• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mixed syllogism practice

Practise syllogisms with three statements and mixed conclusions, using the rules table first and a diagram to confirm.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Some questions give three statements, or ask for several conclusions at once. Combine the statements two at a time using the rules table, then check each conclusion against the results. Always take the statements as true, however strange they sound.

Working with three statements

Three statements

  1. Combine two Two statements that share a term give an intermediate conclusion.
  2. Add the third Combine that conclusion with the third statement.
  3. Check each conclusion Against everything you have derived.
  4. Doubtful? Draw it Use a diagram.
  1. Combine two statements that share a term to get an intermediate conclusion.
  2. Combine that conclusion with the third statement.
  3. Check each given conclusion against everything you have derived.
  4. For doubtful ones, draw a diagram.

Worked examples

Example 1. Statements: All lions are animals. All animals are mortal. Some mortals are wise. Conclusions: I. All lions are mortal. II. Some wise creatures are mortal. I: from the first two statements, All lions are mortal. II reverses the third statement ('Some mortals are wise' gives 'Some wise are mortals'). Both follow.

Example 2. Statements: Some bats are birds. All birds are flyers. No flyer is a stone. Conclusions: I. Some bats are flyers. II. No bird is a stone. From the first two, Some bats are flyers, so I follows. From the second and third, All birds are flyers and No flyer is a stone give No bird is a stone, so II follows. Both follow.

Example 2, two at a time

  • Statements 1 and 2
    • Some bats are birds
    • All birds are flyers
    • So some bats are flyers: I follows
  • Statements 2 and 3
    • All birds are flyers
    • No flyer is a stone
    • So no bird is a stone: II follows

Example 3. Statements: All books are papers. Some papers are files. Conclusion: Some books are files. All A are B with Some B are C gives no conclusion, so it does not follow.

Example 4. Statements: All A are B. All C are B. Conclusion: All A are C. Both A and C are inside B, but they could be different parts of B. It does not follow. Also, 'Some A are C' does not follow either, because A and C could be separate.

Combine two statements at a time. A conclusion that needs an assumption you were not given does not follow.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Chain statements two at a time.
  • Do not assume overlaps that are not stated.
  • Check reversed conclusions and either-or separately.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statements: All cups are plates. All plates are bowls. Some bowls are glasses. Conclusions: I. All cups are bowls. II. Some glasses are bowls.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The first two statements give 'All cups are bowls', so I follows. II is the third statement reversed ('Some' converts to 'Some'), so it follows too.

  2. 2. Statements: Some men are teachers. All teachers are kind. No kind person is rude. Conclusions: I. Some men are kind. II. All kind people are teachers.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 'Some men are teachers' with 'All teachers are kind' gives 'Some men are kind', so I follows. II reverses an 'All' statement, which is not allowed.

  3. 3. Statements: All A are B. All C are B. Conclusions: I. Some A are C. II. All A are C.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A and C both lie inside B, but they may sit in different parts of B with no overlap. So neither 'Some A are C' nor 'All A are C' is true in every diagram.

  4. 4. Statements: No ball is a bat. All bats are wooden. Conclusions: I. No wooden thing is a ball. II. Some wooden things are not balls.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 'No A is B' with 'All B are C' gives 'Some C are not A', which is II. Balls may still be wooden (in the part of wooden things outside bats), so I does not follow.

  5. 5. Statements: All stones are birds. All birds can sing. Which conclusion follows?

    1. All stones can sing
    2. No stone can sing
    3. All singers are stones
    4. Some birds are not stones
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Accept the statements as true however strange they are. Stones lie inside birds, which lie inside singers, so all stones can sing. Reversing to 'All singers are stones' is not allowed, and nothing forces some birds to be outside stones.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery