• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Numbers, majorities and dates: a calculation drill for Centre-State relations

Solve dated and numerical questions on Articles 249, 250, 280, 356, 368 and the GST Council by applying the rule, the count and the calendar in order.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Some Centre-State questions need arithmetic: a majority to count, a date to work out, a share to divide. The rules are short, and the marks are lost only when a rule is applied to the wrong starting date or to the wrong group of members. Use the table below as your fixed reference, and then practise on the worked examples.

The numbers to know

Fixed numbers and periods
ProvisionNumber or period
Article 249 resolutionTwo-thirds of Rajya Sabha members present and voting; in force up to one year at a time; law ceases six months after the resolution lapses
Article 250 lawCeases six months after the national emergency ends
National emergency (Article 352)Approved within one month; special majority; six months at a time
President's rule (Article 356)Approved within two months; six months at a time; three years at most
Finance Commission (Article 280)Constituted every fifth year or earlier; a chairman and four other members
GST Council (Article 279A)Union one-third and states together two-thirds of the weight; decision needs three-fourths of the weighted votes
Amendment affecting states (Article 368)Special majority plus ratification by not less than half of the states

Worked example 1: Article 249 and the six-month tail

The Rajya Sabha passes a resolution on 15 March of Year 1, valid for one year, and it is renewed once for another year. A law is made under it. Step 1: the first period ends on 15 March of Year 2. Step 2: the renewal carries it to 15 March of Year 3, where the resolution lapses. Step 3: the law ceases to have effect six months after the resolution ceases, that is on 15 September of Year 3, except for things done before then. The six months always run from the day the resolution stops, not from the day the law was passed.

Worked example 2: Article 250

A national emergency ceases to operate on 20 July of Year 5. Parliament had made a law on a State List subject during it. Working: the law ceases to operate six months after the Proclamation stops operating, so on 20 January of Year 6. Compare with Article 249: both have a six-month tail, but the starting event differs (end of the resolution in 249, end of the emergency in 250).

Worked example 3: the ceiling on President's rule

President's rule is proclaimed on 1 January of Year 1. What is the latest date to which it can continue? Step 1: the maximum is three years. Step 2: three years from 1 January of Year 1 is 1 January of Year 4. Step 3: continuation beyond one year, that is beyond 1 January of Year 2, needs a national emergency in operation and the Election Commission's certificate that elections cannot be held. Answer: 1 January of Year 4 at the very latest.

Worked example 4: the GST Council vote

Suppose, only for arithmetic, that there are 30 state members and all vote. Each state carries two-thirds divided by 30, which is 2.22 per cent. To pass a proposal with the Union in favour (33.33 per cent), the states must add at least 75 minus 33.33 = 41.67 per cent. That needs 41.67 divided by 2.22 = 18.75, so 19 states. Check: 19 states give 42.2 per cent, total 75.6 per cent, which is enough; 18 states give 40 per cent, total 73.3 per cent, which is not. To block a proposal, a group needs more than 25 per cent: the Union alone has 33.33 per cent and can block by itself.

Worked example 5: sharing a pool

Suppose the shareable pool of Union taxes is ₹5,000 crore, and the states together receive 40 per cent. Three states divide that in the ratio 4 : 3 : 3. Working: 40 per cent of 5,000 = 2,000. The shares: 4/10 of 2,000 = 800, and 3/10 of 2,000 = 600 each. Check: 800 + 600 + 600 = 2,000. These figures are for practice only.

Write the start date, add the period, then check for any condition. For majorities, compute both tests and use the larger. For shares, compute the pool first, then divide by the ratio.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: the six-month tails of Articles 249 and 250 start from different events; President's rule has a three-year ceiling; the GST arithmetic depends on the Union's one-third weight; and amendments affecting states need ratification by half.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A resolution under Article 249 lapses on 1 July of Year 4. A law made under it ceases to have effect on

    1. 1 July of Year 5
    2. 1 January of Year 5
    3. 1 October of Year 4
    4. 1 January of Year 4
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The law ceases six months after the resolution ceases to be in force: 1 July of Year 4 plus six months is 1 January of Year 5.

  2. 2. A national emergency ceases on 31 March. A law made under Article 250 ceases on

    1. 30 June
    2. 31 March of the next year
    3. 30 September
    4. 31 December
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Six months after 31 March is 30 September (the last day of the sixth month after March).

  3. 3. President's rule proclaimed on 1 June of Year 1 can continue, at the very most, until

    1. 1 June of Year 2
    2. 1 June of Year 4
    3. 1 December of Year 3
    4. 1 June of Year 3
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The ceiling is three years from the date of the Proclamation: 1 June of Year 4.

  4. 4. In the GST Council the states together carry what share of the weighted votes?

    1. Two-thirds
    2. One-third
    3. One-half
    4. Three-fourths
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Union has one-third of the weight and the states together two-thirds.

  5. 5. The shareable pool is ₹5,000 crore and the states get 40 per cent. A state with 3/10 of the states' share receives

    1. ₹300 crore
    2. ₹1,500 crore
    3. ₹600 crore
    4. ₹800 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 40 per cent of 5,000 = 2,000; 3/10 of 2,000 = 600 crore.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery