- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement questions: finding the one false word in Centre-State relations
Practise multi-statement questions on legislative, administrative and financial relations by locating the single word that makes a statement false.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most Centre-State questions in competitive exams are not 'what is Article 249?' but 'which of the following statements are correct?'. Each wrong statement is usually a true statement with one word changed. If you learn the usual swaps, you can find the false word in seconds and eliminate options without reading every line twice.
The six favourite swaps
| Swap | True version | False version |
|---|---|---|
| Majority | Two-thirds of members present and voting (Article 249) | Two-thirds of the total membership |
| House | A resolution of the Rajya Sabha (Article 249) | A resolution of the Lok Sabha |
| Level of government | Residuary power lies with Parliament (Article 248) | Residuary power lies with the states |
| Fund | Statutory grants are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India (Article 275) | ... on the Consolidated Fund of the state |
| Direction of power | Union directs the states (Article 256, 257) | States direct the Union |
| Quantifier | Parliament may legislate on the State List in five situations | Parliament may legislate on the State List at any time |
The words to underline while reading are the small ones: only, always, any, all, never, total, present and voting, Consolidated Fund of India. An examiner who wants to make a statement false almost always changes one of these.
Method
- Read each statement alone and decide true or false without looking at the options.
- Underline the key noun (House, majority, fund, period) and recall the Article attached to it.
- Mark each statement T or F, then match the pattern to the options.
- If two statements are certain, eliminate options that contradict them before checking the third.
Do not ask 'does this sound right?' Ask 'which one word could have been changed?' Check the majority, the House, the fund and the level of government first.
Worked example 1: the legislative field
Consider: (1) Residuary power of legislation belongs to the state legislatures. (2) A state law on a Concurrent List subject that conflicts with an earlier Union law is void to the extent of the conflict, unless it received the President's assent. (3) An Article 249 resolution needs two-thirds of the total membership of the Rajya Sabha. Working: (1) is false, since Article 248 gives residuary power to Parliament. (2) is true: Article 254(1) and (2). (3) is false, because the test is two-thirds of the members present and voting. Answer: (2) only. Note that (1) and (3) each fail on one word: states and total membership.
Worked example 2: the financial field
Consider: (1) The Finance Commission is constituted by the President every fifth year or earlier. (2) Grants under Article 275 are charged on the Consolidated Fund of the state. (3) A state may borrow from outside India on the security of its Consolidated Fund. Working: (1) is true (Article 280). (2) is false; the fund is the Consolidated Fund of India. (3) is false; under Article 293 a state may borrow only within India. Answer: (1) only.
Worked example 3: the administrative field
Consider: (1) Article 256 obliges every state to comply with laws made by Parliament. (2) If a state ignores a Union direction under Article 256 or 257, the President may hold that the state government cannot be carried on under the Constitution (Article 365). (3) The Governor is elected by the state legislature. Working: (1) and (2) are true. (3) is false since the Governor is appointed by the President. Answer: (1) and (2) only. Notice that a statement can be false because it describes a different country's system, such as an elected governor.
Worked example 4: a trap with 'any'
'Parliament may make a law on any State List subject during a national emergency.' This is true under Article 250. 'Parliament may make a law on any State List subject at any time.' This is false. The extra words 'at any time' remove all the five conditions. Always check whether a quantifier makes the statement larger than the rule.
Key takeaways: find the changed word; check majority, House, fund, level of government and quantifier first; remember that one certain statement can eliminate several options.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement is correct?
- Residuary power rests with the state legislatures
- Residuary power rests with Parliament
- Residuary power rests with the President
- Residuary power rests with the Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 248 gives residuary power of legislation, including residuary taxation, to Parliament.
-
2. An Article 249 resolution requires a majority of
- A majority of the total membership of the Lok Sabha
- One-half of the members present in the Rajya Sabha
- Two-thirds of Rajya Sabha members present and voting
- A majority of the total membership of both Houses
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 249 requires a resolution of the Rajya Sabha supported by not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting.
-
3. Statutory grants under Article 275 are charged on
- The Public Account of India
- The Consolidated Fund of the state concerned
- The Contingency Fund of India
- The Consolidated Fund of India
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 275 grants are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India.
-
4. Which statement about state borrowing is correct?
- A state may borrow only within India
- A state may borrow abroad without limit
- A state may borrow only from the Union
- A state may never borrow
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 293 allows a state to borrow within the territory of India on the security of its Consolidated Fund, subject to limits.
-
5. 'Parliament may make laws on any State List subject at any time.' This statement is
- True, as Parliament has the residuary power
- True, as Article 246 gives it every subject
- False, as Parliament may do so only in listed cases
- False, as Parliament may never do so at all
Show answer
Answer: C. Parliament may legislate on State List subjects only in the situations the Constitution lists, such as Articles 249, 250, 252, 253 and 356. 'Never' is also wrong.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.