• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ranking and identification questions: which solution has the highest or lowest...

Rank solutions by freezing point, boiling point, vapour pressure and osmotic pressure by comparing i × concentration, find isotonic pairs and identify an unknown electrolyte from its van't Hoff factor.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many exam questions on colligative properties need no calculator at all. They ask which of four solutions has the lowest freezing point, which pair is isotonic, or which formula fits a measured effect. The one tool for all of them is the effective concentration, i × m (or i × C for osmotic pressure). This lesson sets out the tool, applies it in four question patterns and warns about the one place where the shortcut fails: weak electrolytes.

The ranking tool

For each solution multiply the number of particles per formula unit (i, assuming complete dissociation of strong electrolytes) by the concentration. Compare the products. The larger the product, the greater the lowering of freezing point, the greater the raising of boiling point, the greater the osmotic pressure and the lower the vapour pressure. Use molality for freezing and boiling points, and molarity (at one temperature) for osmotic pressure.

Particles per formula unit
SoluteTypical i (complete dissociation)Reason
Glucose, urea, sucrose1Molecules do not split
NaCl, KCl, MgSO42Two ions
CaCl2, K2SO43Three ions
AlCl34Four ions
Al2(SO4)35Five ions

Pattern 1: rank unlike concentrations

Which has the highest boiling point: 0.10 m glucose, 0.07 m NaCl, 0.05 m K2SO4 or 0.04 m AlCl3? Effective values: 0.10 × 1 = 0.10; 0.07 × 2 = 0.14; 0.05 × 3 = 0.15; 0.04 × 4 = 0.16. AlCl3 has the largest value, so the highest boiling point. The same solution has the lowest freezing point and the lowest vapour pressure, and glucose has the highest vapour pressure.

Pattern 2: equal effects from different solutes

Two solutions with the same effective value have the same boiling point, freezing point and vapour pressure. For example 0.08 m NaCl (0.16) and 0.04 m AlCl3 (0.16) have identical colligative properties. If a question lists both and asks which has the higher boiling point, the correct answer is that they are equal.

Pattern 3: isotonic pairs

Which solution is isotonic with 0.06 M Al2(SO4)3 at the same temperature? The effective value of the reference is 0.06 × 5 = 0.30. Compare 0.1 M NaCl (0.2), 0.1 M CaCl2 (0.3), 0.1 M glucose (0.1) and 0.2 M NaCl (0.4). Only 0.1 M CaCl2 matches, so it is isotonic.

Pattern 4: identify the solute from the effect

A 0.10 m aqueous solution freezes with ΔTf = 0.558 K (Kf = 1.86). Then i = 0.558 ÷ (1.86 × 0.10) = 3.0. Of glucose, NaCl, K2SO4 and Al2(SO4)3 (i = 1, 2, 3, 5), only K2SO4 fits (CaCl2 would fit equally if offered). The method: divide the measured effect by the effect expected for one particle per formula unit, and match the result to the number of ions.

Where the shortcut fails: weak electrolytes

A weak electrolyte such as ethanoic (acetic) acid dissociates only slightly, so its i lies just above 1, far below the full-dissociation value of 2. In a ranking question, a 0.1 m solution of acetic acid goes between 0.1 m glucose and 0.1 m NaCl: its freezing point is slightly lower than glucose and much higher than NaCl. In concentrated solutions even strong electrolytes fall short of full dissociation, but entrance-level questions use the table values unless the data say otherwise.

Effective concentration = i × m. Highest effective value: lowest freezing point, highest boiling point, lowest vapour pressure. Equal effective values: equal properties. Weak electrolytes: i between 1 and the full value.

Key takeaways

  • Rank by i × m (freezing, boiling, vapour pressure) or i × C (osmotic pressure).
  • Equal i × m means equal colligative properties.
  • Isotonic means equal i × C at the same temperature.
  • Divide a measured effect by the single-particle effect to get i, then match it to a formula.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which solution has the highest boiling point: 0.10 m glucose, 0.07 m NaCl, 0.05 m K2SO4 or 0.04 m AlCl3 (all strong electrolytes fully dissociated)?

    1. 0.10 m glucose
    2. 0.07 m NaCl
    3. 0.05 m K2SO4
    4. 0.04 m AlCl3
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Effective values: 0.10, 0.14, 0.15 and 0.16. AlCl3 (i = 4) gives 0.16, the highest.

  2. 2. Among the same four solutions, which has the highest vapour pressure?

    1. 0.10 m glucose
    2. 0.07 m NaCl
    3. 0.05 m K2SO4
    4. 0.04 m AlCl3
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Vapour pressure is lowered most by the solution with the most particles. Glucose has the fewest (0.10), so its vapour pressure is the highest.

  3. 3. Which solution is isotonic with 0.06 M Al2(SO4)3 (complete dissociation)?

    1. 0.1 M NaCl
    2. 0.1 M glucose
    3. 0.2 M NaCl
    4. 0.1 M CaCl2
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 0.06 M Al2(SO4)3 has effective value 0.30, as does 0.1 M CaCl2 (3 × 0.1). The others give 0.2, 0.1 and 0.4.

  4. 4. A 0.10 m aqueous solution shows ΔTf = 0.558 K (Kf = 1.86 K kg/mol). The solute could be:

    1. Glucose
    2. NaCl
    3. K2SO4
    4. Al2(SO4)3
    Show answer

    Answer: C. i = 0.558 ÷ 0.186 = 3.0, which matches a salt giving three ions, such as K2SO4.

  5. 5. Which statement about 0.1 m aqueous solutions is correct?

    1. Acetic acid freezes at a lower temperature than NaCl
    2. Acetic acid freezes lower than glucose but higher than NaCl
    3. Acetic acid freezes at the same temperature as glucose
    4. Acetic acid freezes higher than glucose
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Acetic acid is a weak electrolyte; its i is slightly above 1, so it lowers the freezing point a little more than glucose (i = 1) and much less than NaCl (i = 2).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery