- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Origin of life: theories, experiments and traps
Separate the theories of the origin of life, read Miller's experiment correctly and handle assertion-reason questions on early life.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the origin of life look easy but are full of traps. Options mix up theories that sound alike, assertion-reason pairs pair a true statement with a false reason, and one wrong word, such as 'oxygen' in a list of early gases, decides the answer. This lesson gives you a quick map of the theories, the exact facts of Miller's experiment, and a method for assertion-reason questions that you can use throughout the course.
The theories at a glance
| Theory | Core claim | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Special creation | All living forms were created as they are and have not changed | Not supported by evidence |
| Spontaneous generation | Life arises suddenly from non-living matter | Disproved by Redi and Pasteur |
| Panspermia | Spores or units of life came to Earth from outer space | Moves the question elsewhere; not a full explanation |
| Biogenesis | Life comes only from pre-existing life | Accepted for life today |
| Chemical evolution | First life arose slowly from non-living molecules | Oparin–Haldane; widely accepted |
A speed method: look for the key word. 'Suddenly from non-living' signals spontaneous generation; 'from outer space' or 'spores' signals panspermia; 'only from pre-existing life' signals biogenesis; 'slowly from inorganic or organic molecules' signals chemical evolution.
Chemical evolution, step by step
Oparin and Haldane proposed that the early Earth's atmosphere was reducing, with no free oxygen, and contained gases such as methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour. Energy from lightning, ultraviolet radiation and volcanic heat drove reactions that formed simple organic molecules: amino acids, sugars and nitrogen bases. These accumulated in the seas, joined into larger molecules such as proteins and nucleic acids, and became enclosed in droplets. Oparin called such colloidal droplets coacervates; Sidney Fox later made protein-like droplets called microspheres. Such structures are thought to resemble the forerunners of cells.
The first cells are thought to have been simple, anaerobic and dependent on ready-made organic food. Later, photosynthetic organisms such as cyanobacteria appeared, and the oxygen they released slowly built up in the atmosphere, changing it from reducing to oxidising. Note the trap: oxygen came after life, from photosynthesis, not before it.
Worked example 1: what Miller did and did not show
In 1953 Miller passed electric sparks through methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour in a closed apparatus and later found amino acids in the liquid. Use this to judge three statements. Statement 1, 'Miller made living cells': false, only molecules formed. Statement 2, 'Miller's mixture contained oxygen': false, the point was an oxygen-free atmosphere. Statement 3, 'Miller showed that organic molecules can form from inorganic gases with energy': true. In an exam, two of four options are usually versions of statements 1 and 2.
The assertion-reason method
- Step 1: decide whether the assertion (A) is true on its own.
- Step 2: decide whether the reason (R) is true on its own.
- Step 3: only if both are true, ask whether R actually explains A.
- Step 4: choose: both true and R explains A; both true but R does not explain A; A true, R false; A false, R true (or both false).
Worked example 2: an assertion-reason question
Assertion: Miller's experiment supports chemical evolution. Reason: Miller obtained living cells in his apparatus. Step 1: the assertion is true, because amino acids formed from simple gases. Step 2: the reason is false, because no cell formed. Step 3 is not needed. Answer: A is true but R is false. A second pair: Assertion, the early atmosphere had no free oxygen; Reason, oxygen was later added by photosynthetic organisms. Both are true, but the reason explains why oxygen appeared later, not why it was absent at first, so R is not the explanation of A.
A final trap concerns Pasteur and Miller. Pasteur showed that life does not arise from non-living matter under present conditions, while Miller showed that organic molecules could form under early-Earth conditions. The two results do not contradict each other. Today the atmosphere contains oxygen and the Earth is full of microbes that would consume any newly formed organic molecules, so chemical evolution cannot repeat itself now. An option claiming that Miller disproved Pasteur, or the reverse, is wrong.
Early Earth: reducing atmosphere, no free oxygen. Miller: sparks in methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour gave amino acids, not life. Oxygen came later, from photosynthesis.
Key takeaways
- Match the theory to its key word: suddenly, outer space, pre-existing life, slowly from molecules.
- Coacervates (Oparin) and microspheres (Fox) are proposed forerunners of cells.
- The first cells were probably anaerobic; atmospheric oxygen came from photosynthesis.
- In assertion-reason questions, test A and R separately before linking them.
Check your understanding
-
1. The theory that life reached Earth as spores from outer space is called:
- Panspermia
- Biogenesis
- Special creation
- Spontaneous generation
Show answer
Answer: A. Panspermia proposes that units of life (spores) came from outer space. It does not explain how life began in the first place.
-
2. Assertion: Miller's experiment supports chemical evolution. Reason: Miller obtained living cells in his apparatus. Choose the correct option.
- Both are true and the reason explains the assertion
- The assertion is true but the reason is false
- Both are true but the reason does not explain the assertion
- Both are false
Show answer
Answer: B. Miller produced amino acids from simple gases, which supports chemical evolution, so the assertion is true. No living cells formed, so the reason is false.
-
3. Which of these was NOT part of the gas mixture in Miller's experiment?
- Methane
- Ammonia
- Oxygen
- Hydrogen
Show answer
Answer: C. Miller copied a reducing, oxygen-free early atmosphere: methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour. Oxygen was deliberately absent.
-
4. Oparin's term for colloidal droplets of organic molecules that may have been forerunners of cells is:
- Microspheres
- Chromosomes
- Spores
- Coacervates
Show answer
Answer: D. Oparin called these droplets coacervates. Microspheres are the protein-like droplets later made by Sidney Fox.
-
5. Free oxygen in Earth's atmosphere came mainly from:
- The sparks in early lightning
- Breakdown of ammonia
- Photosynthesis by early organisms such as cyanobacteria
- Volcanic eruptions on the early Earth
Show answer
Answer: C. The early atmosphere had no free oxygen. Photosynthetic organisms such as cyanobacteria released oxygen, which slowly built up after life began.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.