- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Revoking a National Emergency and its effects on the federal system
Apply the rules for revoking a National Emergency and work out how it changes the powers of the Union, the states and the life of the Lok Sabha.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Once you know how a National Emergency begins, the next layer of questions asks how it ends and what it changes while it lasts. These questions reward precise recall of numbers: one-tenth, 14 days, six months, one year, end of the financial year. This lesson sets out each number with the reason behind it, so that you can rebuild it under exam pressure rather than guess.
How the emergency ends
The President may revoke a proclamation at any time by a later proclamation. Revocation needs no approval from Parliament. In addition, the President must revoke it if the Lok Sabha passes a resolution disapproving the proclamation or its continuance. That resolution needs only a simple majority of the members present and voting, and only the Lok Sabha passes it; the Rajya Sabha has no role. Notice the deliberate asymmetry: keeping the emergency alive needs a special majority in both Houses, but ending it needs a simple majority in one House. The 44th Amendment designed it this way so that the elected House could pull the country out of an emergency easily.
To make this possible even when Parliament is not sitting, members holding at least one-tenth of the total membership of the Lok Sabha may give written notice of their intention to move such a resolution. The notice goes to the Speaker if the House is in session, or to the President if it is not. A special sitting must be held within 14 days of the notice being received.
Effects on Centre-State relations
During a National Emergency the federal structure works in a unitary way, but the state governments and legislatures are not suspended. That is the key difference from President's Rule. Three changes happen. Executive: under Article 353 the Union may give directions to any state on the manner in which it exercises its executive power, on any matter, not only on the usual subjects. Legislative: under Article 250 Parliament may make laws on any subject in the State List; the state legislature keeps its power but Union law prevails. Such Union laws cease to have effect six months after the emergency ends. Article 353 also lets Parliament confer powers and impose duties on Union officers even in matters outside the Union List. Financial: under Article 354 the President may by order modify the constitutional distribution of revenue between the Union and the states. Such an order lasts until the end of the financial year in which the emergency ends, and it must be laid before each House of Parliament.
Effect on the life of legislatures
While a proclamation is in operation, Parliament may extend the normal five-year term of the Lok Sabha by law, by not more than one year at a time, and never beyond six months after the proclamation ceases to operate (Article 83(2)). Parliament may extend the term of a state Legislative Assembly in the same manner and within the same limits (Article 172(1)).
| Effect | Article | Time limit |
|---|---|---|
| Union directions to states on any matter | 353 | While the emergency lasts |
| Parliament legislates on State List | 250 | Law lapses six months after the emergency ends |
| Revenue distribution modified | 354 | Till the end of the financial year in which the emergency ends |
| Lok Sabha term extended | 83(2) | One year at a time; not beyond six months after the emergency ends |
Worked example 1: the notice
Take an illustrative Lok Sabha of 540 members. One-tenth of 540 is 54, so at least 54 members must sign the written notice. Suppose the House is not in session and the President receives the notice on 3 March. The special sitting must be held within 14 days, that is by 17 March. If the resolution is then carried by a simple majority of those present and voting, the President must revoke the proclamation.
Worked example 2: lapse of laws and orders
Parliament, under Article 250, passes a law on a State List subject during an emergency. The emergency is revoked on 1 June. The law continues to operate for six months and lapses at the start of December, except for things already done under it. In the same emergency the President had modified revenue sharing under Article 354. The financial year runs from April to March, so an emergency that ends on 1 June brings the order to an end on 31 March of the following year.
Worked example 3: extension of the Lok Sabha
Suppose the Lok Sabha's normal term would end on 1 May. During an emergency Parliament extends it by one year, to 1 May of the next year. The emergency is revoked on 1 August, well before that. The term may not continue beyond six months after revocation, that is 1 February. So the House can last only until 1 February, not until 1 May.
To stay, an emergency needs a special majority in both Houses every six months; to go, it needs only a simple majority in the Lok Sabha.
Key takeaways
- Revocation by the President needs no parliamentary approval.
- A Lok Sabha disapproval resolution passed by simple majority forces revocation; one-tenth of members can demand a special sitting within 14 days.
- States keep their governments and legislatures, but the Union directs and legislates over them.
- Six months after the end: laws under Article 250 lapse, and an extended Lok Sabha must end by then.
- Article 354 orders run to the end of the financial year.
When a question mixes these numbers, list the four time limits from the table before reading the options. Wrong options usually swap two of them, such as giving the Article 354 order a six-month life.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which body can force the revocation of a National Emergency by passing a resolution with a simple majority?
- Rajya Sabha
- A joint sitting of both Houses
- Lok Sabha
- Union Cabinet
Show answer
Answer: C. Only the Lok Sabha can pass the disapproval resolution, by a simple majority of members present and voting; the President must then revoke the proclamation.
-
2. In an illustrative Lok Sabha of 540 members, how many members at least must sign the notice seeking a special sitting to disapprove an emergency?
- 54
- 108
- 180
- 271
Show answer
Answer: A. One-tenth of the total membership: 540 ÷ 10 = 54.
-
3. A law made by Parliament under Article 250 on a State List subject during an emergency ceases to have effect:
- Immediately when the emergency ends
- Six months after the emergency ends
- One year after the emergency ends
- At the end of the financial year
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 250(2): such a law ceases to have effect, to the extent Parliament was otherwise not competent, on the expiry of six months after the proclamation ceases to operate.
-
4. An order under Article 354 modifying the distribution of revenues remains in force:
- For six months after the emergency ends
- For one year after it is made
- Until Parliament repeals it
- Until the end of the financial year in which the emergency ends
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 354 limits such an order to the end of the financial year in which the proclamation ceases to operate.
-
5. During a National Emergency, the legislature of a state:
- Is dissolved automatically
- Is suspended until the emergency ends
- Continues, but Parliament may also make laws on State List subjects
- Loses power only over the Concurrent List
Show answer
Answer: C. A National Emergency does not suspend or dissolve state legislatures. Their power becomes subject to Parliament's overriding power under Article 250.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.