- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Problem set: negative statements with All, Some and No
Practise every pairing in which one statement says 'No', learn which pairs give 'Some are not' conclusions, and meet the two-negative case that produces an either-or.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Statements containing 'No' cause the most lost marks, because the conclusion changes its form: a pair of true statements about groups inside each other can give a negative conclusion with the words 'Some ... are not'. This lesson sets out all five pairings that include a 'No' statement and then drills them with worked problems.
The five pairings with a No statement
| Statement 1 | Statement 2 | Conclusion | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| All A are B | No B is C | No A is C | A sits inside B, B avoids C |
| No A is B | All B are C | Some C are not A | B is inside C and avoids A |
| Some A are B | No B is C | Some A are not C | Those A that are B avoid C |
| No A is B | Some B are C | Some C are not A | Those C that are B avoid A |
| No A is B | No B is C | None | A and C both avoid B, but may overlap |
Watch the direction of the last words. When the first statement is 'No A is B' and the second is 'All B are C' or 'Some B are C', the conclusion is about C first: Some C are not A. The conclusion 'Some A are not C' does not follow in those two cases.
No with All or Some gives 'Some C are not A'. All or Some with No gives 'No A is C' or 'Some A are not C'. No with No gives nothing.
Worked problems
Problem 1. Statements: No bird is a fish. Some fish are red. Conclusions: I. Some red things are not birds. II. Some birds are not red. Statement 1 is No A is B and statement 2 is Some B are C, so Some C are not A: Some red things are not birds. I follows. II has the form Some A are not C, which does not follow: all birds may be red. Only I follows.
Problem 2. Statements: No stone is glass. All glass is brittle. Conclusions: I. Some brittle things are not stones. II. No brittle thing is a stone. No A is B with All B are C gives Some C are not A, so I follows. II is far too strong, since some brittle thing other than glass could be a stone. Only I follows.
Problem 3. Statements: Some coins are metal. No metal is paper. Conclusions: I. Some coins are not paper. II. No coin is paper. Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C, so I follows. II does not follow, because the coins that are not metal are left unconstrained. Only I follows.
Problem 4. Statements: No pen is a book. No book is a table. Conclusions: I. Some pens are tables. II. No pen is a table. Two No statements give no conclusion, so neither follows alone. But the conclusions are Some and No on the same terms, which is a complementary pair. Either I or II follows.
Problem 5. Statements: All cats are pets. No pet is a plant. Conclusions: I. No plant is a cat. II. Some cats are not plants. The table gives No cat is a plant. I is the reversal of this. II follows because cats exist and none is a plant. Both follow.
A reading trick
Replace the statements with a picture in your head. For 'No A is B, All B are C', picture B as a small circle inside C and A well away from B. Then ask what is certain about the part of C outside B. Part of C may be A, part may not. Only the C members that are B are certainly not A, so you can say only 'Some C are not A'.
Key takeaways
- There are four pairings with No that give a conclusion, and one (No with No) that gives none.
- The group named first in the conclusion is the one that carries the words 'are not'.
- A conclusion with No in it is too strong whenever the statements leave an unconstrained part.
- Two No statements may still produce an either-or pair.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: No bus is a boat. All boats float. Which conclusion follows?
- Some floating things are not buses
- Some buses are not floating things
- No floating thing is a bus
- All buses are floating things
Show answer
Answer: A. No A is B with All B are C gives Some C are not A: Some floating things are not buses. 'No floating thing is a bus' is too strong.
-
2. Statements: All roses are flowers. No flower is a stone. Which conclusion follows?
- Some roses are stones
- No rose is a stone
- Some stones are roses
- All stones are flowers
Show answer
Answer: B. All A are B with No B is C gives No A is C. The other options contradict this or say something not stated.
-
3. Statements: Some pens are red. No red thing is cheap. Which conclusion follows?
- No pen is cheap
- All pens are cheap
- Some pens are not cheap
- Some cheap things are pens
Show answer
Answer: C. Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C. The pens that are not red are not covered by the second statement, so No pen is cheap is too strong.
-
4. Statements: No tiger is a cow. Some cows are white. Which conclusion follows?
- Some tigers are not white things
- No tiger is a white thing
- Some tigers are white things
- Some white things are not tigers
Show answer
Answer: D. No A is B with Some B are C gives Some C are not A: Some white things are not tigers. The conclusion about tigers being not white does not follow.
-
5. Statements: No cup is a plate. No plate is a bowl. Which answer is correct for I. Some cups are bowls and II. No cup is a bowl?
- Either I or II follows
- Only conclusion I follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Neither conclusion follows
Show answer
Answer: A. Two No statements give no conclusion, so neither follows alone. The conclusions are Some and No on the same terms, so exactly one is true: either I or II.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.