- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Case law on the amending power: timeline and matching
Match the leading cases on the amending power to their holdings and years, and solve chronology and matching questions quickly.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Case-law questions come in three shapes: match the case to its holding, arrange cases in order, or pick the case that struck down a particular amendment. All three become easy with one timeline and a one-line summary per case.
The timeline
| Year | Case | Holding |
|---|---|---|
| 1951 | Shankari Prasad | Amending power under Article 368 includes Fundamental Rights |
| 1965 | Sajjan Singh | Followed Shankari Prasad |
| 1967 | Golak Nath | Parliament cannot abridge Fundamental Rights by amendment (6:5, eleven judges) |
| 1973 | Kesavananda Bharati | Any part may be amended, but not the basic structure (7:6, thirteen judges) |
| 1975 | Indira Nehru Gandhi v Raj Narain | Struck down clause (4) of Article 329A (39th Amendment); free and fair elections are basic |
| 1980 | Minerva Mills | Struck down clauses (4) and (5) of Article 368; limited amending power and FR-DPSP balance are basic |
| 1981 | Waman Rao | Basic structure applies to amendments made after 24 April 1973 |
| 1992 | Kihoto Hollohan | Paragraph 7 of the Tenth Schedule invalid for want of ratification |
| 1994 | S.R. Bommai | Federalism and secularism are basic features |
| 1997 | L. Chandra Kumar | Judicial review by High Courts and the Supreme Court is basic; tribunals cannot oust it |
| 2007 | I.R. Coelho | Ninth Schedule laws added after 24 April 1973 are open to basic structure review |
Anchors that make the order stick
Fix two anchor dates. First, 24 April 1973, the day Kesavananda Bharati was decided; Waman Rao and I.R. Coelho both use it as the cut-off. Second, the 42nd Amendment (1976), which tried to put amendments beyond judicial review by adding clauses (4) and (5) to Article 368; Minerva Mills (1980) struck those clauses down. Everything before 1973 is the 'can Parliament amend Fundamental Rights' debate; everything after is about what the basic structure contains.
Anchor: 24 April 1973 (Kesavananda). Before it: whether Fundamental Rights can be amended. After it: what the basic structure includes and which amendments break it.
Worked example 1
Which case struck down the provision of the 42nd Amendment that said no amendment could be questioned in any court? The provision is Article 368(4), with (5) declaring no limit on the amending power. These were inserted in 1976 and struck down in Minerva Mills (1980). Trap options will include Kesavananda (1973) - impossible, since it came before the 42nd Amendment.
Worked example 2
Arrange: (a) L. Chandra Kumar, (b) Waman Rao, (c) Indira Nehru Gandhi v Raj Narain, (d) Kihoto Hollohan. Step 1: Indira Gandhi case, 1975. Step 2: Waman Rao, 1981. Step 3: Kihoto Hollohan, 1992. Step 4: L. Chandra Kumar, 1997. Order: c, b, d, a. A time-saving check: any case using the basic structure must come after 1973, and Minerva Mills must come after 1976.
Using logic to eliminate options
Many case questions can be solved even when memory is shaky. A judgment cannot strike down an amendment passed after it, so any option pairing Kesavananda (1973) with a provision of the 42nd Amendment (1976) is wrong. A case that applies the basic structure must come after Kesavananda, so Golak Nath (1967) can never be the answer to a basic-structure question. A cut-off date of 24 April 1973 points to Waman Rao or I.R. Coelho, depending on whether the question is about amendments in general or Ninth Schedule laws in particular. And a holding about ratification - an amendment failing because the states were not asked - points to Kihoto Hollohan, the case on the Tenth Schedule. Combine these checks with the timeline and most four-option questions reduce to one choice quickly.
Key takeaways: memorise one line per case and the two anchors (24 April 1973 and the 42nd Amendment of 1976); use logic - a case cannot strike down an amendment made after it - to eliminate options.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which case held that Ninth Schedule laws added after 24 April 1973 can be tested against the basic structure?
- Kesavananda Bharati
- Minerva Mills
- I.R. Coelho
- Golak Nath
Show answer
Answer: C. I.R. Coelho (2007), a nine-judge bench, held so; Waman Rao had set the same cut-off date for amendments.
-
2. Clause (4) of Article 329A, inserted by the 39th Amendment, was struck down in
- Indira Nehru Gandhi v Raj Narain
- Kihoto Hollohan
- S.R. Bommai
- Sajjan Singh
Show answer
Answer: A. The 1975 judgment held that clause, which shielded a particular election from challenge, violated free and fair elections.
-
3. Paragraph 7 of the Tenth Schedule was held invalid in Kihoto Hollohan because
- It violated secularism
- It was not ratified by the states though it affected the courts' jurisdiction
- It was passed by a simple majority
- The President had withheld assent
Show answer
Answer: B. Paragraph 7 barred courts' jurisdiction, which needed ratification under the proviso to Article 368(2); it was not ratified.
-
4. Arrange in order: (1) Waman Rao (2) Minerva Mills (3) S.R. Bommai (4) Golak Nath
- 4, 2, 3, 1
- 2, 4, 1, 3
- 4, 1, 2, 3
- 4, 2, 1, 3
Show answer
Answer: D. Golak Nath 1967, Minerva Mills 1980, Waman Rao 1981, S.R. Bommai 1994.
-
5. Which case held that the power of judicial review of High Courts and the Supreme Court cannot be excluded by tribunals?
- L. Chandra Kumar
- Shankari Prasad
- Waman Rao
- Golak Nath
Show answer
Answer: A. L. Chandra Kumar v Union of India (1997).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.