- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Rearranging statements when the middle term is in a different place
Use reversal and re-ordering to line up two statements whose common term is not in the usual position, and learn the extra rules that give a conclusion in those cases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The rules table from earlier lessons assumes the statements come in a neat order: the first statement ends with the middle term, and the second begins with it. In real questions the common (middle) term can appear anywhere. This lesson shows how to rearrange the statements so that the table applies, and gives the extra rules you need when the middle term is the subject twice or the predicate twice.
Step 1: find the middle term
The middle term is the group that appears in both statements. Call it M, and call the two outer groups A and C. The conclusion will link A and C and will not mention M.
Step 2: reverse safely, then re-order
- No and Some statements may be reversed freely: No A is B becomes No B is A, and Some A are B becomes Some B are A. Nothing is lost.
- All statements may not be reversed. All A are B becomes only Some B are A, which is weaker and throws information away.
- Because an All statement cannot be turned round, you may instead swap the order of the two statements.
- Arrange the pair so that the first ends with M and the second starts with M, then use the table.
Reverse only No and Some statements. To line up an All statement, change the order of the statements instead.
Extra rules for M in the predicate twice
| Statements | Conclusion | How to get it |
|---|---|---|
| All A are M; No C is M | No A is C | Reverse the second: All A are M, No M is C |
| Some A are M; No C is M | Some A are not C | Reverse the second: Some A are M, No M is C |
| No A is M; All C are M | No C is A | Swap the order: All C are M, No M is A |
| All A are M; Some C are not M | Some C are not A | A holds inside M, so a C outside M is outside A |
| All A are M; All C are M | None | Both may sit in different parts of M |
Extra rules for M in the subject twice
| Statements | Conclusion | Why |
|---|---|---|
| All M are A; All M are C | Some A are C | M has members, and they lie in both A and C |
| Some M are A; All M are C | Some A are C | Those M that are A are also C |
| No M is A; All M are C | Some C are not A | M has members; they are C and not A |
| Some M are A; Some M are C | None | The two parts of M may differ |
| No M is A; No M is C | None | A and C both avoid M, but may overlap each other |
Worked examples
Example 1. Statements: All pens are tools. No stone is a tool. Conclusion: No pen is a stone. M is 'tool', the predicate in both. Reverse the second to get No tool is a stone, then All A are B with No B is C gives No pen is a stone. The conclusion follows.
Example 2. Statements: All cats are pets. All dogs are pets. Conclusion: Some cats are dogs. Again M (pets) is the predicate twice, and both statements are All. The row says no conclusion, because cats and dogs may be different parts of pets. It does not follow.
Example 3. Statements: All buses are vehicles. All buses are large. Conclusions: I. Some vehicles are large. II. All vehicles are large. M is 'buses', the subject twice. The rule gives Some vehicles are large, so I follows. II does not, since vehicles that are not buses may not be large. Only I follows.
Example 4. Statements: No metal is wood. All metal is hard. Conclusion: Some hard things are not wood. M is 'metal', the subject twice. The row 'No M is A, All M are C' gives Some C are not A, which is exactly the conclusion. It follows, but 'No hard thing is wood' would not.
Key takeaways
- Find M, then reverse only No and Some statements.
- With M the predicate twice, a conclusion needs one negative statement.
- With M the subject twice, two All statements still give Some, because M has members.
- Two Some statements, or two No statements, give nothing.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: All desks are tables. No chair is a table. Which conclusion follows?
- No desk is a chair
- All desks are chairs
- Some desks are chairs
- Some chairs are desks
Show answer
Answer: A. M is 'table', the predicate in both. Reverse the second statement: No table is a chair. All desks are tables, so no desk is a chair.
-
2. Statements: All books are items. All pens are items. Which conclusion follows?
- Some books are pens
- All books are pens
- No book is a pen
- None of these three follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Both statements are All with M (items) as the predicate. Books and pens may be separate or overlapping parts of items, so no conclusion about them is forced.
-
3. Statements: All trucks are vehicles. All trucks are heavy. Which conclusion follows?
- All vehicles are heavy
- No vehicle is heavy
- Some vehicles are heavy
- Some heavy things are not vehicles
Show answer
Answer: C. M is 'trucks', the subject twice. Trucks exist and are both vehicles and heavy, so Some vehicles are heavy follows. The other options go beyond that.
-
4. Statements: No coin is paper. All coins are round. Which conclusion follows?
- No round thing is paper
- All round things are coins
- Some coins are not round
- Some round things are not paper
Show answer
Answer: D. M is 'coins', the subject twice. 'No M is A, All M are C' gives Some C are not A: some round things are not paper. The other options are not forced, or contradict the statements.
-
5. Statements: Some A are M. Some C are M. What can be concluded about A and C?
- Some A are C
- Nothing definite
- Some A are not C
- No A is C
Show answer
Answer: B. Two Some statements never give a conclusion: the part of M that is A and the part that is C may be different.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.