• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Assertion-reason and 'how many are correct' sets on the emergency Articles

Work through statement sets and assertion-reason items on Articles 352, 356, 358, 359 and 360 using a truth-key method that handles each statement alone.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Emergency questions are built to confuse. The same word, 'approval', appears for all three emergencies with different time limits and different majorities; the same word, 'rights', hides the difference between Article 358 and Article 359. The surest defence is to hold a small truth key in your head and test every statement against it, one at a time.

The truth key

Truth key for the three emergencies
PointArticle 352Article 356Article 360
GroundWar, external aggression, armed rebellionFailure of constitutional machinery in a stateThreat to financial stability or credit
Approval withinOne monthTwo monthsTwo months
MajoritySpecial majoritySimple majoritySimple majority
DurationSix months at a time; no maximumSix months at a time; maximum three yearsUntil revoked

Worked example 1: how many are correct?

Statements: (1) A National Emergency can be proclaimed on the ground of internal disturbance. (2) A National Emergency needs approval within one month. (3) President's Rule needs approval by a special majority. (4) A Financial Emergency needs no six-monthly renewal. Working: (1) is false, since 'armed rebellion' replaced 'internal disturbance' in 1978. (2) is true. (3) is false, because a simple majority is enough. (4) is true. So two statements, (2) and (4), are correct. Answer: two.

Worked example 2: assertion and reason, case A

Assertion (A): President's Rule cannot ordinarily continue beyond one year. Reason (R): For it to continue beyond one year, a National Emergency must be in operation and the Election Commission must certify that continuation is necessary. Working: Step 1, A is true, because after one year special conditions apply. Step 2, R is true. Both conditions are required together. Step 3, R explains A, because the conditions are the reason why a second year is not ordinary. Answer: both are true and R is the correct explanation.

Worked example 3: assertion and reason, case B

Assertion (A): A Financial Emergency must be renewed every six months. Reason (R): A Financial Emergency lasts until it is revoked by the President. Working: A is false, since there is no six-monthly renewal. R is true. Answer: A is false and R is true. Notice that R is actually the reason why A is false.

Worked example 4: articles 358 and 359

Statements: (1) Article 358 suspends Article 19 automatically. (2) Article 359 suspends Article 19 automatically. (3) Article 359 order cannot suspend the right to move court for Articles 20 and 21. (4) Article 358 operates on all three grounds of emergency. Working: (1) true. (2) false, because 359 works by a presidential order and suspends enforcement, not the right. (3) true. (4) false: Article 358 operates only when the emergency is declared on the ground of war or external aggression. So (1) and (3) are correct. Answer: two.

Check each statement against the truth key. In assertion-reason questions, judge A and R separately, then ask whether R explains A.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • A truth key of ground, approval time, majority and duration settles most items.
  • Article 358 is automatic and limited to war or external aggression; Article 359 needs an order.
  • In assertion-reason questions, a false assertion with a true reason is common for the Financial Emergency.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Consider: (1) National Emergency needs approval by special majority. (2) Financial Emergency needs approval within one month. How many are correct?

    1. Only (1)
    2. Only (2)
    3. Both (1) and (2)
    4. Neither (1) nor (2)
    Show answer

    Answer: A. (1) is true. (2) is false: a Financial Emergency must be approved within two months.

  2. 2. A: A National Emergency on armed rebellion does not suspend Article 19 automatically. R: Article 358 operates only on war or external aggression. Choose the best answer.

    1. A is true and R is false
    2. A is false and R is true
    3. Both are true; R explains A
    4. Both A and R are false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. On armed rebellion Article 358 does not apply, so A is true; R states the reason.

  3. 3. Which emergency can last for a maximum of three years?

    1. National Emergency
    2. President's Rule
    3. Financial Emergency
    4. All three
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Only President's Rule has a fixed maximum of three years.

  4. 4. The majority needed to approve President's Rule is:

    1. two-thirds of members present and voting
    2. a majority of the total membership
    3. three-fourths of the members
    4. a simple majority
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Approval of Article 356 needs only a simple majority.

  5. 5. Which of the following is TRUE of Article 359?

    1. It operates automatically
    2. It works only on war or external aggression
    3. It suspends Articles 20 and 21
    4. It works by a Presidential order
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 359 works by an order of the President. It cannot suspend enforcement of Articles 20 and 21.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery