• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Opposite statements and testing a conclusion by contradiction

Learn which statements contradict each other, which statements imply a weaker one, and how to reject a conclusion quickly because it clashes with what you are given.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many wrong conclusions in a syllogism question can be rejected in seconds, without any diagram, because they directly contradict the statements. This lesson teaches the four pairs of opposite statements and the weaker statements that each form quietly implies. With these two tools you can throw out a false conclusion on sight.

The four pairs of opposites

Two statements are opposites (contradictories) when exactly one of them must be true and the other false. They cannot both be true, and they cannot both be false.

Opposite pairs
If this is trueThen this is falseWhy
All A are BSome A are not BA has no member outside B
No A is BSome A are BA and B share nothing
Some A are BNo A is BAt least one A is in B
Some A are not BAll A are BAt least one A lies outside B

Notice the pattern: All is opposed by Some are not, and No is opposed by Some. 'All' is not opposed by 'No'. If all dogs are animals, then 'No dog is an animal' is false, but it is also not the opposite; it is simply far too strong.

A stronger statement implies a weaker one

Under the usual exam convention that every named group has at least one member, a universal statement carries a particular statement inside it.

  • All A are B implies Some A are B (and so Some B are A).
  • No A is B implies Some A are not B, and also Some B are not A.
  • Some A are B and Some A are not B imply nothing more; they are the weakest forms.

The reverse is not true. 'Some A are B' does not imply 'All A are B', and 'Some A are not B' does not imply 'No A is B'.

A conclusion that is the opposite of a given or derived statement can never follow.

— Rule to remember

Worked examples

Example 1. Statement: All dogs are animals. Conclusion: Some dogs are not animals. This is the opposite of the statement itself, so it is false and does not follow.

Example 2. Statements: All A are B. All B are C. Conclusion: Some A are not C. The table gives All A are C. The conclusion is the opposite of this derived truth, so it does not follow.

Example 3. Statement: Some pens are books. Conclusions: I. No pen is a book. II. Some books are pens. Conclusion I is the opposite of the statement, so it does not follow. Conclusion II is the reverse of the statement, so it follows. Only II follows.

Example 4. Statements: Some A are B. No B is C. Conclusions: I. Some A are not C. II. All A are C. The table gives Some A are not C, so I follows. Conclusion II is the opposite of I, so it cannot be true. Only I follows.

When the opposite is not available

If a conclusion is not contradicted, it is not automatically true. From 'Some A are B', the conclusion 'All A are B' is not contradicted, yet it is not guaranteed either. A conclusion follows only when it is forced. Use this order of checks:

  1. Is the conclusion the opposite of a statement or of something already derived? Then it does not follow.
  2. Is it a legal reversal or a result from the rules table? Then it follows.
  3. Neither? Then it does not follow by itself, and you should test for either-or with its opposite.

Key takeaways

  • Opposites: All with Some are not, and No with Some.
  • All implies Some; No implies Some are not; the converse never holds.
  • A contradicted conclusion never follows, and an uncontradicted one still needs proof.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement is the opposite of 'No bird is a mammal'?

    1. All birds are mammals
    2. Some birds are not mammals
    3. Some birds are mammals
    4. No mammal is a bird
    Show answer

    Answer: C. No A is B is opposed by Some A are B. Exactly one of the two can be true. 'All birds are mammals' is much stronger and is not the opposite.

  2. 2. Statement: All tigers are animals. Which of these cannot be true?

    1. Some tigers are not animals
    2. Some tigers are animals
    3. Some animals are tigers
    4. All animals are tigers
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Some tigers are not animals is the opposite of the statement, so it is false. The other options are true, or at least possible: 'All animals are tigers' can be true if tigers are the only animals in the picture.

  3. 3. Statements: Some A are B. All B are C. Which of these cannot follow?

    1. Some A are C
    2. No A is C
    3. Some C are A
    4. Some B are C
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Some A are B with All B are C gives Some A are C, and the other two options follow from it or from the statements. The opposite of Some A are C is No A is C, which therefore cannot follow.

  4. 4. Statement: No pen is a pencil. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some pens are pencils
    2. All pens are pencils
    3. All pencils are pens
    4. Some pens are not pencils
    Show answer

    Answer: D. No A is B implies Some A are not B (every named group has members). The other options contradict the statement or say something it does not.

  5. 5. Statement: Some roses are red. Is 'All roses are red' certain?

    1. Yes, it is forced
    2. Yes, because some means all
    3. No, it is not forced
    4. No, because it is the opposite
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Some A are B does not imply All A are B. The statement leaves open that some roses are not red. The conclusion is not forced, but it is also not the opposite of the statement.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery