- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Common traps in syllogism questions and how to avoid them
Study the most frequent mistakes, such as reversing an All statement or using either-or at the wrong moment, and build a habit that catches each one before it costs a mark.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most marks in syllogism are lost to a small set of repeated mistakes, not to difficult logic. This lesson lists them one by one. For each trap you will see what goes wrong, a quick safeguard, and a worked problem in which the trap is waiting.
The trap list
| Trap | What goes wrong | Safeguard |
|---|---|---|
| Real-world knowledge | You reject a conclusion because it sounds false | Treat the statements as true, however strange |
| Reversing All | All A are B turned into All B are A | All reverses only to Some B are A |
| Linking two Somes | Some A are B and Some B are C taken to give Some A are C | Two Some statements never give a conclusion |
| Reversing Some-not | Some A are not B turned into Some B are not A | Some-not cannot be reversed |
| Wrong either-or | Applied to conclusions on different terms, or when one already follows | Test each alone first; same terms in the same order for All and Some-not |
| Possible versus definite | A 'can be' conclusion treated as certain, or the reverse | Possible needs one fitting diagram; definite needs all |
| Stopping early | One conclusion follows, so the other is ignored | Test both conclusions every time |
Accept the statements, test each conclusion alone, and use either-or last.
Worked problems
Problem 1 (real world). Statements: All fish are birds. All birds can swim. Conclusion: All fish can swim. The statements are false in the real world, but the question says to accept them. All A are B and All B are C give All A are C, so the conclusion follows.
Problem 2 (wrong either-or). Statement: Some pens are blue. I. All pens are blue. II. Some blue things are not pens. These look like opposites but they are not on the same terms in the same order: 'All pens are blue' has the opposite 'Some pens are not blue', not 'Some blue things are not pens'. Neither follows alone, and there is no either-or. Neither follows. Compare II with 'Some pens are not blue', which would make an either-or pair.
Problem 3 (a good either-or). Statements: All books are papers. Some papers are files. I. Some books are files. II. No file is a book. Neither follows alone. The conclusions are Some and No on the same two terms, and these two forms are symmetrical, so the order does not matter. Either I or II follows.
Problem 4 (one follows already). Statement: All A are B. I. Some A are B. II. No A is B. I follows. II is its opposite, so it cannot. Either-or is not used, because it needs both conclusions to fail alone. Only I follows.
Problem 5 (possibility). Statement: All A are B. 'Possibly some B are not A.' Draw A smaller than B, so part of B lies outside A. The diagram fits, so the possibility holds. But the definite statement 'Some B are not A' does not follow, since B and A may be identical.
A pre-answer checklist
- Did I translate every sentence, especially 'only' and 'not all'?
- Did I test both conclusions alone?
- Did I reverse anything? If so, was it a No, a Some, or an All turned into Some?
- If I chose either-or, do the conclusions share the same terms, and does neither follow alone?
- If the word is 'possible', did I find one fitting diagram?
Key takeaways
- Most errors come from reversals and from either-or misuse.
- A definite conclusion must hold in every diagram; a possibility needs one.
- Run the checklist before you mark an answer.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: All lamps are bright. A student concludes 'All bright things are lamps'. What is wrong?
- An All statement cannot be reversed
- Lamps are not bright
- The conclusion is too weak
- The statement is a possibility
Show answer
Answer: A. All A are B reverses only to Some B are A. 'All bright things are lamps' would need the circles to be identical.
-
2. Statements: Some cats are black. Some black things are rare. Which conclusion follows?
- None of the three below
- Some cats are rare
- Some rare things are cats
- Some cats are not rare
Show answer
Answer: A. Two Some statements never give a conclusion. Cats that are black and black things that are rare may be different members.
-
3. Statement: Some roads are wet. I. All roads are wet. II. Some roads are not wet. What is the correct answer?
- Only conclusion I follows
- Either I or II follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Neither conclusion follows
Show answer
Answer: B. Neither follows alone, since the statement settles neither. They are the All and Some-not pair on the same terms, so one of them must be true.
-
4. Statement: All bags are boxes. Which of these is only a possibility, not a certainty?
- Some bags are boxes
- Some boxes are bags
- Some boxes are not bags
- All bags are boxes
Show answer
Answer: C. Boxes outside the bags are possible but not forced, since the circles may coincide. The other three are certain.
-
5. Statement: Some fruits are not sweet. A student writes 'Some sweet things are not fruits'. What should you do?
- Accept it, because it is a reversal
- Accept it, because it is an either-or
- Reject it, because it contradicts the statement
- Reject it, because Some-not cannot be reversed
Show answer
Answer: D. Some A are not B cannot be reversed. The new sentence is not forced, though it does not contradict the statement.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.