallerHuman birth weight: very low and very high weights survive less well
DirectionalOne extremePeak shifts towards that extremeDark peppered moths; antibiotic resistance
DisruptiveBoth extremesMiddle falls, two peaks may formBirds with small or large beaks where only small and large seeds are common

Speed method: find the part of the curve that is favoured. Middle, then stabilising; one end, then directional; both ends, then disruptive. Do not be misled by the word 'change': stabilising selection still changes the population by reducing variation, even though the average stays the same.

Worked example 1: three stories

Story 1: a new antibiotic kills most bacteria, but those with a rare resistance gene survive and multiply. One end of the variation is favoured, so this is directional selection. Story 2: in a bird population, nests with very few eggs leave few young, while nests with very many eggs often fail because parents cannot feed all the chicks; nests with an average number do best. The middle is favoured: stabilising selection. Story 3: on an island where only very small and very large seeds are common, finches with medium beaks starve while those with small or large beaks do well. Both ends are favoured: disruptive selection, which can eventually split a population into two forms.

Darwin, Lamarck and the modern synthesis

Darwin's theory rests on overproduction, struggle for existence, heritable variation, survival of the fittest and natural selection, leading to branching descent from common ancestors. Darwin could not explain where variation came from or how it was inherited, because genetics was not yet understood. The modern synthetic theory combines Darwin's selection with genetics: variation arises from mutation and genetic recombination, natural selection acts on it, and reproductive isolation allows new species to form. Lamarck's 'inheritance of acquired characters' is part of neither.

Worked example 2: sorting statements

Sort these four. (a) 'Variation arises by mutation and recombination.' This is genetics added to Darwin: modern synthesis. (b) 'Organisms produce more offspring than can survive.' Darwin's overproduction. (c) 'Organs grow through use and the change is inherited.' Lamarck. (d) 'Isolation lets diverged populations become separate species.' Modern synthesis. A question asking for the statement that is 'not part of the synthetic theory' wants (c).

Fitness, once more

Fitness in all these cases means reproductive fitness: the relative number of offspring an individual leaves. An individual that lives long but leaves no offspring has zero fitness in the evolutionary sense. Selection acts on individuals, but its result is seen as a change in the population over generations.

A last trap is the difference between natural and artificial selection. In artificial selection, a person chooses which plants or animals breed, as in developing high-yielding crops or different breeds of dogs. The mechanism, unequal reproduction of variants, is the same as in natural selection, which is why Darwin used breeders' results as support for his theory. The difference is only who does the selecting: the environment or the breeder.

Middle favoured: stabilising. One end favoured: directional. Both ends favoured: disruptive. Synthetic theory = mutation + recombination + selection + isolation.

Key takeaways

  • Stabilising selection narrows the curve without shifting the average.
  • Directional selection shifts the average; resistance to antibiotics and pesticides is the classic case.
  • Disruptive selection favours both extremes and can split a population.
  • The modern synthesis explains the source of variation that Darwin lacked.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Selection that favours individuals with average values of a trait is called:

    1. Directional selection
    2. Disruptive selection
    3. Stabilising selection
    4. Artificial selection
    Show answer

    Answer: C. When the middle of the curve is favoured and the extremes are removed, the selection is stabilising.

  2. 2. Bacteria resistant to an antibiotic become common after the antibiotic is used widely. This is an example of:

    1. Stabilising selection
    2. Disruptive selection
    3. Genetic drift
    4. Directional selection
    Show answer

    Answer: D. One extreme of the variation (resistance) is favoured, so the population's average shifts in that direction: directional selection.

  3. 3. On an island only very small and very large seeds are available, and finches with medium beaks decline. Which type of selection is acting?

    1. Stabilising selection
    2. Directional selection
    3. Disruptive selection
    4. No selection
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Both extremes (small and large beaks) are favoured and the middle is removed. That is disruptive selection.

  4. 4. Which of these is NOT a factor in the modern synthetic theory of evolution?

    1. Gene mutation
    2. Genetic recombination
    3. Reproductive isolation
    4. Inheritance of acquired characters
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The synthetic theory combines mutation, recombination, natural selection and reproductive isolation. Inheritance of acquired characters is Lamarck's idea and is not part of it.

  5. 5. What happens to a population's curve for a trait under stabilising selection?

    1. The peak shifts towards one side
    2. The peak stays at the same average and becomes narrower
    3. Two separate peaks form
    4. The curve becomes flatter and wider around the same average
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Stabilising selection removes extremes, so variation falls: the curve becomes narrower and taller with the average unchanged.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery