- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Spot the correct equation: checking and deriving by dimensions
Test candidate formulas for dimensional consistency and derive exponents in short relations, with the exam traps that catch careless students.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Two kinds of questions use the principle of homogeneity again and again. In one you are given several formulae and must pick the one that can be correct. In the other you are told what a quantity depends on and must find the exponents. Both reduce to the same routine: write the dimensions of each symbol, and make both sides match. This lesson drills that routine.
Question type 1: which formula can be right?
Write the dimensions of every term in each option. An option fails as soon as one term does not match the others, or the left side does not match the right. An option that passes is only dimensionally possible; it still may have a wrong numerical factor, but in a multiple-choice question there is usually only one survivor.
Question type 2: find the exponents
- Write the relation as quantity = k × (first)^a × (second)^b × (third)^c, where k is a pure number.
- Replace each symbol by its dimensions.
- Equate the powers of M, L and T on both sides. This gives one equation for each base quantity.
- Solve and check by substituting back.
Worked examples
Example 1. A mass m on a spring of constant k oscillates with period T. Which is possible: T = 2π√(m/k) or T = 2π√(k/m)? Since k = [M T⁻²], m/k = [M] ÷ [M T⁻²] = [T²], so √(m/k) = [T]. The first form is dimensionally correct. The second gives [T⁻¹], a frequency, so it is wrong.
Example 2. The speed of a wave on a string depends on the tension T = [M L T⁻²] and mass per unit length μ = [M L⁻¹]. Let v = k T^a μ^b. Mass: a + b = 0. Time: −2a = −1, so a = ½ and b = −½. Length: a − b = ½ + ½ = 1, which matches [L T⁻¹]. So v = k√(T/μ).
Example 3. The centripetal force F depends on mass m, speed v and radius r. Let F = k m^a v^b r^c. Mass: a = 1. Time: −b = −2, so b = 2. Length: b + c = 1, so c = −1. Thus F = k m v²/r. Dimensional analysis cannot give k, but experiment and theory show k = 1.
Example 4. The kinetic energy of a body is written in terms of its momentum p and mass m as E = k p^a m^b. With p = [M L T⁻¹] and E = [M L² T⁻²]: Time: −a = −2, so a = 2. Length: a = 2, which matches. Mass: a + b = 1, so b = −1. Hence E = k p²/m, and indeed k = ½.
Example 5. In x = a + bt + ct², where x is in metres and t in seconds, find the units of a, b and c. Every term must be a length. So a is in m, bt is in m so b is in m/s, and ct² is in m so c is in m/s².
Traps
- A term inside a square root, such as √(gh + something), must have the same dimensions as gh before the root is taken.
- Adding quantities such as force and energy is always wrong, however neat the formula looks.
- A formula can pass the dimensional test and still be wrong. Dimensions cannot detect a wrong numerical constant, so KE = mv² passes just as KE = ½mv² does.
Only quantities of the same dimensions may be added or equated. To derive: equate the powers of M, L and T on both sides.
Key takeaways
- To choose the right formula, check each option term by term.
- To derive a relation, set up one equation per base quantity.
- Dimensional analysis never gives pure numbers such as ½ or 2π.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which equation is dimensionally correct, with symbols having their usual meanings?
- v = u + a t²
- s = u t + a t
- v = u² + 2 a s
- v² = u² + 2 a s
Show answer
Answer: D. In v² = u² + 2as every term has dimensions [L² T⁻²]. In the others the terms have different dimensions.
-
2. If the kinetic energy E depends on momentum p and mass m as E = k p^a m^b, then:
- E ∝ p m
- E ∝ p²/m
- E ∝ p/m²
- E ∝ p m²
Show answer
Answer: B. Time gives a = 2. Mass gives a + b = 1, so b = −1. Hence E ∝ p²/m.
-
3. In x = a t² + b t, with x in metres and t in seconds, the unit of b is:
- m s
- m/s²
- m
- m/s
Show answer
Answer: D. The term b t must be a length in metres, so b has the unit m/s.
-
4. Which expression has the dimensions of speed? (F is force, m is mass, l is length)
- √(F l / m)
- √(F / m)
- √(F m / l)
- √(F l m)
Show answer
Answer: A. F l / m = [M L T⁻²][L] ÷ [M] = [L² T⁻²], and its square root is [L T⁻¹], a speed.
-
5. Which two quantities can be added together?
- force and energy
- speed and acceleration
- pressure and ρgh
- power and work
Show answer
Answer: C. ρgh = [M L⁻³][L T⁻²][L] = [M L⁻¹ T⁻²], the same as pressure. The other pairs differ in dimensions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.