- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Scenario questions on emergencies: from the facts to the Article, the approval and the effects
Practise reading a short situation and working out which emergency applies, who approves it, how long it lasts and what changes for rights and for the state.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Case-based questions give a short story and ask what the Constitution allows. They reward a fixed order of thinking. If you identify the ground first and then follow the same four questions every time, even an unfamiliar story becomes a familiar problem.
The four-question method
- Ground: what has happened - war or aggression, armed rebellion, breakdown of a state's government, or a financial threat?
- Article and approval: which Article applies, who decides, and how soon must Parliament approve, by what majority?
- Duration: for how long, and how can it end?
- Effects: what changes for the states, for the Lok Sabha and for Fundamental Rights?
| Situation | Article |
|---|---|
| Foreign attack or armed rebellion threatens India or a part of it | 352 |
| A state government cannot function according to the Constitution | 356 |
| A state refuses to follow lawful Union directions | 356 read with 365 |
| India's financial stability or credit is threatened | 360 |
Worked example 1: armed rebellion in a region
A well-organised armed rebellion has taken control of districts in one region, and the Union Cabinet decides to recommend an emergency in that region only. Working: Step 1, the ground is armed rebellion, so Article 352. Step 2, the Cabinet's decision must be sent in writing; Parliament must approve within one month by a special majority in each House. Step 3, the proclamation can be limited to the region (42nd Amendment). Step 4, Article 358 does not apply automatically, as the ground is not war or external aggression; but Article 359 may be used for the rights named in a presidential order, excluding Articles 20 and 21. Step 5, Parliament may legislate on State List subjects (Article 250) and the Union can give directions to the state (Article 353). Answer: Article 352 with the consequences listed.
Worked example 2: a state government falls
After an election, no party in a state assembly has a majority. The Governor sends a report that no stable government can be formed after trying all options. The President proclaims President's Rule. Working: the ground is failure of constitutional machinery, so Article 356. Parliament must approve within two months by a simple majority. If approved, it lasts six months from the proclamation, and can be extended up to three years. The Assembly should be kept in suspended animation until Parliament approves, as Bommai laid down. The High Court continues to work. Answer: Article 356, two months, simple majority, six months at a time.
Worked example 3: a threatened treasury
The Union's credit is badly threatened, and the President is satisfied that a financial emergency exists. Working: Article 360. Parliament must approve within two months by a simple majority. Once approved it continues until revoked, with no six-monthly renewal. The Union may direct states to observe financial propriety, direct salary reductions of all or any class of persons serving the Union or states, including judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts, and may require state money bills to be reserved for the President's consideration. Answer: Article 360 with these effects.
Ground first; then Article, approval, duration and effects. Never start from the effects: the same effect (for example, Union directions to states) belongs to more than one emergency.
Key takeaways
- Identify the ground before anything else.
- Armed rebellion and war both trigger Article 352, but only war or external aggression triggers Article 358.
- Each emergency has its own approval time, majority and duration.
Check your understanding
-
1. A foreign army enters Indian territory. Which Article applies?
- Article 352
- Article 356
- Article 360
- Article 365
Show answer
Answer: A. External aggression is a ground for a National Emergency under Article 352.
-
2. In an emergency on the ground of armed rebellion, Article 19 is:
- suspended automatically by Article 358
- suspended by Article 356
- not suspended automatically
- permanently abolished
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 358 applies only to war or external aggression. On armed rebellion Article 19 is not suspended automatically.
-
3. A state government refuses to comply with lawful directions given by the Union. Which Articles are relevant?
- Articles 352 and 358
- Articles 356 and 365
- Articles 360 and 359
- Articles 353 and 354
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 365 says that failure to comply with Union directions can be treated as a breakdown of constitutional machinery, which leads to Article 356.
-
4. In a Financial Emergency, the Union may direct reduction of salaries of:
- Members of Parliament and Ministers only
- Judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts only
- Members of the Election Commission and auditors only
- All or any class of persons serving the Union or states
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 360 allows reduction of salaries of all or any class of persons serving the Union or a state, including High Court and Supreme Court judges.
-
5. Which authority approves the proclamation of President's Rule?
- The Supreme Court
- Parliament
- The Council of States only
- The Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. Both Houses of Parliament must approve it within two months.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.