- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Either-or and possibility conclusions
Recognise when exactly one of two conclusions must be true (either-or) and how to treat conclusions that say something is possible.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some questions give two conclusions neither of which follows alone, yet one of them must be true. These are called either-or cases. Other conclusions talk about what 'can be' or 'is possible'. Both types need a precise rule.
Either-or and possibility
-
Either-or
- Neither conclusion follows alone
- Same two terms
- Opposites: Some with No, or All with Some not
-
Possibility
- 'Some A can be B' or 'It is possible that ...'
- Follows if at least one diagram fits the statements and makes it true
- Fails if every diagram contradicts it
Either-or
Either-or applies when all three conditions hold: (1) the two conclusions have the same two terms (same subject and same predicate); (2) neither conclusion follows on its own from the statements; (3) the two conclusions are opposites, in one of these pairs: Some A are B with No A is B, or All A are B with Some A are not B. Then 'either I or II follows'.
Possibility
A conclusion of the form 'Some A can be B' or 'It is possible that ...' follows if you can draw at least one diagram that fits the statements and makes the conclusion true. It fails if every diagram contradicts it.
Worked examples
Example 1. Statements: All dogs are animals. Some animals are brown. Conclusions: I. Some dogs are brown. II. No dog is brown. Neither follows alone, since the brown animals may or may not be dogs. They have the same terms and are the pair 'Some' versus 'No'. Either I or II follows.
Example 2. Statements: All pens are books. Some books are red. Conclusion: Some pens can be red. Draw a diagram in which the red part of books overlaps pens. It fits both statements, so the possibility follows.
Example 3. Statements: No cat is a dog. Conclusion: Some cats can be dogs. Every diagram has cats and dogs apart, so the possibility does not follow.
Example 4. Statements: Some A are B. Conclusions: I. All A are B. II. Some A are not B. Neither follows alone. I is 'All A are B' and II is 'Some A are not B', which is an opposite pair on the same terms. Either I or II follows.
Either-or needs the same two terms, neither conclusion following alone, and the two being opposites (Some with No, or All with Some not).
Key takeaways
- Test each conclusion alone first; consider either-or only if neither follows.
- The two conclusions must have the same subject and predicate.
- A possibility follows if some diagram makes it true.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: All pens are books. Some books are red. Conclusions: I. Some pens are red. II. No pen is red.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: C. The red books may or may not include pens, so neither conclusion follows alone. They have the same terms (pens, red) and form the opposite pair Some / No, so either I or II follows.
-
2. Which of these is NOT one of the conditions for an either-or answer?
- Both conclusions must be 'Some' statements
- Both conclusions have the same two terms
- Neither conclusion follows on its own
- The two conclusions form an opposite pair
Show answer
Answer: A. Either-or needs the same two terms, neither conclusion following alone, and an opposite pair (Some with No, or All with Some not). The pairs always mix two different forms, so 'both must be Some' is not a condition.
-
3. Statement: No A is B. Conclusion: Some A can be B. What is the verdict?
- Follows: one diagram allows it
- Does not follow: every diagram keeps A and B apart
- Follows: 'No' statements are reversible
- Does not follow: 'can be' conclusions never follow
Show answer
Answer: B. A possibility follows only if at least one diagram fitting the statement makes it true. 'No A is B' forces A and B apart in every diagram, so it does not follow. 'Can be' conclusions do follow in other cases.
-
4. Which pair of conclusions is an opposite pair that can give 'either I or II'?
- All A are B and Some A are B
- Some A are B and Some A are not B
- No A is B and Some A are not B
- All A are B and Some A are not B
Show answer
Answer: D. The two opposite pairs are 'Some A are B' with 'No A is B', and 'All A are B' with 'Some A are not B'. In each pair exactly one must be true. The other pairs can both be true together.
-
5. Statements: All roses are flowers. Some flowers are red. Conclusion: Some roses can be red. What is the verdict?
- Does not follow: no statement links roses with red
- Follows: all roses are red
- Follows: a diagram can be drawn where the red flowers include roses
- Does not follow: two 'Some' statements give no conclusion
Show answer
Answer: C. A possibility needs just one fitting diagram. Draw roses inside flowers and let the red part of flowers overlap roses: both statements stay true, so 'some roses can be red' follows.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.