- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Which majority? Removals, impeachment, emergencies and resolutions
Practise choosing the right kind of majority for removals, impeachment and emergency approvals, and compute the minimum yes votes with practice numbers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on majorities often move beyond amendments. They ask what is needed to remove a judge, impeach the President, remove the Speaker or approve an emergency. The skill is to read the Article's exact words, because the base (total membership, all the then members, or present and voting) changes the answer. All numbers in this lesson are illustrative.
Three bases for counting
- Total membership: the full strength of the House; used in Article 61 and as one part of the Article 368 test.
- All the then members (the effective majority): the members in office on the day, after deducting vacancies; used for the removal of the Vice-President (Article 67) and of the Speaker (Article 94).
- Present and voting: only those who vote; abstainers do not count.
| Action | Article | Majority and extra points |
|---|---|---|
| Impeach the President | 61 | Two-thirds of the total membership of the House; 14 days' notice signed by at least one-fourth of the members |
| Remove a judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court | 124(4), 217 | In each House: majority of total membership and two-thirds of present and voting; same session |
| Remove the Vice-President | 67(b) | Rajya Sabha resolution by a majority of all the then members, agreed to by the Lok Sabha by a simple majority; 14 days' notice |
| Remove the Speaker | 94(c) | Majority of all the then members of the Lok Sabha; 14 days' notice |
| Approve a national emergency | 352 | Each House within one month, by a majority of total membership and two-thirds of present and voting |
| Approve President's rule | 356 | Both Houses within two months, by simple majority |
| Rajya Sabha resolution on State List or all-India services | 249, 312 | Two-thirds of present and voting |
Read the base before the fraction: total membership, all the then members, or present and voting.
Worked example 1: removal of a judge
A House has a total membership of 540. On the day, 400 members are present and voting. What is the minimum number of yes votes for a motion to remove a judge? Step 1: A = more than half of 540 = 271. Step 2: B = two-thirds of 400 = 266.67, which rounds up to 267. Step 3: take the larger, 271. Answer: 271.
Worked example 2: removal of the Speaker
A House has a total membership of 240, and 8 seats are vacant. What is the minimum number of yes votes to remove the Speaker? Step 1: all the then members = 240 - 8 = 232. Step 2: a majority of 232 means more than 116, so 117. Answer: 117. Note that with no vacancies the figure would be 121, so vacancies lower the requirement under the 'all the then members' test.
Worked example 3: impeachment
In a House of total membership 240, how many votes are needed to pass a charge of impeachment of the President? Step 1: the test is two-thirds of the total membership. Step 2: two-thirds of 240 = 160 exactly. Answer: 160. It does not matter how many are present.
Worked example 4: emergency
A House has a total membership of 540 and 360 are present and voting. What is the minimum yes vote to approve a national emergency? Step 1: A = 271. Step 2: B = two-thirds of 360 = 240. Step 3: the larger is 271. Answer: 271. Here the total-membership condition decides because attendance is thin.
Traps
- Impeachment under Article 61 uses total membership alone; there is no second condition.
- The Vice-President is removed by a resolution of the Rajya Sabha agreed to by the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha uses all the then members; this is not a special majority.
- President's rule (Article 356) needs only a simple majority, but a national emergency (Article 352) needs the special majority.
Key takeaways: identify the base first; Article 61 is two-thirds of total membership; judges need a majority of total membership and two-thirds of present and voting; the Vice-President and Speaker go by all the then members; Article 352 needs the special majority and Article 356 a simple majority.
Check your understanding
-
1. The impeachment of the President under Article 61 needs a resolution passed by
- A majority of members present and voting
- Two-thirds of the total membership of the House
- A majority of all the then members
- Three-fourths of present and voting
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 61 requires two-thirds of the total membership of the House.
-
2. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha can be removed by a resolution passed by
- Two-thirds of the total membership
- A joint sitting of both Houses
- Two-thirds of present and voting
- A majority of all the then members
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 94 requires a majority of all the then members of the House.
-
3. In a House with total membership 240, the minimum yes votes for an impeachment charge is
- 160
- 120
- 121
- 180
Show answer
Answer: A. Two-thirds of 240 is 160, counted on the total membership.
-
4. A national emergency proclamation must be approved within
- Two months
- One month
- Three months
- Six months
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 352 requires approval by both Houses within one month, by the special majority. Two months is the period for Article 356.
-
5. Total membership 300; 240 present and voting. Minimum yes votes for removal of a judge is
- 151
- 180
- 160
- 200
Show answer
Answer: C. A = more than half of 300 = 151. B = two-thirds of 240 = 160. The larger is 160, so 160 yes votes are needed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.