- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
When Parliament can make laws on State List subjects
Name the five situations in which Parliament may legislate on State List subjects and state the condition and time limit for each.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In normal times the State List belongs to the states. But the Constitution allows Parliament to enter that field in a few special situations. These are tested often because each has its own condition: who must agree, by what majority, and for how long. This lesson explains the five situations in plain words and adds two ways in which the Centre can control state laws.
1. A Rajya Sabha resolution in the national interest (Article 249)
If the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution, supported by at least two-thirds of the members present and voting, declaring that it is necessary in the national interest for Parliament to make laws on a State List subject, Parliament may do so. The Rajya Sabha is chosen because it represents the states. The resolution stays in force for up to one year and can be renewed any number of times, one year at a time. A law made under it stops working six months after the resolution ends.
2. During a National Emergency (Article 250)
While a Proclamation of Emergency under Article 352 is in operation, Parliament may make laws on any State List subject. The state legislature is not suspended, but Union law prevails. Such laws stop working six months after the emergency ends.
3. When states ask for it (Article 252)
If the legislatures of two or more states pass resolutions asking Parliament to make a law on a State List subject, Parliament may do so for those states. Any other state may adopt the law later by passing a resolution of its own. Once made, such a law can be amended or repealed only by Parliament, not by the states. Laws on water pollution and on the protection of wildlife were made this way.
4. To carry out international agreements (Article 253)
Parliament may make any law, even on a State List subject, to implement a treaty, agreement or convention with other countries, or a decision taken at an international conference. This lets India keep its international promises.
5. During President's Rule (Article 356)
When President's Rule is imposed on a state, Parliament makes laws for that state on State List subjects, or allows the President to make them. These laws continue even after President's Rule ends, until the state legislature changes them.
| Situation | Article | Who must act | Time limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| National interest | 249 | Rajya Sabha, two-thirds of present and voting | One year, renewable; law lapses six months after |
| National Emergency | 250 | Proclamation under Article 352 | Law lapses six months after the emergency |
| States' request | 252 | Two or more state legislatures | Permanent; only Parliament can change it |
| International agreement | 253 | Parliament itself | No limit |
| President's Rule | 356 | Proclamation under Article 356 | Continues until the state legislature changes it |
Control over state laws in normal times
The Governor may reserve certain state bills for the President's consideration (Article 200), and the President may then give or withhold assent (Article 201). Also, a state bill that puts reasonable restrictions on trade within or with that state can be introduced only with the President's prior sanction (Article 304(b)).
Worked example 1: the time limits under Article 249
The Rajya Sabha passes a resolution on 1 August of Year 1. It lasts one year, until 31 July of Year 2. It is renewed once, so it now lasts until 31 July of Year 3, and is not renewed again. The law made under it continues for six more months after that, so it stops working at the end of January of Year 4.
Worked example 2: choosing the right article
Three states want a common law on a State List subject and pass resolutions. Which article? Article 252. Later one of those states wants to change the law for itself. Can its legislature do so? No; only Parliament can amend or repeal a law made under Article 252. Contrast this with Article 356, where laws made by Parliament for a state can later be changed by the state legislature.
Five doors into the State List: 249 (Rajya Sabha, two-thirds, one year), 250 (emergency), 252 (two or more states ask), 253 (treaties), 356 (President's Rule).
Key takeaways
Parliament can legislate on State List subjects only through these five doors. Article 249 needs a two-thirds Rajya Sabha resolution and lasts a year at a time. Laws under Articles 249 and 250 lapse six months after the resolution or emergency ends. Laws under Article 252 can be changed only by Parliament. In normal times, the Centre's control over state laws comes through reservation of bills and prior sanction.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under Article 249, the resolution allowing Parliament to make laws on a State List subject is passed by:
- The Lok Sabha by simple majority
- The Rajya Sabha by two-thirds of members present and voting
- Both Houses in a joint sitting
- The state legislatures
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 249 requires a Rajya Sabha resolution supported by not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting.
-
2. How long does a resolution under Article 249 remain in force?
- Six months
- Three years
- One year, and it can be renewed
- Permanently
Show answer
Answer: C. It remains in force for up to one year and may be renewed any number of times, one year at a time.
-
3. A law made by Parliament under Article 252 at the request of two states can be amended or repealed by:
- The legislatures of those states
- Parliament only
- The President alone
- Any state legislature
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 252(2): such a law can be amended or repealed only by an Act of Parliament.
-
4. Parliament legislates on a State List subject to implement an international treaty. Which article permits this?
- Article 253
- Article 249
- Article 252
- Article 356
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 253 empowers Parliament to make any law for implementing treaties, agreements and conventions.
-
5. A law made by Parliament under Article 249 ceases to have effect:
- Immediately when the resolution expires
- One year after the resolution expires
- At the end of the financial year
- Six months after the resolution ceases to be in force
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 249(3): the law ceases to have effect on the expiry of six months after the resolution ceases to be in force.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.