• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Cooperation between states: trade, courts, rivers and councils

Describe how the Constitution keeps trade free across states, makes courts' orders respected everywhere, and provides bodies for settling disputes between states.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A state is not a separate country. A trader in one state sells goods in another, a person goes to court in one state and the order must be honoured in another, and rivers flow through several states. The Constitution has simple rules to handle these links, and examination questions often ask which Article or body deals with which problem.

Free trade across states

Article 301 says that trade, commerce and intercourse throughout the territory of India are free. This stops states from building walls around themselves. Parliament may restrict this freedom in the public interest (Article 302). A state cannot tax goods from other states more heavily than its own goods (Article 304). If it wants to put reasonable restrictions on trade in the public interest, the bill needs the previous sanction of the President before it is introduced in the state legislature. Neither Parliament nor a state may favour one state over another in trade matters, except that Parliament may do so to deal with a scarcity of goods (Article 303).

Courts and public records

Article 261 is called the full faith and credit clause. The public acts, records and judicial proceedings of the Union and of every state must be recognised throughout India. In simple words, a court order, a birth certificate or a government record from one state is respected in another. Final judgments of civil courts can be executed anywhere in India as law provides.

Rivers and disputes

  • Article 262: Parliament may make a law for the settlement of disputes about the waters of inter-state rivers. It can also bar the courts from hearing such a dispute. A law of 1956, the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, creates tribunals for this.
  • Article 131: the Supreme Court alone decides a dispute between the Union and a state, or between states, if it concerns a legal right.
  • Article 263: the President may set up an Inter-State Council to inquire into disputes, discuss subjects of common interest and advise. It can only advise; it cannot decide. It was set up in 1990.

Besides these there are Zonal Councils, created by the States Reorganisation Act of 1956. There are five, for the northern, central, eastern, western and southern zones. They are advisory and the Union Home Minister is their chairman.

Trade free (301). Full faith and credit (261). River water disputes: tribunal (262). Dispute on a legal right between governments: Supreme Court (131). Advice only: Inter-State Council (263) and Zonal Councils.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: a court order across the border

A court in State A gives a final judgment in a money case, and the person lives in State B. Does the judgment lose its force when he moves? No. Under Article 261, judicial proceedings of State A are given full faith and credit in State B, and the judgment can be executed there.

Worked example 2: which body?

Match: (a) two states dispute the sharing of a river's water; (b) two states dispute whether one of them owns a piece of land, which is a question of legal right; (c) states wish to discuss common problems of a region. Answers: (a) the water tribunal created under Article 262; (b) the Supreme Court under Article 131; (c) the Zonal Council, or the Inter-State Council for matters of wider interest.

Worked example 3: a tax on goods

A state imposes a tax of ₹10 on every kilogram of rice coming from other states but only ₹6 on rice produced in the state. Is that fair under the Constitution? No. Article 304 allows a state to tax outside goods only to the same extent as its own goods. The ₹4 difference is discrimination and the law is invalid to that extent.

Key takeaways: trade and movement are free across India; official acts of one state are respected in all; river disputes go to tribunals created under Article 262; legal disputes between governments go to the Supreme Court; councils only advise.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article declares that trade and commerce throughout India are free?

    1. Article 261
    2. Article 301
    3. Article 262
    4. Article 263
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 301 declares freedom of trade, commerce and intercourse throughout the territory of India.

  2. 2. The 'full faith and credit' clause is in

    1. Article 301
    2. Article 131
    3. Article 261
    4. Article 263
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 261 requires that public acts, records and judicial proceedings of the Union and every state be given recognition everywhere in India.

  3. 3. Disputes about the waters of an inter-state river are dealt with under

    1. Article 262
    2. Article 131
    3. Article 301
    4. Article 352
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 262 allows Parliament to provide for adjudication of such disputes and to bar the courts from hearing them.

  4. 4. The Inter-State Council under Article 263 is

    1. A court with power to decide
    2. A body with power to dismiss a state government
    3. An advisory body that recommends
    4. A committee of the Supreme Court
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Inter-State Council inquires into disputes and advises on coordination; it has no power to decide or to give orders.

  5. 5. The chairman of each Zonal Council is

    1. The Prime Minister
    2. The Union Home Minister
    3. The Chief Justice of India
    4. The Chief Minister of the host state
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Zonal Councils, created by the States Reorganisation Act, 1956, are chaired by the Union Home Minister.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery