- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Resolutions and the states' role: Articles 3, 169, 249, 252 and ratification
Distinguish the different ways in which state legislatures and the Rajya Sabha take part in lawmaking and amendment, and practise the numbers for each.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the role of the states mix several Articles that look similar. Each Article gives a different role to a state legislature or to the Rajya Sabha. This lesson sets them in a table, adds the numbers and gives practice in telling them apart. All numbers are illustrative.
| Article | Who acts | Majority | Effect | An Article 368 amendment? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | State legislature gives its views when a bill affects its state | Not binding | Parliament may form states or change boundaries and names by simple majority | No (Article 4) |
| 169 | State Assembly passes a resolution | Majority of total membership and two-thirds of present and voting | Parliament may create or abolish the Legislative Council by law | No |
| 249 | Rajya Sabha passes a resolution | Two-thirds of present and voting | Parliament may legislate on a State List subject for up to one year at a time | No |
| 252 | Legislatures of two or more states pass resolutions | Resolutions of the Houses of those states | Parliament may legislate for those states; others may adopt later | No |
| 368 proviso | Legislatures of at least half of the states | Simple majority in each | Federal amendments become ready for assent | Yes |
Three points are the most tested. First, in Article 3 the state's views are only advisory, and Parliament is not bound by them. Second, in Article 252 an Act made at the request of states can be amended or repealed only by Parliament, not by the states, though other states may adopt it by passing a resolution. Third, a law under Article 249 lasts for no more than one year at a time, and ceases six months after the resolution lapses.
Article 3: advisory views. Article 169: state resolution, then Parliament's law. Article 249: Rajya Sabha two-thirds. Article 252: states ask, Parliament makes the law.
Worked example 1: Article 169
A state Assembly has a total membership of 150. On the day, 120 members are present and voting. What is the minimum yes vote for the resolution to create a Legislative Council? Step 1: A = more than half of 150 = 76. Step 2: B = two-thirds of 120 = 80. Step 3: the larger is 80. Answer: 80. Then Parliament passes a law by a simple majority.
Worked example 2: Article 249
In the Rajya Sabha, 150 members are present and voting. How many yes votes are needed for a resolution under Article 249? Step 1: two-thirds of 150 = 100. Step 2: no condition on total membership. Answer: 100.
Worked example 3: ratification
For practice, suppose there are 28 states and an amendment on the Seventh Schedule has passed both Houses. How many states must ratify? Step 1: half of 28 = 14. Step 2: 'not less than one-half' includes 14. Answer: 14. For 29 states the answer would be 15.
Worked example 4: telling the Articles apart
Statement: 'A resolution of two state legislatures asking Parliament to legislate on a State List subject is an amendment under Article 368.' Step 1: this is Article 252. Step 2: Article 252 gives Parliament a power to legislate; it does not amend the Constitution. Answer: false.
Common traps
- A state's views under Article 3 are not a veto.
- The Article 169 resolution needs the special majority of the Assembly, but the law that follows needs only a simple majority.
- Article 249 is a Rajya Sabha power and has no ratification by states.
- Ratification under Article 368 is by simple majority, not by two-thirds.
Key takeaways: compare the Articles by who acts, what majority and what follows; Article 3 views are advisory; Article 169 needs the special majority in the Assembly and then a law; Article 249 needs two-thirds of the Rajya Sabha present and voting; Article 252 needs resolutions from at least two states; ratification under Article 368 is by simple majority.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under Article 3, the views of the state legislature on a bill affecting its area are
- Binding on Parliament
- Advisory only
- Required to be two-thirds
- Required to be unanimous
Show answer
Answer: B. Parliament asks for the views but is not bound by them.
-
2. A resolution under Article 249 must be passed by
- Two-thirds of present and voting in the Rajya Sabha
- A simple majority of the Lok Sabha
- Half of the state legislatures
- A majority of total membership in both Houses
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 249 needs a Rajya Sabha resolution by two-thirds of the members present and voting.
-
3. Assembly total membership 150; 120 present and voting. Minimum yes votes for a resolution under Article 169
- 76
- 80
- 100
- 120
Show answer
Answer: B. A = 76; B = two-thirds of 120 = 80; the larger is 80.
-
4. Which Article lets Parliament legislate for states that ask it to?
- Article 3
- Article 169
- Article 252
- Article 312
Show answer
Answer: C. Under Article 252, resolutions of two or more state legislatures let Parliament legislate for them.
-
5. With 28 states, ratification of a federal amendment needs at least
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 21
Show answer
Answer: B. Half of 28 is 14.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.