• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Fundamental rights during an emergency: Articles 358 and 359

Distinguish the automatic suspension of Article 19 under Article 358 from the President's order under Article 359, and apply both to scenarios.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The most conceptual part of the emergency provisions is what happens to fundamental rights. Two articles do the work, and exams love to swap their features. Article 358 deals only with Article 19 and works automatically. Article 359 works only through a presidential order and can reach other rights, with two important exceptions. Once you can fill in a comparison table from memory, most questions become simple.

Article 358: Article 19 is suspended automatically

Article 19 guarantees six freedoms, including speech and expression, assembly, association and movement. As soon as a National Emergency is proclaimed on the ground of war or external aggression, Article 358 suspends these freedoms automatically; no separate order is needed. The State may then make any law or take any executive action that would otherwise violate Article 19. Since the 44th Amendment, Article 358 does not operate when the emergency is proclaimed on the ground of armed rebellion. When the emergency ends, Article 19 revives automatically. Laws inconsistent with Article 19 stop operating to that extent, but nothing done during the emergency can be challenged afterwards.

The 44th Amendment added a further limit. The protection of Article 358 covers only a law that contains a recital saying it is made in relation to the emergency, and executive action taken under such a law. A law with no such recital can be challenged for violating Article 19 even during the emergency.

Article 359: suspending the right to go to court

Article 359 lets the President, by order, suspend the right to move any court for the enforcement of the fundamental rights named in the order. It is important to read this carefully: the rights themselves are not suspended, only their enforcement through the courts. The order may cover the whole emergency or a shorter period, may extend to the whole of India or a part, and must be laid before each House of Parliament. It can be used whatever the ground of the emergency, including armed rebellion.

After the 44th Amendment, the President cannot suspend the right to move court for the enforcement of Article 20 (protection in respect of conviction for offences) and Article 21 (protection of life and personal liberty). This change followed the experience of the 1975 emergency and the Supreme Court's decision in the ADM Jabalpur case (1976), which had held that a person could not approach the court for enforcement of Article 21 while such an order was in force. That decision was later overruled. As with Article 358, protection under Article 359 extends only to laws that recite their connection with the emergency.

Article 358 compared with Article 359
FeatureArticle 358Article 359
Rights affectedOnly Article 19Rights named in the President's order
How it operatesAutomaticallyOnly by presidential order
GroundsWar or external aggression onlyAny ground of National Emergency
What is suspendedThe Article 19 rights themselvesThe right to move court for enforcement
ExceptionsNone neededArticles 20 and 21 can never be named
DurationWhole period of the emergencyPeriod specified in the order

Worked example 1: emergency on armed rebellion

An emergency is proclaimed on the ground of armed rebellion. The government wants to ban public assemblies in the affected area. Step 1: is Article 19 suspended automatically? No, because Article 358 applies only to war or external aggression. Step 2: can it still act? Yes, the President may issue an order under Article 359 naming Article 19, which suspends the right to move court to enforce it. Step 3: can that order also name Article 21? No; Articles 20 and 21 are outside the reach of Article 359.

Worked example 2: a law without a recital

During an emergency on the ground of external aggression, a state passes a law restricting the movement of journalists. The law does not say that it is made in relation to the emergency. A journalist challenges it. Step 1: Article 19 is suspended under Article 358. Step 2: but Article 358(2) withholds protection from a law without the recital. Step 3: the law can therefore be tested against Article 19 in court. The missing recital is decisive.

Article 358: Article 19 only, automatic, war or external aggression only. Article 359: by order, any ground, any right except Articles 20 and 21.

Key takeaways

  • Article 358 suspends Article 19 automatically, but only in an emergency on war or external aggression.
  • Article 359 suspends the remedy, not the right, and needs a presidential order.
  • Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended through Article 359 since the 44th Amendment.
  • Both articles protect only laws that state their connection with the emergency.

A quick test for any statement: ask which article it describes, then check the ground and the right it names. If a statement says Article 21 was suspended under the present Constitution, it is wrong.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Article 358 automatically suspends which fundamental right?

    1. Article 21
    2. Article 19
    3. Article 14
    4. All fundamental rights
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 358 deals only with the freedoms guaranteed by Article 19.

  2. 2. On which ground of emergency does Article 358 NOT operate?

    1. War
    2. External aggression
    3. Armed rebellion
    4. It operates on all three
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Since the 44th Amendment, Article 358 applies only when the emergency is on the ground of war or external aggression, not armed rebellion.

  3. 3. The right to move court for the enforcement of which articles cannot be suspended under Article 359?

    1. Articles 20 and 21
    2. Articles 14 and 19
    3. Articles 19 and 21
    4. Articles 32 and 226
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The 44th Amendment excluded Articles 20 and 21 from the reach of an order under Article 359.

  4. 4. Assess the statement: 'Article 359 suspends the fundamental rights named in the President's order.'

    1. Correct as stated
    2. Incorrect: it suspends the right to move courts for their enforcement
    3. Incorrect: it can suspend only Article 19
    4. Incorrect: it applies only during a Financial Emergency
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Under Article 359 the rights continue to exist; what is suspended is the right to approach a court to enforce them.

  5. 5. During an emergency on the ground of external aggression, a law restricting speech is passed without any recital linking it to the emergency. Can it be challenged under Article 19?

    1. No, it cannot be challenged at all
    2. Only after the emergency ends
    3. Only in a High Court
    4. Yes, because the protection of Article 358 covers only laws stated to relate to the emergency
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 358(2), inserted by the 44th Amendment, denies protection to a law that does not contain a recital that it is made in relation to the emergency, so it can be challenged.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery