- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Counting votes: majority calculations for amendments
Calculate the minimum votes needed under different kinds of majority, including Article 368's two-part test, and avoid mixing them up under time pressure.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some questions give you numbers - total strength, members present, abstentions - and ask whether a bill or resolution passed. These are quick marks if you know exactly what each type of majority counts. All numbers in this lesson are illustrative practice numbers, not the actual strength of any House.
Four kinds of majority
| Kind | What it counts | Where used (examples) |
|---|---|---|
| Simple | More than half of members present and voting | Ordinary bills; Article 356 approval; state ratification of amendments |
| Absolute | More than half of the total membership | Part (a) of the Article 368 special majority |
| Two-thirds of present and voting | At least two-thirds of those who vote | Article 249 and Article 312 Rajya Sabha resolutions |
| Article 368 special | Absolute majority AND two-thirds of present and voting, in each House | Constitution Amendment Bills; approval of a national emergency |
Members who are present but abstain are not 'voting'. They count towards neither the 'yes' nor the base of a 'present and voting' fraction. But they do not reduce the total membership, which is fixed by the House's strength.
The speed method for Article 368
- Compute A = the smallest whole number greater than half of the total membership.
- Compute B = two-thirds of members present and voting, rounded up to a whole number.
- The minimum 'yes' vote is the larger of A and B.
- If voting is thin, A usually decides; if attendance is high, B usually decides.
Minimum yes votes under Article 368 = max(more than half of total membership, two-thirds of present and voting, rounded up).
Worked example 1
Total membership 540. Present and voting 420. A: half of 540 is 270, so A = 271. B: two-thirds of 420 = 280. Answer: 280. Now suppose only 390 vote. B = 260, A = 271, so the answer becomes 271: the total-membership condition now decides. Remember to recompute both each time.
Worked example 2
Total membership 240. 200 present, of whom 17 abstain, so 183 vote. 'Yes' votes are 121 and 'no' votes 62. Did an Article 368 bill pass? A = 121 (half of 240 is 120). B = two-thirds of 183 = 122. The bill needs 122; it got 121, so it fails by one vote even though it has an absolute majority. If the same House were voting on an Article 249 resolution, the test is only B = 122, so that also fails. Check: 121/183 is about 66.1%, just below two-thirds.
Ratification arithmetic
'Not less than one-half of the states' means at least half; with an odd number of states, round up. For practice, with 29 states, half is 14.5, so 15 legislatures must ratify. With 28 states, 14 is enough. Each legislature itself votes by simple majority.
Common slips and how to avoid them
The first slip is rounding the wrong way. Two-thirds of 100 is 66.67, so 66 is not enough and 67 is the minimum; always round a fractional requirement up, never down. The second slip is treating 'majority of total membership' as half of the total: half of 240 is 120, but 120 is not a majority - 121 is. The third slip is using the number present instead of the number voting when some members abstain. The fourth is forgetting that the Article 368 test applies in each House separately: a bill can satisfy both conditions in the Lok Sabha and still fail in the Rajya Sabha. Write down A and B for each House before deciding.
Key takeaways: identify the type of majority before computing; abstainers drop out of 'present and voting'; under Article 368 compute both conditions and take the larger; round up fractions; 'one-half of states' rounds up when the number of states is odd.
Check your understanding
-
1. Total membership 500; present and voting 450. Minimum 'yes' votes for an amendment bill?
- 251
- 300
- 334
- 226
Show answer
Answer: B. A = 251; B = 2/3 × 450 = 300. The larger is 300.
-
2. Total membership 500; present and voting 330. Minimum 'yes' votes for an amendment bill?
- 220
- 166
- 251
- 330
Show answer
Answer: C. A = 251; B = 2/3 × 330 = 220. The larger is 251.
-
3. An Article 249 resolution: 150 present, 15 abstain. Minimum 'yes' votes?
- 90
- 100
- 76
- 101
Show answer
Answer: A. Present and voting = 135. Two-thirds of 135 = 90.
-
4. For practice, if there are 31 states, how many must ratify an amendment to the Seventh Schedule?
- 15
- 31
- 21
- 16
Show answer
Answer: D. Half of 31 is 15.5; 'not less than one-half' means at least 16.
-
5. Which statement is correct?
- Abstaining members count as 'no' votes
- Abstentions reduce the total membership
- Abstaining members are excluded from 'present and voting'
- Abstentions make the vote invalid
Show answer
Answer: C. Abstainers do not vote, so they are left out of 'present and voting'; total membership is unaffected.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.