- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
President's Rule under Article 356: imposition, approval and limits
Apply the rules on imposing, approving, extending and ending President's Rule, including the conditions for going beyond one year and the Bommai safeguards.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
President's Rule, also called State Emergency or Constitutional Emergency, is the emergency provision used most often in practice, so questions on it are common. Its numbers differ from those of Article 352, and that is the main trap: two months instead of one, simple majority instead of special, three years maximum instead of no limit. This lesson sets the two side by side.
The grounds: Articles 355, 356 and 365
Article 355 places a duty on the Union to protect every state against external aggression and internal disturbance and to ensure that the government of every state is carried on in accordance with the Constitution. Article 356 is the means of carrying out that duty. The President may proclaim President's Rule if satisfied, on the report of the Governor or otherwise, that a situation has arisen in which the government of the state cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution. The words 'or otherwise' mean that a Governor's report is not essential. Under Article 365, if a state fails to comply with directions given by the Union, the President may treat this as such a situation.
Approval and duration
The proclamation must be approved by both Houses of Parliament within two months, by a simple majority of members present and voting. Once approved, it lasts six months and can be extended by six months at a time, with approval each time, up to a maximum of three years. If the Lok Sabha is dissolved during the two months, the Rajya Sabha's approval keeps the proclamation alive until 30 days after the new Lok Sabha first sits.
Continuing beyond one year requires both of two conditions, added by the 44th Amendment: a National Emergency must be in operation in the whole of India or in the whole or part of the state, and the Election Commission must certify that general elections to the state assembly cannot be held because of difficulties. The President can revoke the proclamation at any time without Parliament's approval.
What changes in the state
The President takes over the functions of the state government, usually acting through the Governor, and the state Council of Ministers is dismissed. The state legislature is either suspended or dissolved, and Parliament exercises its law-making powers. Parliament may delegate that power to the President (Article 357). The President may also authorise spending from the state's Consolidated Fund when the Lok Sabha is not in session, pending Parliament's sanction. Laws made during this period continue after President's Rule ends until the state legislature changes them. The High Court is not affected; the President cannot take over its powers.
The Bommai safeguards
In S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) a nine-judge bench of the Supreme Court held that a proclamation under Article 356 is open to judicial review; the court can examine whether relevant material existed. The assembly should not be dissolved until Parliament has approved the proclamation; until then it may only be suspended. If the court strikes down the proclamation it can restore the dismissed government. The strength of a government is to be tested on the floor of the House, not in the Governor's residence.
Worked example 1: is a second year allowed?
President's Rule is imposed on 1 January and approved in February. On 1 January the next year the government wants to extend it. Step 1: one year is complete, so the special conditions apply. Step 2: suppose no National Emergency is in operation anywhere. Step 3: the first condition fails, so the extension is not permitted, whatever the Election Commission says.
Worked example 2: the vote
In an illustrative House, 300 members are present and voting on the approval resolution: 155 in favour and 145 against. A simple majority of present and voting is more than 150, so 155 carries the resolution. The same numbers would have failed under Article 352, which needs two-thirds of present and voting, that is 200.
Article 356: two months, simple majority, six months at a time, three years at most; beyond one year only with a National Emergency and an Election Commission certificate.
Key takeaways
- A Governor's report is not essential: 'on the report of the Governor or otherwise'.
- Approval within two months by simple majority; three years is the ceiling.
- Beyond one year needs both conditions together.
- The legislature is suspended or dissolved; the High Court is untouched.
- Bommai made the proclamation reviewable and the floor test the measure of majority.
If a statement mixes Article 352 and Article 356 numbers, separate them using the quote above. That alone eliminates most wrong options.
Check your understanding
-
1. Within what period must a proclamation under Article 356 be approved by Parliament?
- One month
- Two months
- Six months
- Fourteen days
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 356 requires approval by both Houses within two months, by simple majority.
-
2. What is the maximum period for which President's Rule can continue?
- One year
- Six months
- Three years
- No limit
Show answer
Answer: C. It can be extended six months at a time up to a maximum of three years.
-
3. Which of the following is NOT affected by a proclamation under Article 356?
- The state Council of Ministers
- The state's legislative powers
- The executive functions of the state government
- The High Court of the state
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 356(1)(c) forbids the President from assuming any power of the High Court or suspending provisions relating to it.
-
4. For President's Rule to continue beyond one year, what is required?
- Both a National Emergency in operation (in the whole of India or the whole or part of the state) and an Election Commission certificate
- Only an Election Commission certificate
- Only a National Emergency
- Approval by a special majority of the Rajya Sabha
Show answer
Answer: A. The 44th Amendment requires both conditions together; either one alone is not enough.
-
5. Which article allows the President to treat a state's failure to comply with Union directions as a failure of constitutional machinery?
- Article 352
- Article 360
- Article 365
- Article 368
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 365 says the President may hold that the state's government cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution if it fails to comply with Union directions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.