• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Federalism in India: why the Centre and the states share power

Explain in simple words what a federation is, why India's Constitution calls India a Union of States, and which features are federal and which are unitary.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

India is governed at two levels at the same time. There is one government for the whole country, the Union or Centre, and there is a government for each state. Both make laws, collect taxes and run offices. Questions on how these two levels share power are called questions on Centre-State relations. Before learning the detailed rules, you need a clear picture of why this sharing exists and what kind of system India has. That is the aim of this first lesson.

What is a federation?

A federation is a system in which power is divided by a written constitution between a national government and regional governments, and neither can take away the other's share on its own. The opposite is a unitary system, where all power belongs to the national government, which may create or remove regional bodies as it likes. Many countries combine features of both. India does, and that is why textbooks often describe it as quasi-federal: federal in structure, with a strong tilt towards the Centre.

The word 'federation' does not appear in the Constitution. Article 1 says that India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States. Dr B. R. Ambedkar explained in the Constituent Assembly that this wording was chosen to show two things: the Indian federation was not the result of an agreement among states, and no state has the right to break away from it.

Federal features

  • A written Constitution that is supreme.
  • Two sets of governments: Union and states.
  • Division of powers through three lists in the Seventh Schedule.
  • A rigid amending process for provisions that affect the states.
  • An independent judiciary to settle disputes between the Centre and states.
  • A two-House Parliament in which the Rajya Sabha represents the states.

Unitary features (the tilt towards the Centre)

  • The Union List is the longest list and contains the most important subjects.
  • Parliament can change the area, boundaries or names of states by an ordinary law (Article 3).
  • Single citizenship and a single, integrated judiciary.
  • Governors are appointed by the President.
  • All India Services serve both the Union and the states.
  • Emergency provisions can turn the system almost unitary.

Why a strong Centre?

The makers of the Constitution worked just after Partition, with the princely states still being integrated and the country facing great diversity of language, religion and region. They wanted a Centre strong enough to hold the country together and to plan its development, while still giving states real power over local matters such as police, public health and agriculture.

Where the rules are

The detailed rules fall into three groups. Legislative relations (who makes which law) and administrative relations (who carries out which work) are in Part XI of the Constitution, Articles 245 to 263. Financial relations (who taxes and who spends) are in Part XII, Articles 264 to 300A. The lists of subjects are in the Seventh Schedule. The next four lessons take these one at a time.

Worked example 1: sorting features

Sort these: (a) written Constitution, (b) single citizenship, (c) independent judiciary, (d) Governor appointed by the President. Ask of each: does it protect the separate existence of the states (federal), or does it strengthen the Centre (unitary)? A written, supreme Constitution and an independent judiciary protect both levels, so (a) and (c) are federal. Single citizenship and a Governor chosen by the Centre strengthen the Centre, so (b) and (d) are unitary.

Worked example 2: the Article 3 test

Suppose Parliament wants to create a new state by dividing an existing one. Under Article 3 the bill needs the President's recommendation, and the President must refer it to the legislature of the affected state for its views. But Parliament is not bound by those views and may pass the law by a simple majority. In a pure federation, a region's boundaries usually cannot be changed without its consent. So this is a unitary feature.

India is a Union of States: federal in structure (two governments, divided powers, a supreme written Constitution) but with a strong Centre (Union List, Article 3, Governors, All India Services, emergencies).

Key takeaways

India has two levels of government with powers divided by the Constitution, which makes it federal. Several features give the Centre more weight, which makes it unitary in spirit. Article 1 calls India a Union of States. The rules on Centre-State relations are in Parts XI and XII, and the subject lists are in the Seventh Schedule.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How does Article 1 of the Constitution describe India?

    1. A Federation of States
    2. A Confederation of States
    3. A Union of States
    4. A Republic of Provinces
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 1 says India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States. The word 'federation' is not used.

  2. 2. Which of the following is a federal feature?

    1. Division of powers between the Centre and the states
    2. Single citizenship
    3. All India Services
    4. Appointment of Governors by the President
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Division of powers protects the separate role of each level of government. The other three strengthen the Centre.

  3. 3. Which of the following is a unitary feature?

    1. A written Constitution
    2. An independent judiciary
    3. A two-House Parliament
    4. Single citizenship
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Single citizenship strengthens national unity and the Centre; the others are typical federal features.

  4. 4. Legislative and administrative relations between the Union and the states are dealt with in:

    1. Part III
    2. Part XI
    3. Part XVIII
    4. Part IV
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Part XI (Articles 245-263) covers legislative and administrative relations. Part III is Fundamental Rights, Part IV Directive Principles, Part XVIII Emergency Provisions.

  5. 5. The Union, State and Concurrent Lists are found in which Schedule?

    1. First Schedule
    2. Fourth Schedule
    3. Seventh Schedule
    4. Tenth Schedule
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Seventh Schedule contains the three lists. The First lists states and territories, the Fourth allots Rajya Sabha seats, and the Tenth deals with defection.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery