Revision notes

Centre-State Relations: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Article map drill: Articles 245 to 293 at speed

ArticleContentHook
245Extent of laws of Parliament and statesWhere laws run
246Subject-matter: the three listsWho legislates on what
246ASpecial provision on GSTA for the 'add-on' tax power
248Residuary powers with ParliamentLeftovers
249Rajya Sabha resolution, national interestRajya Sabha opens the door
250During a Proclamation of EmergencyEmergency opens it
252Two or more states consentStates open it
253International agreementsTreaties open it
254Inconsistency between Union and state lawsClash rule
ArticleContent
256Obligation of states and the Union
257Control of the Union over states in certain cases
258Union entrusts functions to states (with consent)
258AStates entrust functions to the Union (with consent)
261Full faith and credit
262Inter-state river water disputes
263Inter-State Council
ArticleContent
266Consolidated Funds and public accounts
267Contingency Fund
268Levied by Union, collected and kept by states
269Levied and collected by Union, assigned to states
269AGST on inter-state supply
270Taxes levied and distributed between Union and states
271Surcharge for Union purposes
275Statutory grants-in-aid
279AGST Council
280Finance Commission
282Discretionary grants
292Borrowing by the Union
293Borrowing by states

Legislative 245-255, administrative 256-263, financial 264-293. Ladder: 268 state collects and keeps, 269 Union collects and state keeps, 270 shared, 271 Union only.

  • Learn articles in three groups, not as a long list.
  • Use hooks: doors 249-253, faith-water-council 261-263, the 268-271 ladder.
  • Check neighbouring numbers in matching questions.
  • Use sure pairs to eliminate answer codes.

Redraw the three tables from memory twice this week. Once you can, every later lesson in this course becomes easier, because you will be reasoning with the numbers rather than searching for them.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Legislative relations traps: repugnancy, residuary power and interpretation doctrines

On the Concurrent List, Parliament wins whether earlier or later, unless the state law has the President's assent; and even then Parliament can override it. A law is judged by its substance, not its label.

  • Union law prevails over a repugnant state law on Concurrent subjects regardless of which came first.
  • Only the repugnant part is void.
  • With presidential assent the state law prevails in that state, but Parliament can still override it.
  • Pith and substance saves incidental overlaps; colourable legislation defeats disguised ones.

For statement questions, underline the words 'before', 'after', 'entirely' and 'always'. They mark most of the traps in this topic.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Parliament in the state field: majorities, durations and control of state bills

ProvisionTriggerMajority or conditionLife of the lawWho can change it later
Art. 249Rajya Sabha resolutionTwo-thirds of RS members present and votingResolution: one year, renewable any number of times; law lapses six months after it endsParliament
Art. 250Proclamation under Art. 352Approved emergencyLapses six months after the emergency endsParliament
Art. 252Resolutions of two or more state legislaturesEach state's own resolutionPermanentOnly Parliament
Art. 253Treaty or international decisionOrdinary lawPermanentParliament
Art. 356President's RuleApproved proclamationContinues after President's RuleState legislature, later

Articles 249 and 312: Rajya Sabha, two-thirds of present and voting. Article 249 resolution: one year at a time; law lapses six months after. Article 252 law: only Parliament can change it. President's Rule laws: the state legislature can change them later.

  • Use only 'present and voting' for Rajya Sabha resolutions under Articles 249 and 312.
  • Add six months to the end of the last renewed period, not to the first resolution.
  • Article 252 laws are permanent and only Parliament can amend them.
  • The President is not bound to assent even after a state legislature reconsiders a returned bill.

Most errors in this topic come from mixing up the 'who can change it later' column. Re-read that column before attempting the self-check.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Administrative relations practice: directions, cooperation bodies and disputes

Body or toolBasisNature
Inter-State CouncilArticle 263; set up by presidential order in 1990Advisory; chaired by the Prime Minister
Zonal CouncilsStates Reorganisation Act, 1956Statutory, advisory; five zones (Northern, Central, Eastern, Western, Southern); chaired by the Union Home Minister
North Eastern CouncilNorth Eastern Council Act, 1971Statutory body for the north-eastern states
All India ServicesArticle 312Recruited by the Centre, serve the states
Delegation by consentArticles 258 and 258AVoluntary transfer of functions

Coercive: 256, 257, then 365, then 356. Cooperative: 258 and 258A by consent; Inter-State Council (Article 263); Zonal Councils and the North Eastern Council (statutes); All India Services (Article 312).

  • Non-compliance with Union directions links to Article 356 through Article 365.
  • The Inter-State Council is constitutional; Zonal Councils and the North Eastern Council are statutory.
  • Zonal Councils are chaired by the Union Home Minister; the Inter-State Council by the Prime Minister.
  • Water disputes go to tribunals under the 1956 Act, and Parliament may exclude court jurisdiction.
  • Final civil judgments are executable anywhere in India under Article 261.

When a question lists several bodies, first sort them by basis (Constitution or statute) and by nature (coercive or cooperative). Most options fail one of these two tests.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Financial relations practice: tax categories, grants, the GST Council and reform commissions

ArticleLevied byCollected byKept byExample
268UnionStatesStatesStamp duties on bills of exchange, cheques and promissory notes
269UnionUnionStatesTaxes on inter-state sale and consignment of goods
270UnionUnionSharedIncome tax other than on agricultural income, corporation tax
271UnionUnionUnion onlySurcharges for Union purposes
CommissionSet up bySelected recommendations
Rajamannar Committee (1969)Government of Tamil NaduSet up the Inter-State Council at once; omit Articles 356, 357 and 365; make the Finance Commission a permanent body
Sarkaria Commission (1983)Union governmentA permanent Inter-State Council under Article 263; use Article 356 sparingly, as a last resort; Governor to be an eminent person from outside the state, not too closely involved in its recent politics
Punchhi Commission (2007)Union governmentA second Union commission that reviewed Centre-State relations afresh

GST Council: three-fourths of weighted votes; Union one-third, states two-thirds. The Union needs at least 62.5% of the states' weight with it, and cannot pass anything alone.

  • Ladder: 268 states keep and collect; 269 Union collects, states keep; 270 shared; 271 Union only.
  • Article 275 grants are statutory; Article 282 grants are discretionary.
  • The Finance Commission has a chairman and four members and its advice is not binding.
  • GST Council decisions need three-fourths of weighted votes; neither side can pass a decision alone.
  • Rajamannar (state) sought deletion of Article 356; Sarkaria (Union) sought its sparing use.

For the commissions, remember who appointed each one; it explains the tone of its recommendations and settles most statement questions.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Statement questions: finding the one false word in Centre-State relations

How a true statement is turned false
SwapTrue versionFalse version
MajorityTwo-thirds of members present and voting (Article 249)Two-thirds of the total membership
HouseA resolution of the Rajya Sabha (Article 249)A resolution of the Lok Sabha
Level of governmentResiduary power lies with Parliament (Article 248)Residuary power lies with the states
FundStatutory grants are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India (Article 275)... on the Consolidated Fund of the state
Direction of powerUnion directs the states (Article 256, 257)States direct the Union
QuantifierParliament may legislate on the State List in five situationsParliament may legislate on the State List at any time

Do not ask 'does this sound right?' Ask 'which one word could have been changed?' Check the majority, the House, the fund and the level of government first.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: find the changed word; check majority, House, fund, level of government and quantifier first; remember that one certain statement can eliminate several options.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Numbers, majorities and dates: a calculation drill for Centre-State relations

Fixed numbers and periods
ProvisionNumber or period
Article 249 resolutionTwo-thirds of Rajya Sabha members present and voting; in force up to one year at a time; law ceases six months after the resolution lapses
Article 250 lawCeases six months after the national emergency ends
National emergency (Article 352)Approved within one month; special majority; six months at a time
President's rule (Article 356)Approved within two months; six months at a time; three years at most
Finance Commission (Article 280)Constituted every fifth year or earlier; a chairman and four other members
GST Council (Article 279A)Union one-third and states together two-thirds of the weight; decision needs three-fourths of the weighted votes
Amendment affecting states (Article 368)Special majority plus ratification by not less than half of the states

Write the start date, add the period, then check for any condition. For majorities, compute both tests and use the larger. For shares, compute the pool first, then divide by the ratio.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: the six-month tails of Articles 249 and 250 start from different events; President's rule has a three-year ceiling; the GST arithmetic depends on the Union's one-third weight; and amendments affecting states need ratification by half.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Emergencies, the Governor and Article 3: a mixed drill

Quick map
GroupArticles and their content
Emergencies352 national emergency; 353 effect on Union's executive power; 354 revenue distribution; 355 Union's duty to protect states; 356 President's rule; 357 legislative power under 356; 358 and 359 fundamental rights during emergency; 360 financial emergency
The Governor153 office; 155 appointment; 156 term; 157 qualifications; 158 conditions; 159 oath; 161 clemency; 163 aid and advice; 164 ministers; 174 sessions; 200 and 201 bills; 213 ordinances; 361 immunity
Altering states1 Union of States; 2 admission; 3 formation and alteration; 4 not an amendment under Article 368

Article 3 needs the President's recommendation. An ordinance needs a House not in session. President's rule follows a report and is approved within two months. Financial emergency can reduce judges' salaries.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: learn the Article hooks in groups; for matching, fix the pairs you are sure about first; remember the order of steps in President's rule; check qualifiers such as 'consent' or 'any time'.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Assertion-reason and case-based questions on Centre-State relations

True/false first, 'why' second. A true R that merely sits beside A is option 2, not option 1.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: always judge A and R separately before judging the link; a true R that does not answer 'why' gives option 2; read cases for the Article that fits, then apply its numbers.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery