Revision notes

Syllogism: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Statements and the four basic forms

The four forms

  • Universal
    • All A are B (affirmative)
    • No A is B (negative)
  • Particular
    • Some A are B (affirmative)
    • Some A are not B (negative)
FormStatementMeaning
Universal affirmativeAll A are BEvery member of A is also a member of B
Universal negativeNo A is BA and B have no member in common
Particular affirmativeSome A are BAt least one member of A is a member of B
Particular negativeSome A are not BAt least one member of A is not a member of B

Reversing a statement

  • Reverses fully
    • No A is B gives No B is A
    • Some A are B gives Some B are A
  • Reverses only to 'Some'
    • All A are B gives Some B are A
    • All A are B does not give All B are A

All A are B gives Some B are A. Some A are B gives Some B are A. No A is B gives No B is A. All A are B does not give All B are A.

— Conversions to remember
  • Learn the four forms and which of them can be reversed.
  • Accept the statements as true, whatever you know.
  • 'Some' includes the possibility of 'all' but does not promise it.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Venn diagrams for syllogisms

Each statement as circles

  • All A are B Circle A lies completely inside circle B (or is the same as B).
  • No A is B The circles are separate, with no overlap.
  • Some A are B The circles overlap, or one lies inside the other.
  • Some A are not B Part of A lies outside B.

Testing with Venn diagrams

  1. Draw both statements One circle per group, linked through the common group.
  2. Draw every arrangement For example, a small or a large overlap.
  3. True in all of them? Then the conclusion follows.
  4. False in any one? Then it does not follow.

A conclusion follows only if it is true in every possible Venn diagram of the statements.

— Rule to remember
  • One circle per group.
  • Draw every allowed arrangement.
  • Only a conclusion true in all arrangements follows.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Rules for two-statement conclusions

Statement 1Statement 2Conclusion
All A are BAll B are CAll A are C
All A are BSome B are CNo definite conclusion
Some A are BAll B are CSome A are C
All A are BNo B is CNo A is C
No A is BAll B are CSome C are not A
Some A are BNo B is CSome A are not C
Some A are BSome B are CNo definite conclusion
No A is BNo B is CNo definite conclusion

Pairs with no definite conclusion

  • Some A are B + Some B are C Two 'Some' statements.
  • No A is B + No B is C Two 'No' statements.
  • All A are B + Some B are C

Example 1: table, then reversal

  1. All pens are books; all books are papers
  2. All pens are papers From the table: conclusion I follows.
  3. Some papers are pens Reversing I (All to Some): conclusion II follows.

Two particular (Some) statements, or two negative (No) statements, never give a conclusion.

— Rule to remember
  • Learn the eight rows of the table.
  • Check reversed conclusions separately.
  • If in doubt, draw the Venn diagrams.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Either-or and possibility conclusions

Either-or and possibility

  • Either-or
    • Neither conclusion follows alone
    • Same two terms
    • Opposites: Some with No, or All with Some not
  • Possibility
    • 'Some A can be B' or 'It is possible that ...'
    • Follows if at least one diagram fits the statements and makes it true
    • Fails if every diagram contradicts it

Either-or needs the same two terms, neither conclusion following alone, and the two being opposites (Some with No, or All with Some not).

— Rule to remember
  • Test each conclusion alone first; consider either-or only if neither follows.
  • The two conclusions must have the same subject and predicate.
  • A possibility follows if some diagram makes it true.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Mixed syllogism practice

Three statements

  1. Combine two Two statements that share a term give an intermediate conclusion.
  2. Add the third Combine that conclusion with the third statement.
  3. Check each conclusion Against everything you have derived.
  4. Doubtful? Draw it Use a diagram.

Example 2, two at a time

  • Statements 1 and 2
    • Some bats are birds
    • All birds are flyers
    • So some bats are flyers: I follows
  • Statements 2 and 3
    • All birds are flyers
    • No flyer is a stone
    • So no bird is a stone: II follows

Combine two statements at a time. A conclusion that needs an assumption you were not given does not follow.

— Rule to remember
  • Chain statements two at a time.
  • Do not assume overlaps that are not stated.
  • Check reversed conclusions and either-or separately.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Everyday wording: turning sentences into the four forms

Translating common wordings
Standard formEveryday wordingsExample
All A are BEvery A is B; each A is B; any A is B; all of the A are BEvery pen is a tool: All pens are tools
No A is BNone of the A is B; not a single A is B; there is no A that is BNot a single stone is soft: No stone is soft
Some A are BA few A are B; several A are B; at least one A is B; some of the A are BAt least one nurse is tall: Some nurses are tall
Some A are not BNot all A are B; not every A is B; a few A are not B; at least one A is not BNot all fruits are sweet: Some fruits are not sweet

Only A are B means All B are A. Not all A are B means Some A are not B.

— Rule to remember
  • Every, each and any mean All; none and not a single mean No.
  • A few, several and at least one mean Some; not all and not every mean Some are not.
  • 'Only A are B' means All B are A: the group after 'only' becomes the predicate.
  • Translate first, test second.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Opposite statements and testing a conclusion by contradiction

Opposite pairs
If this is trueThen this is falseWhy
All A are BSome A are not BA has no member outside B
No A is BSome A are BA and B share nothing
Some A are BNo A is BAt least one A is in B
Some A are not BAll A are BAt least one A lies outside B

A conclusion that is the opposite of a given or derived statement can never follow.

— Rule to remember
  • Opposites: All with Some are not, and No with Some.
  • All implies Some; No implies Some are not; the converse never holds.
  • A contradicted conclusion never follows, and an uncontradicted one still needs proof.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Rearranging statements when the middle term is in a different place

Reverse only No and Some statements. To line up an All statement, change the order of the statements instead.

— Rule to remember
M is the predicate of both statements
StatementsConclusionHow to get it
All A are M; No C is MNo A is CReverse the second: All A are M, No M is C
Some A are M; No C is MSome A are not CReverse the second: Some A are M, No M is C
No A is M; All C are MNo C is ASwap the order: All C are M, No M is A
All A are M; Some C are not MSome C are not AA holds inside M, so a C outside M is outside A
All A are M; All C are MNoneBoth may sit in different parts of M
M is the subject of both statements
StatementsConclusionWhy
All M are A; All M are CSome A are CM has members, and they lie in both A and C
Some M are A; All M are CSome A are CThose M that are A are also C
No M is A; All M are CSome C are not AM has members; they are C and not A
Some M are A; Some M are CNoneThe two parts of M may differ
No M is A; No M is CNoneA and C both avoid M, but may overlap each other
  • Find M, then reverse only No and Some statements.
  • With M the predicate twice, a conclusion needs one negative statement.
  • With M the subject twice, two All statements still give Some, because M has members.
  • Two Some statements, or two No statements, give nothing.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Statements with 'Some are not': what they allow and what they do not

Pairs with 'Some are not' that give nothing
First statementSecond statementConclusion
Some A are not BAll B are CNone
Some A are not BSome B are CNone
Some A are not BNo B is CNone
Some A are not BSome B are not CNone
All A are BSome B are not CNone
PatternStatementsConclusion
1All A are M; Some C are not MSome C are not A
2All M are A; Some M are not CSome A are not C

A 'Some are not' statement and an All statement give a conclusion only when they share the subject (All M are A, Some M are not C) or share the predicate (All A are M, Some C are not M).

— Rule to remember
  • Some A are not B cannot be reversed.
  • It gives a conclusion with an All statement only in Patterns 1 and 2.
  • In every other pairing it gives no conclusion, so reject conclusions that claim one.
  • Draw the circle of the All statement first; the 'some not' part must stay outside it.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery