- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
True or false rapid fire on the amendment procedure
Test eighteen statements about the amendment procedure, each with a one-line reason, so you can spot false statements quickly in the exam.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A quick way to prepare for statement-based questions is rapid fire: read a statement, decide true or false in ten seconds, and then check the reason. The statements below cover introduction, passing, ratification, assent and the role of the courts. Cover the right two columns of the table, answer each statement, then check yourself. Repeat until you are right every time.
| Statement | Verdict | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| An amendment bill may be introduced in the Rajya Sabha | True | Either House may introduce it |
| A state legislature may introduce an amendment bill | False | Only Parliament has the initiative |
| The President may refuse assent to an amendment bill | False | Article 368(2) says the President shall give assent |
| A joint sitting can resolve a disagreement on an amendment bill | False | Joint sittings are not allowed for amendment bills |
| State legislatures ratify by a special majority | False | A simple majority of each legislature is enough |
| There is a fixed time limit for states to ratify | False | The Constitution fixes none |
| Every amendment needs ratification by the states | False | Only the federal matters of the proviso do |
| An amendment bill needs the President's prior recommendation | False | No prior recommendation is needed |
| A private member can introduce an amendment bill | True | Any member may introduce it |
| Both Houses have equal power on an amendment bill | True | There is no joint sitting; each House must pass it |
| Absolute majority means more than half of the members present | False | It means more than half of the total membership |
| Members who abstain count as voting | False | Only those who vote are voting |
| An ordinance can amend the Constitution | False | An ordinance is not an amendment under Article 368 |
| Article 368 is in Part XX | True | Part XX contains only Article 368 |
| The basic structure doctrine is written in Article 368 | False | It is a doctrine of the Supreme Court |
| An amendment can be struck down for damaging the basic structure | True | Kesavananda Bharati (1973) and later cases |
| After Kesavananda, Fundamental Rights cannot be amended at all | False | They can be amended within the basic structure |
| The Fifth Schedule can be amended by a simple majority | True | Paragraph 7 says it is not an amendment under Article 368 |
How to use the table
Notice that the false statements fall into three families. First, initiative and procedure: only Parliament may introduce; there is no joint sitting; the President must assent. Second, ratification: the states ratify by simple majority, with no time limit, and only for federal matters. Third, majority words: absolute means total membership, and abstainers are not voting. When a statement uses an absolute word such as every, always or only, check it against these families first.
False families: wrong body, wrong majority, wrong scope. True families: either House, equal Houses, basic structure review.
Worked example 1
Statement: 'An amendment bill passed by the Lok Sabha and rejected by the Rajya Sabha becomes law after a joint sitting.' Step 1: joint sittings apply to ordinary bills only. Step 2: an amendment bill must pass each House separately by the special majority. Answer: false.
Worked example 2
Statement: 'Ratification by the legislatures of half of the states is required for amending the provisions on the election of the President.' Step 1: the election of the President is on the proviso list. Step 2: so half of the states must ratify, each by a simple majority. Answer: true.
Worked example 3
Consider: (1) The President may return an amendment bill for reconsideration. (2) Only a Minister may introduce an amendment bill. (3) States must ratify within six months. Step 1: (1) false, as the President must assent. Step 2: (2) false, as private members may introduce. Step 3: (3) false, as no time limit exists. Answer: none of the three is correct.
Key takeaways: only Parliament initiates; either House; separate passage by special majority; no joint sitting; assent is compulsory; states ratify by simple majority without a time limit and only for federal matters; abstainers are not voting; the basic structure is a judicial doctrine.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement is correct?
- The President may withhold assent from an amendment bill
- An amendment bill may be introduced in either House of Parliament
- A state legislature may introduce an amendment bill
- A joint sitting may pass an amendment bill
Show answer
Answer: B. Either House may introduce an amendment bill. The President must assent, only Parliament introduces, and a joint sitting is not available.
-
2. State legislatures ratify an amendment by
- A special majority of two-thirds
- A unanimous vote
- A simple majority
- A referendum
Show answer
Answer: C. Each legislature ratifies by a simple majority.
-
3. An absolute majority means more than half of
- The members present
- The members voting
- The members who abstain
- The total membership
Show answer
Answer: D. Absolute majority is counted on the total membership.
-
4. Which statement about an ordinance is correct?
- It cannot amend the Constitution
- It can amend the Fundamental Rights
- It can amend Article 368
- It needs ratification by the states
Show answer
Answer: A. An ordinance is issued under Article 123 and cannot amend the Constitution under Article 368.
-
5. Which is false?
- Article 368 is in Part XX
- The basic structure doctrine is a judicial doctrine
- The Fifth Schedule can be amended by a simple majority
- All amendments need ratification by half of the states
Show answer
Answer: D. Only amendments touching the federal matters in the proviso need ratification.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.