Revision notes

Amendment of the Constitution: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Sorting provisions by procedure: practice and traps

ProvisionLooks likeActually needs
Election of the Vice-President (Art 66)Ratification, like the PresidentSpecial majority only - Art 66 is not in the proviso
Number of Supreme Court judgesRatification (Supreme Court)Simple majority law - Art 124(1) says 'until Parliament by law prescribes'
Fifth and Sixth SchedulesSpecial majority (they are Schedules)Simple majority - deemed not amendments
Fundamental RightsRatification (very important)Special majority only
Fourth ScheduleSpecial majority (just a seat table)Ratification - representation of states in Parliament

Ratification is for the federal bargain: President's election, executive power, courts, the lists and legislative powers, states' seats in Parliament, and Article 368. Importance alone does not trigger it.

Key takeaways: learn the ratification list exactly, learn the main simple-majority items, and default the rest to special majority; watch for Article 66, the number of judges, the Fifth and Sixth Schedules, Fundamental Rights and the Fourth Schedule.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Counting votes: majority calculations for amendments

KindWhat it countsWhere used (examples)
SimpleMore than half of members present and votingOrdinary bills; Article 356 approval; state ratification of amendments
AbsoluteMore than half of the total membershipPart (a) of the Article 368 special majority
Two-thirds of present and votingAt least two-thirds of those who voteArticle 249 and Article 312 Rajya Sabha resolutions
Article 368 specialAbsolute majority AND two-thirds of present and voting, in each HouseConstitution Amendment Bills; approval of a national emergency

Minimum yes votes under Article 368 = max(more than half of total membership, two-thirds of present and voting, rounded up).

Key takeaways: identify the type of majority before computing; abstainers drop out of 'present and voting'; under Article 368 compute both conditions and take the larger; round up fractions; 'one-half of states' rounds up when the number of states is odd.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Procedure traps: amendment bills versus ordinary and money bills

PointOrdinary billMoney billConstitution Amendment Bill
Where introducedEither HouseLok Sabha onlyEither House
Who may introduceMinister or private memberMinister onlyMinister or private member
President's prior recommendationNot needed (generally)NeededNot needed
Deadlock between HousesJoint sitting possibleRajya Sabha can only delay up to 14 daysNo joint sitting; bill fails
MajoritySimpleSimpleSpecial (and ratification where required)
President's optionsAssent, withhold, or return onceAssent or withhold; cannot returnMust assent

Amendment bill: either House, anyone may introduce, no recommendation, no joint sitting, President must sign.

Key takeaways: use the comparison table; amendment bills are like ordinary bills on introduction (either House, any member) but unlike them on joint sittings and the President's role; ratification comes before assent; states never initiate amendments.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Case law on the amending power: timeline and matching

YearCaseHolding
1951Shankari PrasadAmending power under Article 368 includes Fundamental Rights
1965Sajjan SinghFollowed Shankari Prasad
1967Golak NathParliament cannot abridge Fundamental Rights by amendment (6:5, eleven judges)
1973Kesavananda BharatiAny part may be amended, but not the basic structure (7:6, thirteen judges)
1975Indira Nehru Gandhi v Raj NarainStruck down clause (4) of Article 329A (39th Amendment); free and fair elections are basic
1980Minerva MillsStruck down clauses (4) and (5) of Article 368; limited amending power and FR-DPSP balance are basic
1981Waman RaoBasic structure applies to amendments made after 24 April 1973
1992Kihoto HollohanParagraph 7 of the Tenth Schedule invalid for want of ratification
1994S.R. BommaiFederalism and secularism are basic features
1997L. Chandra KumarJudicial review by High Courts and the Supreme Court is basic; tribunals cannot oust it
2007I.R. CoelhoNinth Schedule laws added after 24 April 1973 are open to basic structure review

Anchor: 24 April 1973 (Kesavananda). Before it: whether Fundamental Rights can be amended. After it: what the basic structure includes and which amendments break it.

Key takeaways: memorise one line per case and the two anchors (24 April 1973 and the 42nd Amendment of 1976); use logic - a case cannot strike down an amendment made after it - to eliminate options.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Matching amendments to their changes

AmendmentChange
1st (1951)Ninth Schedule; Articles 31A and 31B; Article 15(4); new grounds in Article 19(2)
7th (1956)Reorganisation of states; Union Territories; Article 258A
24th (1971)Parliament may amend any part, including Part III; President must assent; Article 13(4)
61st (1988)Voting age reduced from 21 to 18
69th (1991)Special status for Delhi as the National Capital Territory (Article 239AA)
86th (2002)Article 21A; revised Article 45; Fundamental Duty in Article 51A(k)
101st (2016)GST: Articles 246A, 269A and 279A

Look-alike pairs: 42 adds, 44 restores; 52 creates anti-defection, 91 tightens it and caps ministries at 15%; 73 villages, 74 towns, 97 co-operatives.

Key takeaways: learn amendments in confusable pairs; split compound statements into claims and test each; remember articles as well as themes (21A, 239AA, 243, 279A, 300A).

Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Which majority? Removals, impeachment, emergencies and resolutions

ActionArticleMajority and extra points
Impeach the President61Two-thirds of the total membership of the House; 14 days' notice signed by at least one-fourth of the members
Remove a judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court124(4), 217In each House: majority of total membership and two-thirds of present and voting; same session
Remove the Vice-President67(b)Rajya Sabha resolution by a majority of all the then members, agreed to by the Lok Sabha by a simple majority; 14 days' notice
Remove the Speaker94(c)Majority of all the then members of the Lok Sabha; 14 days' notice
Approve a national emergency352Each House within one month, by a majority of total membership and two-thirds of present and voting
Approve President's rule356Both Houses within two months, by simple majority
Rajya Sabha resolution on State List or all-India services249, 312Two-thirds of present and voting

Read the base before the fraction: total membership, all the then members, or present and voting.

Key takeaways: identify the base first; Article 61 is two-thirds of total membership; judges need a majority of total membership and two-thirds of present and voting; the Vice-President and Speaker go by all the then members; Article 352 needs the special majority and Article 356 a simple majority.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

True or false rapid fire on the amendment procedure

StatementVerdictReason
An amendment bill may be introduced in the Rajya SabhaTrueEither House may introduce it
A state legislature may introduce an amendment billFalseOnly Parliament has the initiative
The President may refuse assent to an amendment billFalseArticle 368(2) says the President shall give assent
A joint sitting can resolve a disagreement on an amendment billFalseJoint sittings are not allowed for amendment bills
State legislatures ratify by a special majorityFalseA simple majority of each legislature is enough
There is a fixed time limit for states to ratifyFalseThe Constitution fixes none
Every amendment needs ratification by the statesFalseOnly the federal matters of the proviso do
An amendment bill needs the President's prior recommendationFalseNo prior recommendation is needed
A private member can introduce an amendment billTrueAny member may introduce it
Both Houses have equal power on an amendment billTrueThere is no joint sitting; each House must pass it
Absolute majority means more than half of the members presentFalseIt means more than half of the total membership
Members who abstain count as votingFalseOnly those who vote are voting
An ordinance can amend the ConstitutionFalseAn ordinance is not an amendment under Article 368
Article 368 is in Part XXTruePart XX contains only Article 368
The basic structure doctrine is written in Article 368FalseIt is a doctrine of the Supreme Court
An amendment can be struck down for damaging the basic structureTrueKesavananda Bharati (1973) and later cases
After Kesavananda, Fundamental Rights cannot be amended at allFalseThey can be amended within the basic structure
The Fifth Schedule can be amended by a simple majorityTrueParagraph 7 says it is not an amendment under Article 368

False families: wrong body, wrong majority, wrong scope. True families: either House, equal Houses, basic structure review.

Key takeaways: only Parliament initiates; either House; separate passage by special majority; no joint sitting; assent is compulsory; states ratify by simple majority without a time limit and only for federal matters; abstainers are not voting; the basic structure is a judicial doctrine.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Resolutions and the states' role: Articles 3, 169, 249, 252 and ratification

ArticleWho actsMajorityEffectAn Article 368 amendment?
3State legislature gives its views when a bill affects its stateNot bindingParliament may form states or change boundaries and names by simple majorityNo (Article 4)
169State Assembly passes a resolutionMajority of total membership and two-thirds of present and votingParliament may create or abolish the Legislative Council by lawNo
249Rajya Sabha passes a resolutionTwo-thirds of present and votingParliament may legislate on a State List subject for up to one year at a timeNo
252Legislatures of two or more states pass resolutionsResolutions of the Houses of those statesParliament may legislate for those states; others may adopt laterNo
368 provisoLegislatures of at least half of the statesSimple majority in eachFederal amendments become ready for assentYes

Article 3: advisory views. Article 169: state resolution, then Parliament's law. Article 249: Rajya Sabha two-thirds. Article 252: states ask, Parliament makes the law.

Key takeaways: compare the Articles by who acts, what majority and what follows; Article 3 views are advisory; Article 169 needs the special majority in the Assembly and then a law; Article 249 needs two-thirds of the Rajya Sabha present and voting; Article 252 needs resolutions from at least two states; ratification under Article 368 is by simple majority.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Matching articles with what they do: a drill

PartSubjectArticles
IIIFundamental Rights12 to 35
IVDirective Principles36 to 51
IVAFundamental Duties51A
IXPanchayats243 to 243O
IXAMunicipalities243P to 243ZG
IXBCo-operative societies243ZH to 243ZT
XIUnion-state relations (legislative and administrative)245 to 263
XVIIIEmergency provisions352 to 360
XXAmendment of the Constitution368
ArticleSubjectAmendment
13(4)Article 13 not to apply to amendments under Article 36824th (1971)
15(4)Special provisions for backward classes1st (1951)
15(5)Special provisions for admission to educational institutions93rd (2005)
16(4A)Reservation in promotions for SC and ST77th (1995)
21ARight to education for children aged 6 to 1486th (2002)
31A, 31BAgrarian laws; Ninth Schedule1st (1951)
31CLaws for Directive Principles 39(b) and (c)25th (1971)
51AFundamental Duties42nd (1976)
239AASpecial provisions for Delhi69th (1991)
246A, 279AGST and the GST Council101st (2016)
300ARight to property as a legal right44th (1978)

Part III 12-35; Part IV 36-51; 51A duties; 243 panchayats; 243P municipalities; 243ZH co-operatives; 352-360 emergency; 368 amendment.

Key takeaways: learn the Part blocks first; link each Article to its amendment; remember the pairs 31A-31B and 246A-279A; watch the traps between Articles in Part III and Part IV.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery