• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Statements with 'Some are not': what they allow and what they do not

Understand why 'Some A are not B' cannot be reversed, learn the two patterns where it combines with an All statement to give a conclusion, and recognise the pairs that give none.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

'Some A are not B' is the weakest and most awkward of the four forms. It cannot be reversed, and most pairs that include it give no conclusion at all. Knowing exactly which pairs do work, and why, saves you from guessing in the exam.

It cannot be reversed

'Some animals are not dogs' is true. Reverse it to 'Some dogs are not animals' and it becomes false. So 'Some A are not B' never becomes 'Some B are not A'. In a diagram, it only says that part of circle A lies outside circle B. It says nothing about what lies outside circle A.

Pairs that give no conclusion

When 'Some A are not B' meets another statement in the usual order, nothing is forced. The table lists the common cases.

Pairs with 'Some are not' that give nothing
First statementSecond statementConclusion
Some A are not BAll B are CNone
Some A are not BSome B are CNone
Some A are not BNo B is CNone
Some A are not BSome B are not CNone
All A are BSome B are not CNone

The reason is the same each time. The members that lie outside B are unconstrained by the second statement, so they can fall on either side of the next boundary.

The two patterns that do work

Pattern 1: All A are M, Some C are not M. A lies wholly inside M. Some C lie outside M. Anything outside M must also lie outside A. So Some C are not A.

Pattern 2: All M are A, Some M are not C. The M members are all inside A. At least one of them is not C. That member is an A and is not a C. So Some A are not C.

PatternStatementsConclusion
1All A are M; Some C are not MSome C are not A
2All M are A; Some M are not CSome A are not C

A 'Some are not' statement and an All statement give a conclusion only when they share the subject (All M are A, Some M are not C) or share the predicate (All A are M, Some C are not M).

— Rule to remember

Worked examples

Example 1. Statements: All pens are tools. Some boxes are not tools. Conclusion: Some boxes are not pens. This is Pattern 1 with M as 'tools'. A box outside the tools is outside the pens. It follows. The conclusion 'Some pens are not boxes' does not follow, since the pens may all lie inside the boxes.

Example 2. Statements: All coins are metal. Some coins are not old. Conclusion: Some metal things are not old. This is Pattern 2 with M as 'coins'. A coin that is not old is a metal thing that is not old. It follows.

Example 3. Statements: Some fruits are not sweet. All sweet things are tasty. Conclusion: Some fruits are not tasty. The fruits that are not sweet could still be tasty, because the second statement only talks about sweet things. It does not follow.

Example 4. Statements: All schools are big. Some schools are not old. Conclusion: Some big places are not old. M is 'schools', and this is Pattern 2. The schools that are not old are big places that are not old. It follows.

Key takeaways

  • Some A are not B cannot be reversed.
  • It gives a conclusion with an All statement only in Patterns 1 and 2.
  • In every other pairing it gives no conclusion, so reject conclusions that claim one.
  • Draw the circle of the All statement first; the 'some not' part must stay outside it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement is true if the statement 'Some boys are not tall' is true?

    1. Some tall people are not boys
    2. Some boys are not tall
    3. All boys are tall
    4. No boy is tall
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Only the statement itself is certain. Some A are not B cannot be reversed, and it does not say whether any boy is tall.

  2. 2. Statements: All cars are vehicles. Some bikes are not vehicles. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some cars are not bikes
    2. No bike is a car
    3. Some bikes are not cars
    4. Some vehicles are not cars
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Pattern 1: bikes outside the vehicles are outside the cars. 'Some cars are not bikes' is not forced, and 'No bike is a car' is stronger than the statements allow.

  3. 3. Statements: Some students are not girls. All girls are tall. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some students are not tall
    2. Some tall people are not students
    3. No student is tall
    4. None of these three follows
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The statements are in the pair 'Some A are not B, All B are C', which gives no conclusion. Students who are not girls may or may not be tall.

  4. 4. Statements: All tigers are wild. Some tigers are not big. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some wild animals are not big
    2. All wild animals are big
    3. Some big animals are not tigers
    4. No wild animal is big
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Pattern 2 with M as 'tigers': a tiger that is not big is a wild animal that is not big. The other options are not forced.

  5. 5. Statements: All pens are tools. Some tools are not metal. Is 'Some pens are not metal' certain?

    1. Yes, it follows
    2. Yes, because every pen is a tool
    3. No, it does not follow
    4. No, because it contradicts the statements
    Show answer

    Answer: C. This is the pair 'All A are B, Some B are not C', which gives no conclusion. The tools that are not metal may all lie outside the pens.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Syllogism

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery