- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Financial relations practice: tax categories, grants, the GST Council and reform commissions
Classify taxes by who levies, collects and keeps them, compute GST Council voting outcomes, and identify the main recommendations of the commissions on Centre-State relations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Financial relations generate the most numerical and classification questions in this topic. This lesson drills the tax ladder of Articles 268 to 271, the two kinds of grants, the Finance Commission, the voting rule of the GST Council, and the commissions that have reviewed Centre-State relations.
The tax ladder, with examples
| Article | Levied by | Collected by | Kept by | Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 268 | Union | States | States | Stamp duties on bills of exchange, cheques and promissory notes |
| 269 | Union | Union | States | Taxes on inter-state sale and consignment of goods |
| 270 | Union | Union | Shared | Income tax other than on agricultural income, corporation tax |
| 271 | Union | Union | Union only | Surcharges for Union purposes |
Since the 80th Amendment (2000), all Union taxes are shareable under Article 270 except those under Articles 268, 269 and 269A, surcharges under Article 271, and cesses levied for specific purposes.
Grants and the Finance Commission
Article 275 grants are statutory, charged on the Consolidated Fund of India, given to states in need of assistance, and include grants for the welfare of Scheduled Tribes and the administration of scheduled areas. Article 282 grants are discretionary, for any public purpose. The Finance Commission (Article 280) is appointed by the President every fifth year or earlier, with a chairman and four other members; Parliament has laid down their qualifications by law. It recommends the division of net proceeds of shared taxes and the principles for Article 275 grants, among other things, and its advice is not binding.
The GST Council: Article 279A
The GST Council is chaired by the Union Finance Minister; its members include the Union Minister of State in charge of revenue or finance and the finance ministers (or other nominated ministers) of the states. Decisions need a majority of at least three-fourths of the weighted votes of members present and voting. The Union's vote carries one-third of the total votes cast, and the states together carry two-thirds.
Worked example 1: does a GST proposal pass?
Let f be the fraction of the states' weight voting yes. With the Union voting yes, the yes share is 1/3 + (2/3)f. Setting this at least 3/4: (2/3)f ≥ 3/4 − 1/3 = 5/12, so f ≥ 5/8 = 62.5%. So the Union plus at least 62.5% of the states' weight is enough. Without the Union, the maximum yes share is 2/3, which is below 3/4, so the Union effectively has a veto. And if more than 37.5% of the states' weight votes no, the proposal fails even with the Union's support.
Worked example 2: classifying a tax
A tax is levied by Parliament, collected by the Union, and the entire proceeds are handed to the states where the goods were consigned. Levied by Union, collected by Union, kept by states: Article 269. If instead the states had collected and kept it, Article 268; if it had been divided, Article 270; if the Union kept it all as a surcharge, Article 271.
Commissions on Centre-State relations
| Commission | Set up by | Selected recommendations |
|---|---|---|
| Rajamannar Committee (1969) | Government of Tamil Nadu | Set up the Inter-State Council at once; omit Articles 356, 357 and 365; make the Finance Commission a permanent body |
| Sarkaria Commission (1983) | Union government | A permanent Inter-State Council under Article 263; use Article 356 sparingly, as a last resort; Governor to be an eminent person from outside the state, not too closely involved in its recent politics |
| Punchhi Commission (2007) | Union government | A second Union commission that reviewed Centre-State relations afresh |
Worked example 3: who said what?
A statement says the Sarkaria Commission recommended deleting Article 356. That is wrong: Sarkaria recommended using it sparingly, as a last resort. Deletion of Articles 356, 357 and 365 was the Rajamannar Committee's demand, a state-appointed body that favoured greater state autonomy. Sorting by 'state-appointed or Union-appointed' usually reveals which recommendation belongs where.
GST Council: three-fourths of weighted votes; Union one-third, states two-thirds. The Union needs at least 62.5% of the states' weight with it, and cannot pass anything alone.
Key takeaways
- Ladder: 268 states keep and collect; 269 Union collects, states keep; 270 shared; 271 Union only.
- Article 275 grants are statutory; Article 282 grants are discretionary.
- The Finance Commission has a chairman and four members and its advice is not binding.
- GST Council decisions need three-fourths of weighted votes; neither side can pass a decision alone.
- Rajamannar (state) sought deletion of Article 356; Sarkaria (Union) sought its sparing use.
For the commissions, remember who appointed each one; it explains the tone of its recommendations and settles most statement questions.
Check your understanding
-
1. Taxes levied by the Union but collected and appropriated by the states fall under:
- Article 269
- Article 270
- Article 268
- Article 271
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 268: levied by the Union, collected and kept by the states, for example stamp duties on bills of exchange and cheques.
-
2. In the GST Council, the Union votes in favour. What is the smallest fraction of the states' total weight that must also vote yes for the proposal to pass?
- 50%
- 62.5%
- 75%
- 66.7%
Show answer
Answer: B. 1/3 + (2/3)f ≥ 3/4 gives (2/3)f ≥ 5/12, so f ≥ 5/8 = 62.5%.
-
3. Which body recommended that Articles 356, 357 and 365 be omitted?
- Rajamannar Committee
- Sarkaria Commission
- Punchhi Commission
- Finance Commission
Show answer
Answer: A. The Rajamannar Committee, appointed by the Tamil Nadu government in 1969, made this demand. Sarkaria recommended sparing use of Article 356.
-
4. Which statement about grants is correct?
- Article 282 grants are statutory and charged on the Consolidated Fund of India
- Article 275 grants can be given only to Union Territories
- The Finance Commission makes Article 282 grants itself
- Article 275 grants are statutory grants to states in need of assistance, charged on the Consolidated Fund of India
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 275 grants are statutory and charged on the Consolidated Fund of India; Article 282 grants are discretionary.
-
5. Which statement about the Finance Commission is correct?
- It has a chairman and four other members and its recommendations are advisory
- It is a permanent body chaired by the Union Finance Minister
- It is appointed by Parliament every ten years
- It decides GST rates
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 280: the President appoints a chairman and four members every fifth year or earlier, and the recommendations are advisory.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.