- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Sorting provisions by procedure: practice and traps
Place any provision in the right amendment category quickly and avoid the classic traps such as the Vice-President's election and the Fifth and Sixth Schedules.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The most common amendment question gives a list of provisions and asks which need ratification by the states, or which can be changed by a simple majority. The trick is not to memorise a hundred items but to learn the short ratification list exactly, learn the main simple-majority items, and put everything else in the special-majority middle.
The ratification list (proviso to Article 368(2))
- Election of the President (Articles 54 and 55).
- Extent of the executive power of the Union and of the states (Articles 73 and 162).
- High Courts for Union Territories (Article 241) and the GST Council (Article 279A).
- The Union judiciary (Supreme Court) and the High Courts in the states.
- Distribution of legislative powers between the Union and the states (Part XI, Chapter I).
- Any of the lists in the Seventh Schedule.
- Representation of states in Parliament (the Fourth Schedule allocates Rajya Sabha seats).
- Article 368 itself.
The main simple-majority items
These are changed by ordinary law and are expressly or in effect outside Article 368: admission or establishment of new states and formation of new states and alteration of areas, boundaries or names (Articles 2, 3, 4); abolition or creation of Legislative Councils (Article 169); local legislatures or councils of ministers for certain Union Territories (Article 239A); administration of Scheduled Areas and Tribal Areas (Fifth Schedule, paragraph 7; Sixth Schedule, paragraph 21); citizenship (Article 11); emoluments in the Second Schedule; quorum and rules of procedure; use of English in Parliament; the number of puisne judges of the Supreme Court; delimitation of constituencies; and elections to Parliament and state legislatures.
Five classic traps
| Provision | Looks like | Actually needs |
|---|---|---|
| Election of the Vice-President (Art 66) | Ratification, like the President | Special majority only - Art 66 is not in the proviso |
| Number of Supreme Court judges | Ratification (Supreme Court) | Simple majority law - Art 124(1) says 'until Parliament by law prescribes' |
| Fifth and Sixth Schedules | Special majority (they are Schedules) | Simple majority - deemed not amendments |
| Fundamental Rights | Ratification (very important) | Special majority only |
| Fourth Schedule | Special majority (just a seat table) | Ratification - representation of states in Parliament |
Ratification is for the federal bargain: President's election, executive power, courts, the lists and legislative powers, states' seats in Parliament, and Article 368. Importance alone does not trigger it.
Worked example 1
Which of these need state ratification: (1) Article 66, (2) Article 55, (3) Article 21, (4) Seventh Schedule List III? Work through: (1) Vice-President's election - not in the proviso, so no. (2) Method of electing the President - yes. (3) A Fundamental Right - special majority only, so no. (4) A Seventh Schedule list - yes. Answer: 2 and 4 only.
Worked example 2
Which can be done by a simple majority: (1) increasing the number of Supreme Court judges, (2) changing the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court in a way that affects its constitutional position, (3) amending paragraph rules of the Sixth Schedule? (1) Yes, Parliament prescribes the number by law. (2) No, the Supreme Court provisions (Part V, Chapter IV) need special majority and ratification. (3) Yes, paragraph 21 of the Sixth Schedule says such laws are not amendments under Article 368. Answer: 1 and 3. The lesson: the subject (Supreme Court) can appear in two categories depending on which provision is touched.
A three-step routine for the exam hall
Step 1: ask whether the provision is one Parliament can change by ordinary law - look for the words until Parliament by law provides, or for the Articles and Schedules that say a change is not deemed an amendment (Articles 4, 169, 239A, Fifth Schedule paragraph 7, Sixth Schedule paragraph 21). If yes, it is simple majority. Step 2: if not, ask whether it is on the ratification list - the President's election, executive power of the Union and states, the courts, Article 241, Article 279A, legislative relations, the Seventh Schedule lists, states' representation in Parliament, or Article 368 itself. If yes, it needs special majority plus half the states. Step 3: everything else, including Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles, Fundamental Duties, the Vice-President's election and most of Parliament's own structure, needs a special majority only. Running these three steps in order prevents the commonest error, which is to put an important-sounding provision into the ratification list simply because it feels important.
Key takeaways: learn the ratification list exactly, learn the main simple-majority items, and default the rest to special majority; watch for Article 66, the number of judges, the Fifth and Sixth Schedules, Fundamental Rights and the Fourth Schedule.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these needs ratification by half the states?
- Election of the Vice-President
- Election of the President
- Fundamental Rights
- Directive Principles
Show answer
Answer: B. Articles 54 and 55 are in the proviso to Article 368(2); Article 66 (Vice-President) is not.
-
2. The Sixth Schedule can be amended by
- Special majority with ratification
- Special majority only
- A simple majority law of Parliament
- The Governor of the state concerned
Show answer
Answer: C. Paragraph 21 of the Sixth Schedule lets Parliament amend it by law; such a law is not deemed an amendment under Article 368.
-
3. Changing the allocation of Rajya Sabha seats among states requires
- Simple majority
- Special majority only
- A Rajya Sabha resolution only
- Special majority and ratification by half the states
Show answer
Answer: D. The Fourth Schedule concerns representation of states in Parliament, which is in the ratification list.
-
4. Increasing the number of judges of the Supreme Court requires
- An ordinary law of Parliament
- Special majority and ratification
- Special majority only
- A Presidential order without Parliament
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 124(1) lets Parliament prescribe the number of judges by law.
-
5. Which pair is correctly matched with its procedure?
- Article 368 itself - special majority only
- Article 169 - ratification by states
- Article 279A - special majority with ratification
- Article 21 - simple majority
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 279A (GST Council) is in the proviso; Article 368 needs ratification, Article 169 needs simple majority, and Article 21 needs special majority.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.