- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Emergencies: how power shifts towards the Centre
Name the three kinds of emergency in the Constitution, say who approves each, and explain in simple words how each one changes the position of the states.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In normal times India works as a federation: the Union and the states each have their own area of power. The Constitution also knows that a country can face a crisis, such as a war or a breakdown of government, in which one strong authority must act quickly. For that it has three kinds of emergency. In each of them power moves towards the Centre, but in different ways and for different periods.
The three kinds of emergency
| Kind | Article | When it can be declared | Approval by Parliament |
|---|---|---|---|
| National emergency | 352 | War, external aggression or armed rebellion threatens India or a part of it | Within one month, by a special majority |
| State emergency (President's rule) | 356 | The government of a state cannot be carried on as the Constitution requires | Within two months, by a simple majority |
| Financial emergency | 360 | The financial stability or credit of India is threatened | Within two months, by a simple majority |
The President declares each emergency by a Proclamation. For a national emergency, the President acts only on the written advice of the Union Cabinet. A special majority means a majority of the total membership of a House and also at least two-thirds of the members present and voting. A simple majority means more than half of those present and voting.
A national emergency and the states
During a national emergency the state governments and legislatures go on working. But three things change. The Union can give directions to a state on how it should use its executive power, on any subject (Article 353). Parliament can make laws on subjects in the State List (Article 250). And the President can change the way taxes and grants are shared between the Union and the states (Article 354). A national emergency lasts for six months at a time, and it must be approved again by Parliament to continue.
President's rule and the financial emergency
Under Article 356 the President may take over the government of a state when it cannot be carried on as the Constitution requires. This usually follows a report from the Governor. The Governor then runs the state for the President, and Parliament makes the laws for the state. It is approved for six months at a time and cannot last more than three years in all. Under Article 360, in a financial emergency, the Union can direct states to follow rules of financial propriety, and the President may reduce salaries of government servants, including judges. This kind of emergency has no fixed end date; it lasts until the President ends it.
Three emergencies: 352 (war, aggression, armed rebellion), 356 (state government cannot function), 360 (financial stability threatened). In 352 the state government stays; in 356 it is replaced.
Worked example 1: which emergency?
Match each situation to an Article. (a) A foreign army invades a border region. (b) After an election no party can form a government in a state, and no one can run it as the Constitution says. (c) The country's credit is in danger. Working: (a) is external aggression, so Article 352. (b) is a breakdown of the state's constitutional machinery, so Article 356. (c) is a threat to financial stability, so Article 360.
Worked example 2: who runs the state?
Is the state government dismissed in a national emergency? No. The Chief Minister and ministers continue in office, but the Union can give them directions and Parliament can make laws on the State List. Under Article 356, however, the state government is displaced, and the Governor acts on behalf of the President. This difference is asked often in examinations.
Worked example 3: counting the approval
A national emergency is proclaimed on 1 June. By what date must both Houses approve it? The time allowed is one month, so by 1 July. If a President's rule is proclaimed on 1 June, the time allowed is two months, so approval is needed by 1 August.
Key takeaways: the Constitution has three emergencies, in Articles 352, 356 and 360. In all of them power moves to the Centre. In a national emergency the state government continues; in President's rule it is displaced; in a financial emergency the Union controls money. Approval is within one month for 352 and within two months for 356 and 360.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article deals with a national emergency?
- Article 352
- Article 356
- Article 360
- Article 368
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 352 deals with a national emergency on the ground of war, external aggression or armed rebellion. Article 356 is President's rule and Article 360 a financial emergency.
-
2. During a national emergency, the state governments
- Are dismissed by the President
- Continue to work, under Union directions
- Are replaced by the Rajya Sabha
- Become part of the Union government
Show answer
Answer: B. The state governments stay in office, but under Article 353 the Union can give directions to them on any subject.
-
3. President's rule in a state is proclaimed under
- Article 352
- Article 360
- Article 368
- Article 356
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 356 allows the President to take over the government of a state if it cannot be carried on as the Constitution requires.
-
4. A national emergency must be approved by Parliament within
- Two weeks
- Six months
- One month
- One year
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 352 requires approval by both Houses within one month, otherwise the Proclamation lapses.
-
5. Which emergency can lead to a reduction in the salaries of government servants, including judges?
- Financial emergency
- National emergency
- President's rule
- None of them
Show answer
Answer: A. Under Article 360 the President may direct a reduction in salaries and allowances of government servants, including judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.