- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Rules for two-statement conclusions
Memorise which pairs of statements give a definite conclusion and which give none, so that most questions can be answered without a diagram.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Drawing diagrams is safe but slow. For two statements that share a middle term, a small table of rules gives the answer in seconds. These rules assume the usual exam convention that every named group has at least one member.
Rules (the middle term links the two statements)
| Statement 1 | Statement 2 | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | All B are C | All A are C |
| All A are B | Some B are C | No definite conclusion |
| Some A are B | All B are C | Some A are C |
| All A are B | No B is C | No A is C |
| No A is B | All B are C | Some C are not A |
| Some A are B | No B is C | Some A are not C |
| Some A are B | Some B are C | No definite conclusion |
| No A is B | No B is C | No definite conclusion |
Two general warnings
Pairs with no definite conclusion
- Some A are B + Some B are C Two 'Some' statements.
- No A is B + No B is C Two 'No' statements.
- All A are B + Some B are C
- Two 'Some' statements never give a conclusion. Two 'No' statements never give a conclusion.
- If a conclusion is just a reversed form of a statement (see Lesson 1), or of a conclusion from the table, it also follows.
Worked examples
Example 1. Statements: All pens are books. All books are papers. Conclusions: I. All pens are papers. II. Some papers are pens. From the table, I follows. Reversing I (All to Some) gives II, so II also follows. Both follow.
Example 1: table, then reversal
- All pens are books; all books are papers
- All pens are papers From the table: conclusion I follows.
- Some papers are pens Reversing I (All to Some): conclusion II follows.
Example 2. Statements: Some doctors are teachers. All teachers are honest. Conclusions: I. Some doctors are honest. II. All honest people are teachers. By the table, 'Some A are B, All B are C' gives 'Some A are C', so I follows. II reverses an 'All', so it does not follow. Only I follows.
Example 3. Statements: No fish is a bird. All birds can fly. Conclusions: I. Some flying creatures are not fish. II. No bird is a fish. 'No A is B, All B are C' gives 'Some C are not A', which is I. II is a reversal of statement 1. Both follow.
Example 4. Statements: All A are B. Some B are C. Conclusions: I. Some A are C. II. Some C are A. The table says no definite conclusion. Neither follows.
Two particular (Some) statements, or two negative (No) statements, never give a conclusion.
Key takeaways
- Learn the eight rows of the table.
- Check reversed conclusions separately.
- If in doubt, draw the Venn diagrams.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: Some A are B. All B are C. Which conclusion follows?
- All A are C
- No definite conclusion
- Some A are not C
- Some A are C
Show answer
Answer: D. The A members that are B lie inside B, which lies inside C, so those A members are C. Nothing is known about the other A members, so 'All A are C' does not follow.
-
2. Statements: No A is B. All B are C. Which conclusion follows?
- No A is C
- Some C are not A
- No C is A
- Some A are not C
Show answer
Answer: B. From the rules table, 'No A is B' with 'All B are C' gives 'Some C are not A': the B members inside C are not A. A may still overlap the part of C outside B, so 'No A is C' does not follow.
-
3. Which pair of statements never gives a definite conclusion?
- Some A are B and Some B are C
- All A are B and All B are C
- Some A are B and All B are C
- All A are B and No B is C
Show answer
Answer: A. Two 'Some' statements never give a conclusion. The other pairs give All A are C, Some A are C and No A is C.
-
4. Statements: Some cars are red. No red thing is cheap. Which conclusion follows?
- No car is cheap
- Some cars are not cheap
- Some cheap things are not cars
- Some cars are cheap
Show answer
Answer: B. 'Some A are B' with 'No B is C' gives 'Some A are not C': the cars that are red are not cheap. Other cars may or may not be cheap, so 'No car is cheap' and 'Some cars are cheap' do not follow, and cheap things could all be cars.
-
5. Statements: All boys are students. All students are young. Conclusions: I. All boys are young. II. Some young people are boys.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: C. 'All A are B' with 'All B are C' gives 'All A are C', so I follows. II is I reversed ('All' converts to 'Some'), so it follows too. Both follow.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.