• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Parliament in the state field: majorities, durations and control of state bills

Compare the conditions and time limits for Union legislation on State List subjects and solve date and majority problems on Articles 249, 250, 252, 253 and 312.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Five provisions let Parliament legislate on State List subjects. Practice questions do not just ask you to name them; they ask you to compute a vote, find a lapse date or say who can later change the law. This lesson compares the five side by side and drills the arithmetic, then covers how the Centre controls state bills in normal times.

The comparison table

ProvisionTriggerMajority or conditionLife of the lawWho can change it later
Art. 249Rajya Sabha resolutionTwo-thirds of RS members present and votingResolution: one year, renewable any number of times; law lapses six months after it endsParliament
Art. 250Proclamation under Art. 352Approved emergencyLapses six months after the emergency endsParliament
Art. 252Resolutions of two or more state legislaturesEach state's own resolutionPermanentOnly Parliament
Art. 253Treaty or international decisionOrdinary lawPermanentParliament
Art. 356President's RuleApproved proclamationContinues after President's RuleState legislature, later

A related provision often confused with Article 249 is Article 312, under which the Rajya Sabha, by the same two-thirds of members present and voting, can declare that a new All India Service should be created in the national interest. Both use the Rajya Sabha because it represents the states, and both use the same majority.

Arithmetic of the Rajya Sabha resolution

Two-thirds of members present and voting is the only test under Articles 249 and 312; there is no condition about total membership. Round up if the result is not a whole number. Members who are present but abstain are not counted in 'present and voting'.

Worked example 1: the vote

Illustrative numbers: 210 Rajya Sabha members are present; 12 abstain and 198 vote. Two-thirds of 198 is 132, so at least 132 'yes' votes are needed. If 130 vote yes and 68 vote no, the resolution fails. If the 12 abstainers had voted no, the base would be 210 and the requirement 140; abstaining actually lowered the bar.

Worked example 2: lapse dates

A resolution under Article 249 is passed on 15 April of Year 1 and renewed twice. Each period is up to one year: first to 14 April of Year 2, then to Year 3, then to 14 April of Year 4. It is not renewed again. The law continues for six months after that, so it lapses in mid-October of Year 4. A common wrong answer adds six months to the original resolution date and forgets the renewals.

Control of state bills in normal times

Under Article 200 the Governor may give assent to a state bill, withhold assent, return a non-money bill for reconsideration, or reserve the bill for the President. Reservation is compulsory for a bill that would endanger the position of the High Court. Under Article 201 the President may assent, withhold assent, or, for a non-money bill, direct the Governor to return it to the legislature; the legislature must reconsider it within six months. If it passes the bill again, the President is still not bound to assent. Separately, the proviso to Article 304(b) requires the President's prior sanction for introducing a state bill that imposes reasonable restrictions on trade.

Worked example 3: who can repeal?

Parliament made three laws on State List subjects: (a) under Article 252 at the request of two states, (b) for a state under President's Rule, and (c) under Article 253 to implement a convention. Later, the legislature of the state in case (b) wants to repeal the law. It may, because laws made during President's Rule continue only until altered by the state legislature. In case (a) the states cannot repeal; only Parliament can. In case (c) the law rests on Parliament's treaty power, so a state cannot repeal it either.

Articles 249 and 312: Rajya Sabha, two-thirds of present and voting. Article 249 resolution: one year at a time; law lapses six months after. Article 252 law: only Parliament can change it. President's Rule laws: the state legislature can change them later.

Key takeaways

  • Use only 'present and voting' for Rajya Sabha resolutions under Articles 249 and 312.
  • Add six months to the end of the last renewed period, not to the first resolution.
  • Article 252 laws are permanent and only Parliament can amend them.
  • The President is not bound to assent even after a state legislature reconsiders a returned bill.

Most errors in this topic come from mixing up the 'who can change it later' column. Re-read that column before attempting the self-check.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Illustrative numbers: 198 Rajya Sabha members are present and voting on an Article 249 resolution. What is the minimum number of 'yes' votes?

    1. 100
    2. 132
    3. 123
    4. 198
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Two-thirds of 198 = 132. No test based on total membership applies to Article 249.

  2. 2. An Article 249 resolution passed on 15 April of Year 1 is renewed twice and then lapses. The law made under it lapses in about:

    1. October of Year 1
    2. April of Year 4
    3. October of Year 4
    4. October of Year 3
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Three one-year periods take it to April of Year 4; six months more is October of Year 4.

  3. 3. Which law made by Parliament on a State List subject can later be repealed by the state legislature concerned?

    1. A law made for the state during President's Rule
    2. A law made under Article 252
    3. A law made under Article 253
    4. None of these
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Laws made during President's Rule continue only until the state legislature alters or repeals them. Article 252 laws can be changed only by Parliament.

  4. 4. A state bill returned by the President is passed again by the legislature within six months. Which is correct?

    1. The President must give assent
    2. The Governor must give assent
    3. The bill becomes law automatically
    4. The President is not bound to give assent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Under Article 201 the President is not obliged to assent even after reconsideration.

  5. 5. Which provision, besides Article 249, requires a Rajya Sabha resolution supported by two-thirds of members present and voting?

    1. Article 252, for state consent
    2. Article 312, for creating a new All India Service
    3. Article 280, for the Finance Commission
    4. Article 263, for the Inter-State Council
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 312 uses the same Rajya Sabha resolution and majority to create new All India Services.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery