• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Match-the-following and chronology questions on emergencies, amendments and cases

Practise matching emergency Articles, Amendments and court cases with their subjects, and arranging emergencies, Amendments and judgments in time order.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Two question types appear again and again on the emergency provisions: 'match list I with list II' and 'arrange in chronological order'. Neither needs deep reasoning, but both punish half-learnt facts. This lesson gives you compact lists to learn, a method for matching, and a way to fix the order of events using a few anchor years.

List 1: the Articles

Articles 352 to 360
ArticleSubject
352Proclamation of National Emergency
353Effect of the proclamation: Union's executive and legislative powers
354Application of revenue-sharing provisions during the emergency
355Duty of the Union to protect states
356President's Rule in a state
357Exercise of the legislature's powers under a Proclamation under 356
358Suspension of Article 19 during an emergency
359Suspension of the enforcement of Fundamental Rights
360Financial Emergency

List 2: Amendments and cases

Amendments and judgments to link with emergencies
ItemWhat to link it with
38th Amendment (1975)President's satisfaction made final; different proclamations on different grounds
42nd Amendment (1976)Emergency may be proclaimed for a part of India
44th Amendment (1978)'Armed rebellion' for 'internal disturbance'; written Cabinet decision; special majority; Articles 20 and 21
ADM Jabalpur (1976)Habeas corpus petitions during the 1975 emergency
Minerva Mills (1980)Limited judicial review of a proclamation; basic structure and balance between rights and directives
S.R. Bommai (1994)Judicial review of President's Rule; floor test; assembly not to be dissolved before approval

Anchor years for chronology

Remember the sequence of years: 1962, 1971, 1975 are the three national emergencies (external aggression, external aggression, internal disturbance). The Amendments follow in the same period: 38th in 1975, 42nd in 1976, and 44th in 1978. The cases are 1973 (Kesavananda Bharati), 1976 (ADM Jabalpur), 1977 (State of Rajasthan), 1980 (Minerva Mills) and 1994 (Bommai).

Worked example 1: matching

Match: (a) 38th Amendment, (b) 42nd Amendment, (c) 44th Amendment, (d) S.R. Bommai with (i) armed rebellion instead of internal disturbance, (ii) emergency for a part of India, (iii) review of President's Rule, (iv) President's satisfaction made final. Working: the 38th made satisfaction final, so (a)-(iv). The 42nd allowed an emergency for part of India, so (b)-(ii). The 44th replaced internal disturbance by armed rebellion, so (c)-(i). Bommai concerns Article 356, so (d)-(iii). Answer: a-iv, b-ii, c-i, d-iii.

Worked example 2: chronological order

Question: Arrange in order of time: (1) Minerva Mills, (2) ADM Jabalpur, (3) Bommai, (4) Kesavananda Bharati. Working: Kesavananda Bharati was decided in 1973, ADM Jabalpur in 1976, Minerva Mills in 1980 and Bommai in 1994. Answer: 4, 2, 1, 3.

Worked example 3: the odd one out

Question: Which of these is NOT an effect of the 44th Amendment on Article 352: (a) 'armed rebellion' replaced 'internal disturbance', (b) approval within one month, (c) emergency can be proclaimed for a part of India, (d) special majority for approval? Working: (a), (b) and (d) are all 1978 changes. The power to proclaim for part of India came from the 42nd Amendment in 1976. Answer: (c).

Years in a line: 1962, 1971, 1975 emergencies; 1975 - 38th; 1976 - 42nd; 1978 - 44th; cases 1973, 1976, 1980, 1994.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Learn Articles 352 to 360 with one phrase each.
  • The 38th and 42nd widened the power; the 44th narrowed it.
  • For chronology, place each item between the anchor years first.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article provides for the suspension of the enforcement of Fundamental Rights during an emergency?

    1. Article 358
    2. Article 359
    3. Article 360
    4. Article 354
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 359 allows the President to suspend the right to move courts for enforcement of rights; Article 358 suspends Article 19.

  2. 2. Arrange in order: Minerva Mills, ADM Jabalpur, Bommai. The correct order is:

    1. ADM Jabalpur, Minerva Mills, Bommai
    2. Minerva Mills, ADM Jabalpur, Bommai
    3. Bommai, ADM Jabalpur, Minerva Mills
    4. ADM Jabalpur, Bommai, Minerva Mills
    Show answer

    Answer: A. ADM Jabalpur was decided in 1976, Minerva Mills in 1980 and Bommai in 1994.

  3. 3. The power to proclaim an emergency for only a part of India came from the:

    1. 38th Amendment
    2. 44th Amendment
    3. 24th Amendment
    4. 42nd Amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 42nd Amendment (1976) introduced this power.

  4. 4. Article 355 deals with:

    1. the Union's duty to protect states
    2. suspension of Article 19
    3. Financial Emergency
    4. revenue sharing in an emergency
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 355 states the duty of the Union to protect every state against external aggression and internal disturbance.

  5. 5. Which pair is correctly matched?

    1. Article 358: the Financial Emergency
    2. Article 357: lawmaking under President's Rule
    3. Article 360: suspension of Article 19 rights
    4. Article 354: President's Rule in a state
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 357 deals with legislative powers under a Proclamation under Article 356. Article 358 is about Article 19, 360 is the Financial Emergency and 354 is revenue sharing.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery