- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Financial relations: sharing taxes and money between the Centre and states
Explain who levies which taxes, how tax money is shared, what grants are, and the role of the Finance Commission and borrowing rules.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Governments need money to do their work. The Union raises more money than it needs for its own tasks, while the states carry heavy responsibilities such as police, health and agriculture with fewer sources of revenue. Financial relations are the rules that close this gap. They are in Part XII of the Constitution.
Who can tax what
The lists that divide law-making powers also divide taxing powers. Taxes in the Union List can be levied only by Parliament; taxes in the State List only by the states. Residuary taxes, those mentioned in no list, belong to Parliament. Since the 101st Amendment (2016), the Goods and Services Tax is a shared power: both Parliament and the state legislatures can make GST laws, but only Parliament can make laws on GST for supplies in the course of inter-state trade.
| Levied by the Union (examples) | Levied by the states (examples) |
|---|---|
| Income tax, other than on agricultural income | Tax on agricultural income |
| Customs duties | Land revenue |
| Corporation tax | Taxes on land and buildings |
| Residuary taxes (in no list) | Taxes on vehicles |
How tax money is shared
- Article 268: some duties, such as stamp duties on bills of exchange and cheques, are levied by the Union but collected and kept by the states.
- Article 269: taxes on the inter-state sale and consignment of goods are levied and collected by the Union but given to the states.
- Article 270: most Union taxes are levied and collected by the Union and then divided between the Union and the states.
- Article 271: surcharges on certain taxes go entirely to the Union.
Grants
The Union also gives money to states as grants. Under Article 275, Parliament provides statutory grants each year to states that need help; these are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India. Under Article 282, the Union (or a state) may give discretionary grants for any public purpose.
The Finance Commission
Under Article 280 the President sets up a Finance Commission every fifth year, or earlier if needed. It has a chairman and four other members. It recommends how the net proceeds of shared taxes should be divided between the Union and the states, and among the states; the principles for grants-in-aid; and measures to help states support their panchayats and municipalities. Its recommendations are advisory.
Borrowing
The Union may borrow within India or abroad on the security of the Consolidated Fund of India (Article 292). A state may borrow only within India (Article 293). If a state still owes money on a loan from the Union, or one guaranteed by it, it needs the Union's consent to borrow further.
Worked example 1: sharing taxes
Use illustrative numbers only. Suppose the net proceeds of shareable Union taxes in a year are ₹2,000 crore, and the states' share is 40%. Step 1: states together receive 40% of 2,000 = ₹800 crore; the Union keeps ₹1,200 crore. Step 2: suppose one state's share among the states is 5%. It receives 5% of 800 = ₹40 crore.
Worked example 2: which article?
A state wants to tax income from farming. Is that allowed? Yes: tax on agricultural income is in the State List. Next, the Union collects tax on goods sent from one state to another and passes all of it to the states. That is Article 269. Finally, the Union adds a surcharge to income tax for its own needs; that money stays with the Union under Article 271.
Union taxes are shared under Article 270, as the Finance Commission (Article 280) recommends; grants come under Article 275 (statutory) and Article 282 (discretionary); states borrow only within India (Article 293).
Key takeaways
Taxing powers follow the lists, with residuary taxes going to Parliament and GST shared. Most Union taxes are divided with the states under Article 270, while surcharges stay with the Union. Grants under Articles 275 and 282 add to state income. The Finance Commission, appointed every five years, recommends the shares. States may borrow only within India.
Check your understanding
-
1. Tax on agricultural income is levied by:
- The Union
- The states
- Both the Union and the states
- Local bodies only
Show answer
Answer: B. Tax on agricultural income is a State List subject. Income tax on other income is levied by the Union.
-
2. The Finance Commission is constituted under which article?
- Article 280
- Article 270
- Article 275
- Article 293
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 280 provides for a Finance Commission every fifth year or earlier.
-
3. A surcharge on certain taxes under Article 271 goes:
- Equally to the Union and the states
- Entirely to the states
- Entirely to the Union
- To the Contingency Fund
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 271 surcharges are for the purposes of the Union and are not shared with the states.
-
4. Discretionary grants for any public purpose are given under:
- Article 275
- Article 280
- Article 266
- Article 282
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 282 allows grants for any public purpose. Article 275 provides statutory grants-in-aid.
-
5. Illustrative numbers: shareable Union taxes are ₹2,000 crore and the states' share is 40%. A state's share among the states is 5%. How much does it receive?
- ₹100 crore
- ₹40 crore
- ₹80 crore
- ₹20 crore
Show answer
Answer: B. States get 40% of 2,000 = 800. The state gets 5% of 800 = 40, that is ₹40 crore.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.