• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Which force is at work? Classifying evolutionary scenarios

Decide whether a scenario shows selection, drift, a bottleneck, the founder effect, gene flow or mutation, and answer the numerical questions attached to each.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A population evolves when its allele frequencies change. Four forces change allele frequencies: mutation, gene flow, genetic drift and natural selection; non-random mating changes only genotype frequencies. (NCERT's list of five factors is gene flow, drift, mutation, recombination and natural selection.) Exam questions describe a story and ask which force is at work. The approach is to find the key word in the story. This lesson gives the key words, a short table, and numerical questions on the forces that are easiest to calculate.

Key words and forces

Reading the story
Story containsForceWhat changes
A new allele appears by a change in DNAMutationAdds new alleles; very slow
Individuals join from another populationGene flow (migration)Allele frequencies of the two populations become more alike
Chance event, small populationGenetic driftFrequencies change at random; alleles can be lost
A few individuals start a new colonyFounder effect (a kind of drift)The new colony has a sample of the original alleles, and rare alleles may be common or absent
A disaster leaves a few survivorsBottleneck (a kind of drift)Variation falls; frequencies change by chance
Some genotypes leave more offspringNatural selectionFrequencies change in a direction that suits the environment
Individuals choose mates like themselves, or relativesNon-random matingGenotype frequencies change, but allele frequencies do not

Two points are tested often. First, drift is random, so it has no direction toward better adaptation, whereas selection has a direction. Second, non-random mating (such as mating between relatives) changes the proportion of homozygotes, but not the frequencies of the alleles themselves.

Worked example 1: gene flow

A population of 200 individuals has allele A at frequency 0.6. Fifty migrants, with A at frequency 0.2, join it and mix freely. What is the new frequency of A? Count the alleles in proportion. Total individuals = 200 + 50 = 250. A-weighted total = 200 × 0.6 + 50 × 0.2 = 120 + 10 = 130. New frequency = 130 ÷ 250 = 0.52. The frequency has moved from 0.6 towards the migrants' value of 0.2 without any selection.

Worked example 2: founder effect

A large population has a recessive allele a at a frequency of 0.01. Four individuals found a new colony on an island, and one of them is a heterozygous carrier Aa; the others are AA. The founders carry 8 alleles, one of which is a. The frequency of a in the colony is initially 1 ÷ 8 = 0.125, which is far higher than 0.01. If the colony is isolated, the disorder caused by aa will be much more common there than in the original population. This is the founder effect. Had the carrier not been among the founders, the allele would be absent from the colony.

Worked example 3: which force?

Identify the force. (a) A cyclone kills most of a small bird population and the survivors happen to be mostly short-winged. (b) An antibiotic kills all but a few bacteria with a resistance gene. (c) Plants of a field cross with pollen from a distant field. Answers: (a) a bottleneck, since the survival was by chance and not due to the wing length. (b) Natural selection, since survival depends on a gene that suits the environment. (c) Gene flow.

The question about size

Drift is strong in small populations and weak in large ones. If a population is large, chance fluctuations average out. Selection works in either size, but in a very small population drift can overpower weak selection.

Chance in a small group: drift. A few founders: founder effect. Survivors of a disaster: bottleneck. Migrants: gene flow. Fitter genotypes breed more: selection.

Key takeaways

  • Founder effect and bottleneck are two forms of genetic drift.
  • Gene flow makes populations more alike; drift makes them differ by chance.
  • Non-random mating changes genotype frequencies but not allele frequencies.
  • New frequency after migration = weighted average of the two populations.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A population of 200 with p = 0.6 receives 50 migrants with p = 0.2. The new p is:

    1. 0.40
    2. 0.52
    3. 0.60
    4. 0.80
    Show answer

    Answer: B. p = (200 × 0.6 + 50 × 0.2) ÷ 250 = (120 + 10) ÷ 250 = 0.52.

  2. 2. A small group founds a colony on an island and carries a rare allele at high frequency. This is:

    1. Selection
    2. Mutation pressure
    3. Gene flow
    4. Founder effect
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The founders carry a chance sample of the alleles of the parent population, so a rare allele can become common. This is the founder effect, a form of drift.

  3. 3. Mating only between close relatives mainly changes:

    1. Allele frequencies in the gene pool
    2. The mutation rate per generation
    3. Proportions of homozygous genotypes
    4. The number of migrants arriving
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Inbreeding raises the proportion of homozygotes without changing allele frequencies.

  4. 4. Which of these is a bottleneck?

    1. A cyclone leaves a few random survivors
    2. A few birds start a new island colony
    3. Insecticide kills susceptible insects
    4. Seeds blow in from a distant field
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A bottleneck is a sharp fall in population size by a chance event. A few birds starting a new island colony is a founder effect, insecticide killing susceptible insects is selection, and seeds blowing in from a distant field is gene flow.

  5. 5. Drift has the greatest effect on allele frequencies in:

    1. A very large population
    2. A population with many migrants
    3. A very small population
    4. A population under strong selection
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In small populations chance changes are large compared with the population size, so allele frequencies can change a lot or be lost.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery