• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Administrative relations practice: directions, cooperation bodies and disputes

Trace the chain from Union directions to Article 365, tell apart the bodies that link the Centre and states, and answer scenario questions on water disputes and full faith and credit.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Administrative relations look simple, but practice questions mix the Union's coercive tools (directions and their consequences) with its cooperative tools (councils, services, delegation). Being able to tell which is which, and which article or law creates each body, is the key skill. This lesson sorts them and then works through scenarios.

The coercive chain

Article 256 obliges each state to exercise its executive power to ensure compliance with Parliament's laws and with existing laws in that state, and lets the Union give directions for that purpose. Article 257 adds directions so that state executive power does not impede the Union's, including directions on the construction and maintenance of means of communication declared to be of national or military importance and on the protection of railways. Article 365 completes the chain: non-compliance with any direction given under the Constitution allows the President to hold that the state cannot be governed in accordance with the Constitution, which is the condition for Article 356.

The cooperative tools

Body or toolBasisNature
Inter-State CouncilArticle 263; set up by presidential order in 1990Advisory; chaired by the Prime Minister
Zonal CouncilsStates Reorganisation Act, 1956Statutory, advisory; five zones (Northern, Central, Eastern, Western, Southern); chaired by the Union Home Minister
North Eastern CouncilNorth Eastern Council Act, 1971Statutory body for the north-eastern states
All India ServicesArticle 312Recruited by the Centre, serve the states
Delegation by consentArticles 258 and 258AVoluntary transfer of functions

Note the difference between a constitutional body and a statutory one. The Inter-State Council is provided for in the Constitution (though it exists only when the President sets it up); the Zonal Councils and the North Eastern Council exist under Acts of Parliament.

Water disputes and full faith and credit

Under Article 262, Parliament may by law provide for the adjudication of disputes about the waters of inter-state rivers and river valleys, and may provide that neither the Supreme Court nor any other court shall exercise jurisdiction over such disputes. Parliament did so through the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956, which provides for tribunals, and also passed the River Boards Act, 1956. Under Article 261, the public acts, records and judicial proceedings of the Union and every state receive full faith and credit throughout India, and final judgments of civil courts can be executed anywhere in India.

All India Services in practice

Officers of the All India Services are recruited and trained by the Centre and allotted to state cadres. They work under the state government day to day, but the ultimate control lies with the Centre: only the Union can impose the major penalty of dismissal or removal. This dual position makes the services both a link and a source of debate between the two levels.

Worked example 1: coercive or cooperative?

Classify: (a) a direction to protect a railway line, (b) a meeting of the Western Zonal Council, (c) a state entrusting a function to the Centre. (a) is a direction under Article 257, coercive, backed by Article 365. (b) is cooperative, under a statute, advisory. (c) is cooperative, under Article 258A, and requires the Union's consent.

Worked example 2: a water dispute

Two states disagree over sharing a river. One state files a suit in the Supreme Court asking it to decide the share. Step 1: Article 262 allows Parliament to exclude the courts' jurisdiction. Step 2: Parliament has provided tribunals under the 1956 Act. Step 3: so the dispute goes to a tribunal under that Act, not to an ordinary suit in court.

Coercive: 256, 257, then 365, then 356. Cooperative: 258 and 258A by consent; Inter-State Council (Article 263); Zonal Councils and the North Eastern Council (statutes); All India Services (Article 312).

Key takeaways

  • Non-compliance with Union directions links to Article 356 through Article 365.
  • The Inter-State Council is constitutional; Zonal Councils and the North Eastern Council are statutory.
  • Zonal Councils are chaired by the Union Home Minister; the Inter-State Council by the Prime Minister.
  • Water disputes go to tribunals under the 1956 Act, and Parliament may exclude court jurisdiction.
  • Final civil judgments are executable anywhere in India under Article 261.

When a question lists several bodies, first sort them by basis (Constitution or statute) and by nature (coercive or cooperative). Most options fail one of these two tests.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which article links a state's failure to comply with Union directions to the imposition of President's Rule?

    1. Article 256
    2. Article 263
    3. Article 257
    4. Article 365
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 365 allows the President to treat non-compliance as a failure of constitutional machinery under Article 356.

  2. 2. Zonal Councils were created under:

    1. Article 263 of the Constitution
    2. The States Reorganisation Act, 1956
    3. The North Eastern Council Act, 1971
    4. Article 312 of the Constitution
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Zonal Councils are statutory bodies under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956.

  3. 3. Who chairs the Zonal Councils?

    1. The Union Home Minister
    2. The Prime Minister
    3. The President
    4. The Chief Justice of India
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Each Zonal Council is chaired by the Union Home Minister; the Inter-State Council is chaired by the Prime Minister.

  4. 4. Two states file a suit in the Supreme Court over sharing an inter-state river. Which is correct?

    1. The Supreme Court must decide it under its original jurisdiction
    2. The President decides it alone
    3. Parliament has provided for tribunals and may exclude court jurisdiction under Article 262
    4. The Finance Commission decides it
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 262 and the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 route such disputes to tribunals.

  5. 5. A final judgment of a civil court in one state can be executed in another state because of:

    1. Article 258
    2. Article 261
    3. Article 262
    4. Article 254
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 261 gives full faith and credit to judicial proceedings and makes final civil judgments executable anywhere in India.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery