- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Financial Emergency under Article 360 and the three emergencies compared
State the rules and effects of a Financial Emergency and use a single comparison table to answer mixed questions on all three emergencies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The third type of emergency, under Article 360, is the shortest to learn and easy to confuse with the others. After learning it, this lesson brings all three types into one table, because the hardest practice questions ask you to compare them, for example 'Which of the following needs a special majority?' or 'Which has no maximum duration?'
When a Financial Emergency can be proclaimed
The President may proclaim a Financial Emergency if satisfied that a situation has arisen whereby the financial stability or credit of India or of any part of its territory is threatened. The proclamation must be approved by both Houses within two months by a simple majority. Once approved it continues indefinitely, until revoked; unlike the other two types, it needs no repeated approval and has no maximum period. The President can revoke it at any time without Parliament's approval. As with the other types, if the Lok Sabha is dissolved, the Rajya Sabha's approval keeps it alive until 30 days after the new Lok Sabha first sits.
Effects
- The Union may give directions to states to observe the canons of financial propriety it specifies.
- The Union may direct reduction of salaries and allowances of all or any class of persons serving in a state.
- The Union may require all money bills and other financial bills of a state to be reserved for the President's consideration after the legislature passes them.
- The President may direct reduction of salaries and allowances of persons serving the Union, including judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts.
Note the last effect carefully. The salaries of judges are normally protected from being reduced to their disadvantage during their term; a Financial Emergency is the exception. Note also that a Financial Emergency does not by itself suspend any fundamental right; Articles 358 and 359 apply only to a proclamation under Article 352.
The three emergencies in one table
| Feature | Article 352 | Article 356 | Article 360 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basis | War, external aggression, armed rebellion | Failure of constitutional machinery in a state | Threat to financial stability or credit |
| Approval deadline | One month | Two months | Two months |
| Majority | Special | Simple | Simple |
| Period after approval | Six months, renewable | Six months, renewable | Indefinite |
| Maximum | None | Three years | None |
| Lok Sabha disapproval forces revocation | Yes | No such provision | No such provision |
| Effect on fundamental rights | Articles 358 and 359 | None directly | None directly |
Worked example 1: elimination with the table
Question: 'Which emergency, once approved, continues without any further approval of Parliament?' Run down the 'Period after approval' row. Articles 352 and 356 both need approval every six months, so they are eliminated. Article 360 continues indefinitely. Answer: Financial Emergency. Time taken: a few seconds, once the table is in your head.
Worked example 2: a three-statement question
Consider: (1) All three emergencies must be approved within two months. (2) Only a National Emergency needs a special majority. (3) A Financial Emergency allows the President to reduce the salaries of Supreme Court judges. Statement 1 is false, because Article 352 needs approval within one month. Statement 2 is true: Articles 356 and 360 need only a simple majority. Statement 3 is true. So statements 2 and 3 are correct. A common wrong answer chooses all three by forgetting the 44th Amendment's one-month rule.
Worked example 3: which article is it?
A statement reads: 'During this emergency the President may require state money bills to be reserved for his consideration.' Money bills and salaries are the signature of Article 360. Under Article 356 the state legislature is suspended or dissolved, so reserving its bills makes no sense, and Article 352 has its own financial effect, the revenue modification under Article 354, which is different.
Article 360: financial stability or credit; two months; simple majority; no renewal and no maximum; the Union controls state finances and can cut even judges' salaries.
Key takeaways
- Financial Emergency needs approval within two months by simple majority and then lasts until revoked.
- Its effects are about money: financial propriety, salaries and reservation of money bills.
- Only Article 352 needs a special majority, has a one-month deadline and can be ended by a Lok Sabha disapproval resolution.
- Only Article 356 has a fixed maximum, three years.
Draw the comparison table from memory once a day for a week. Mixed emergency questions then become look-up exercises rather than memory tests.
Check your understanding
-
1. A proclamation of Financial Emergency must be approved by Parliament:
- Within one month by special majority
- Within two months by simple majority
- Within six months by simple majority
- It needs no approval
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 360 requires approval by both Houses within two months, by simple majority.
-
2. Once approved, a Financial Emergency continues for:
- Six months
- One year
- A maximum of three years
- An indefinite period until revoked, without repeated approval
Show answer
Answer: D. Unlike Articles 352 and 356, Article 360 needs no periodic approval and has no maximum period.
-
3. Which of the following can the President do during a Financial Emergency?
- Direct a reduction in the salaries of Supreme Court and High Court judges
- Suspend the enforcement of Article 21
- Dissolve all state assemblies
- Extend the life of the Lok Sabha by one year
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 360(4)(b) allows directions to reduce salaries of Union employees, including Supreme Court and High Court judges. Article 21 cannot be suspended, and extension of the Lok Sabha is linked to Article 352.
-
4. Which emergency requires approval by a special majority of each House?
- Financial Emergency
- President's Rule
- National Emergency under Article 352
- All three
Show answer
Answer: C. Only Article 352 needs a majority of total membership plus two-thirds of members present and voting. The others need a simple majority.
-
5. For which emergency does the Constitution provide that a Lok Sabha resolution of disapproval, passed by simple majority, forces the President to revoke it?
- Article 356 only
- Article 352 only
- Article 360 only
- All three
Show answer
Answer: B. The disapproval mechanism with a special sitting on one-tenth of members' notice exists only in Article 352.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.