• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Legislative relations: the three lists and who makes which law

Use the Union, State and Concurrent Lists to decide who can make a law, who holds leftover powers, and which law wins when Union and state laws clash.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The first question in any Centre-State problem is: who has the power to make this law? The Constitution answers it by dividing law-making subjects into three lists. Once you can place a subject in the right list and know what happens when two laws clash, you can answer most basic questions on legislative relations.

Where laws apply: Article 245

Parliament may make laws for the whole of India or any part of it. A state legislature may make laws for the whole of its state or any part of it. A law of Parliament is not invalid just because it also operates outside India; for example, it may govern Indian citizens abroad. A state law, by contrast, normally works only within the state, unless there is a real connection between the state and the thing it regulates.

The three lists: Article 246

The Union List (List I) contains subjects of national importance on which only Parliament can make laws. The State List (List II) contains subjects of local importance on which, in normal times, only the state legislature can make laws. The Concurrent List (List III) contains subjects on which both can make laws. Parliament can also make laws on any subject for Union Territories, including subjects in the State List.

Examples of subjects in each list
Union ListState ListConcurrent List
DefencePoliceCriminal law and procedure
Foreign affairsPublic orderMarriage and divorce
RailwaysPublic health and sanitationEducation
Banking and currencyAgricultureForests
Atomic energyLocal governmentTrade unions

The 42nd Amendment (1976) moved five subjects from the State List to the Concurrent List: education, forests, weights and measures, protection of wild animals and birds, and administration of justice (the constitution and organisation of courts other than the Supreme Court and the High Courts).

Leftover subjects: residuary power

No list can foresee every subject. A subject that appears in none of the three lists is called a residuary subject. Under Article 248, Parliament alone can make laws on residuary subjects, including residuary taxes. This follows the Canadian model; in the United States, by contrast, leftover powers rest with the states.

When laws clash: Article 254

If a state law on a Concurrent List subject conflicts with a law of Parliament, the law of Parliament prevails and the state law is void to the extent of the conflict. There is one exception. If the state law was reserved for the President's consideration and received the President's assent, it prevails in that state. Even then, Parliament can later pass a law on the same matter that overrides it.

Worked example 1: placing subjects

A state wants to make laws on (a) its police force, (b) its railways, and (c) marriage. Step 1: police is in the State List, so the state can legislate. Step 2: railways are in the Union List, so the state cannot. Step 3: marriage and divorce are in the Concurrent List, so the state can legislate, but a conflicting Union law would prevail.

Worked example 2: a clash on a Concurrent subject

Parliament has a law on trade unions. A state then passes its own trade union law that conflicts with it. Case 1: the state law did not receive the President's assent. The Union law prevails; the conflicting parts of the state law are void. Case 2: the state reserved its law for the President and the President gave assent. The state law prevails within that state, until Parliament passes a new law that changes the position.

Union List: only Parliament. State List: only the state, in normal times. Concurrent List: both, but Parliament wins a clash unless the state law has the President's assent. Leftovers: Parliament.

Key takeaways

  • Article 245: Parliament for all or part of India; states for all or part of their territory.
  • Article 246: three lists in the Seventh Schedule.
  • Article 248: residuary power with Parliament.
  • Article 254: Union law prevails on Concurrent subjects, except a state law with the President's assent.
  • The 42nd Amendment moved five subjects, including education and forests, to the Concurrent List.

Whenever you read about a new law, try to guess its list. This simple habit quickly builds the instinct that exam questions test.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'Police' is a subject in which list?

    1. Union List
    2. State List
    3. Concurrent List
    4. It is a residuary subject
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Police and public order are State List subjects.

  2. 2. Residuary powers of legislation in India are vested in:

    1. The states
    2. Both Parliament and the states
    3. Parliament
    4. The Supreme Court
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 248 gives Parliament the exclusive power to legislate on any matter not in the State or Concurrent List.

  3. 3. A state law on a Concurrent List subject conflicts with a law of Parliament, and the state law did not receive the President's assent. Which law prevails?

    1. The state law
    2. The law of Parliament
    3. Neither; both are void
    4. Whichever was passed later
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Under Article 254(1), the law of Parliament prevails and the state law is void to the extent of the conflict.

  4. 4. Which subject was moved from the State List to the Concurrent List by the 42nd Amendment?

    1. Education
    2. Police
    3. Defence
    4. Agriculture
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The 42nd Amendment moved education, forests, weights and measures, protection of wild animals and birds, and administration of justice to the Concurrent List.

  5. 5. Which statement about Article 245 is correct?

    1. Parliament can make laws only for the states that consent
    2. Parliament can make laws only for Union Territories
    3. A law of Parliament can never operate outside India
    4. Parliament can make laws for the whole or any part of India, and its laws are not invalid because they operate outside India
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 245 gives Parliament power over the whole or any part of India and saves its laws from invalidity on the ground of extra-territorial operation.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery