• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mixed question types: statements, assertion-reason and matching

Practise the question formats that combine several ideas: true/false statement sets, assertion and reason, and matching columns, across the whole of evolution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The last stage of preparation is to practise the formats rather than the facts. In evolution, the same handful of facts is dressed up in statement sets, assertion-reason items and matching columns. The facts are in the earlier lessons; here the skill is to handle the format. We take each format in turn and show the way to approach it, using content from across the course.

Format 1: statement sets

A statement set gives two to four statements and asks which are correct. The best method is to mark each statement T or F independently, then choose the option that matches your marks. Do not let the combinations in the options influence your marking. A typical set: (i) Homologous organs have the same origin but different functions. (ii) Analogous organs have a common structure. (iii) Vestigial organs are reduced and have lost most of their function. Statement (i) is true, (ii) is false (analogous organs have different structure and the same function), and (iii) is true. The correct option is 'i and iii only'.

Format 2: assertion and reason

An assertion-reason item has an assertion (A) and a reason (R). There are two checks. Is A true? Is R true? If both are true, ask whether R explains A. Example: A: Wings of birds and wings of insects are analogous. R: They have different structures but perform the same function. Both are true and R is the right explanation. A different example: A: Genetic drift is stronger in small populations. R: Mutations occur only in small populations. A is true, but R is false, so the item fails at the second check.

Format 3: matching columns

In a matching item, start with the pairs you are sure of and remove them, so that the uncertain ones are left. Example: match (a) Archaeopteryx, (b) Miller, (c) Weismann, (d) Darwin's finches, with (i) tails of mice, (ii) adaptive radiation, (iii) reptile-bird link, (iv) amino acids from simple gases. The answers are (a)-(iii), (b)-(iv), (c)-(i), (d)-(ii).

Worked example 1: a statement set with a trap

Which are correct? (i) Natural selection acts on genotypes directly. (ii) Evolution occurs in populations, not in individuals. (iii) The fittest individual is always the strongest. Statement (ii) is correct. Statement (i) is false because selection acts on phenotypes, that is, on the traits that individuals show, and the genotype changes in frequency as a result. Statement (iii) is false because fitness is reproductive success, not strength. Only (ii) is correct.

Worked example 2: a numerical statement

A population of 500 has 20 individuals with a recessive trait. Is the statement 'the frequency of the recessive allele is 0.2' true, assuming equilibrium? q² = 20 ÷ 500 = 0.04, so q = 0.2. Yes, it is true. The carrier frequency is 2pq = 2 × 0.8 × 0.2 = 0.32, so about 160 people are carriers.

Worked example 3: assertion and reason that fails

A: Mules are sterile. R: A mule cannot be produced from a horse and a donkey. The assertion is true. The reason is false, since a mule is exactly what such a cross produces. The correct classification is 'A true, R false'.

Mark each statement true or false on its own; for assertion-reason, test A, then R, then whether R explains A.

Key takeaways

  • Mark each statement independently before looking at the options.
  • In assertion-reason items test A, then R, then the link.
  • In matching, remove the sure pairs first.
  • Selection acts on phenotypes; populations evolve, individuals do not.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Assertion: Whale flippers and bat wings are homologous. Reason: They have the same basic bone structure. Which is correct?

    1. A and R true, R explains A
    2. A and R true, R does not explain A
    3. A true, R false
    4. A false, R true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are mammalian forelimbs with the same bone plan, which is the definition of homology, so R explains A.

  2. 2. Which statement is correct?

    1. Evolution takes place in individuals
    2. Analogous organs have a common origin
    3. The fittest is always the largest
    4. Evolution occurs in populations
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Populations evolve as allele frequencies change. Individuals do not evolve, and fitness means reproductive success, not size.

  3. 3. In a population in equilibrium, 20 out of 500 individuals show a recessive trait. The frequency of the recessive allele is:

    1. 0.04
    2. 0.16
    3. 0.20
    4. 0.40
    Show answer

    Answer: C. q² = 20 ÷ 500 = 0.04, so q = 0.2.

  4. 4. Assertion: The wings of insects and birds are analogous. Reason: They have the same structure. The correct statement is:

    1. A true, R true and explains A
    2. A true, R false
    3. A false, R true
    4. Both false
    Show answer

    Answer: B. They are analogous because they have different structure and the same function. The reason is false.

  5. 5. Match Miller and Weismann with their work.

    1. Miller: mouse tails; Weismann: amino acids from gases
    2. Miller: peppered moth; Weismann: pea crosses
    3. Miller: amino acids from gases; Weismann: mouse tails
    4. Miller: fossil birds; Weismann: finch beaks
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Miller produced amino acids from methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour. Weismann cut off mice tails to test inheritance of acquired characters.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery