- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Assertion-reason and case-based questions on Centre-State relations
Answer assertion-reason and short case questions by testing each sentence on its own first, then testing whether the reason really explains the assertion.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Assertion-reason questions give two sentences, an Assertion (A) and a Reason (R), and four standard options. They look harder than statement questions because you must judge two things: whether each sentence is true, and whether R explains A. A fixed method makes them routine.
The four standard options
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Method
- Test A alone as true or false, using the Article you know.
- Test R alone in the same way.
- If both are true, ask: does R answer 'why' for A? If R would still be true even if A were not, it probably does not explain A.
- Choose the option.
True/false first, 'why' second. A true R that merely sits beside A is option 2, not option 1.
Worked example 1
A: A state law that conflicts with an earlier Union law on a Concurrent List subject is, as a rule, void to the extent of the conflict. R: Article 254(1) gives priority to the law made by Parliament. Working: A is true. R is true. R is the very rule that makes A true. Option 1.
Worked example 2
A: The Inter-State Council can give binding decisions on disputes between states. R: Article 263 gives the Council the duty to inquire into and advise upon disputes between states. Working: A is false, because the Council only advises. R is true. Option 4.
Worked example 3
A: A financial emergency continues until it is revoked. R: A financial emergency must be approved within two months by a simple majority of both Houses. Working: A is true. R is true. But the approval rule says nothing about how long the emergency lasts; approval is needed under every emergency, and it does not explain the open-ended duration. Option 2.
Worked example 4: a short case
The Assembly of a state is not in session. The Governor promulgates an ordinance on a subject in the State List on 3 January. The Assembly meets on 10 February. Until when can the ordinance stay in force at most, if it is not approved or disapproved? Working: six weeks from reassembly is 42 days; 10 February plus 42 days is 24 March (18 days to reach 28 February in a non-leap year, then 24 more). Answer: 24 March, in a non-leap year.
Worked example 5: a case on legislative power
A treaty obliges India to adopt a uniform standard for a subject that is in the State List. Can Parliament legislate? Yes, under Article 253, which allows Parliament to make any law for implementing a treaty or international decision. No resolution of the Rajya Sabha is needed, and no consent of the states is needed.
Key takeaways: always judge A and R separately before judging the link; a true R that does not answer 'why' gives option 2; read cases for the Article that fits, then apply its numbers.
Check your understanding
-
1. A: The Rajya Sabha can authorise Parliament to legislate on a State List matter. R: Article 249 requires a resolution supported by two-thirds of the members present and voting. Choose the option.
- Both true, R explains A
- Both true, R does not explain A
- A true, R false
- A false, R true
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 249 is the provision under which the Rajya Sabha resolution gives Parliament power on a State List matter, so both are true and R explains A.
-
2. A: President's rule can last for three years at most. R: President's rule can be proclaimed only with the consent of the state legislature. Choose the option.
- Both true, R explains A
- Both true, R does not explain A
- A true, R false
- A false, R true
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 356(4) sets the three-year ceiling, so A is true. No consent of the state legislature is required, so R is false.
-
3. A: During a national emergency the state legislatures stand dissolved. R: Parliament can make laws on State List subjects during a national emergency. Choose the option.
- Both true, R explains A
- Both true, R does not explain A
- A true, R false
- A false, R true
Show answer
Answer: D. State legislatures continue to function during a national emergency, so A is false. R is true under Article 250.
-
4. A: A Governor can be elected by the people of the state. R: The Governor is appointed by the President. Choose the option.
- Both true, R explains A
- A false, R true
- A true, R false
- Both false
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 155 says the Governor is appointed by the President, so A is false and R is true.
-
5. An Assembly reassembles on 1 March (non-leap year) and takes no action on an ordinance. It ceases to operate on
- 12 April
- 29 April
- 15 April
- 10 May
Show answer
Answer: A. Six weeks are 42 days. From 1 March, 30 days brings us to 31 March and 12 more to 12 April, so the ordinance ceases on 12 April.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.