• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Problem set: negative statements with All, Some and No

Practise every pairing in which one statement says 'No', learn which pairs give 'Some are not' conclusions, and meet the two-negative case that produces an either-or.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Statements containing 'No' cause the most lost marks, because the conclusion changes its form: a pair of true statements about groups inside each other can give a negative conclusion with the words 'Some ... are not'. This lesson sets out all five pairings that include a 'No' statement and then drills them with worked problems.

The five pairings with a No statement

Pairings that include a No statement
Statement 1Statement 2ConclusionReading
All A are BNo B is CNo A is CA sits inside B, B avoids C
No A is BAll B are CSome C are not AB is inside C and avoids A
Some A are BNo B is CSome A are not CThose A that are B avoid C
No A is BSome B are CSome C are not AThose C that are B avoid A
No A is BNo B is CNoneA and C both avoid B, but may overlap

Watch the direction of the last words. When the first statement is 'No A is B' and the second is 'All B are C' or 'Some B are C', the conclusion is about C first: Some C are not A. The conclusion 'Some A are not C' does not follow in those two cases.

No with All or Some gives 'Some C are not A'. All or Some with No gives 'No A is C' or 'Some A are not C'. No with No gives nothing.

— Rule to remember

Worked problems

Problem 1. Statements: No bird is a fish. Some fish are red. Conclusions: I. Some red things are not birds. II. Some birds are not red. Statement 1 is No A is B and statement 2 is Some B are C, so Some C are not A: Some red things are not birds. I follows. II has the form Some A are not C, which does not follow: all birds may be red. Only I follows.

Problem 2. Statements: No stone is glass. All glass is brittle. Conclusions: I. Some brittle things are not stones. II. No brittle thing is a stone. No A is B with All B are C gives Some C are not A, so I follows. II is far too strong, since some brittle thing other than glass could be a stone. Only I follows.

Problem 3. Statements: Some coins are metal. No metal is paper. Conclusions: I. Some coins are not paper. II. No coin is paper. Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C, so I follows. II does not follow, because the coins that are not metal are left unconstrained. Only I follows.

Problem 4. Statements: No pen is a book. No book is a table. Conclusions: I. Some pens are tables. II. No pen is a table. Two No statements give no conclusion, so neither follows alone. But the conclusions are Some and No on the same terms, which is a complementary pair. Either I or II follows.

Problem 5. Statements: All cats are pets. No pet is a plant. Conclusions: I. No plant is a cat. II. Some cats are not plants. The table gives No cat is a plant. I is the reversal of this. II follows because cats exist and none is a plant. Both follow.

A reading trick

Replace the statements with a picture in your head. For 'No A is B, All B are C', picture B as a small circle inside C and A well away from B. Then ask what is certain about the part of C outside B. Part of C may be A, part may not. Only the C members that are B are certainly not A, so you can say only 'Some C are not A'.

Key takeaways

  • There are four pairings with No that give a conclusion, and one (No with No) that gives none.
  • The group named first in the conclusion is the one that carries the words 'are not'.
  • A conclusion with No in it is too strong whenever the statements leave an unconstrained part.
  • Two No statements may still produce an either-or pair.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statements: No bus is a boat. All boats float. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some floating things are not buses
    2. Some buses are not floating things
    3. No floating thing is a bus
    4. All buses are floating things
    Show answer

    Answer: A. No A is B with All B are C gives Some C are not A: Some floating things are not buses. 'No floating thing is a bus' is too strong.

  2. 2. Statements: All roses are flowers. No flower is a stone. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some roses are stones
    2. No rose is a stone
    3. Some stones are roses
    4. All stones are flowers
    Show answer

    Answer: B. All A are B with No B is C gives No A is C. The other options contradict this or say something not stated.

  3. 3. Statements: Some pens are red. No red thing is cheap. Which conclusion follows?

    1. No pen is cheap
    2. All pens are cheap
    3. Some pens are not cheap
    4. Some cheap things are pens
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C. The pens that are not red are not covered by the second statement, so No pen is cheap is too strong.

  4. 4. Statements: No tiger is a cow. Some cows are white. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some tigers are not white things
    2. No tiger is a white thing
    3. Some tigers are white things
    4. Some white things are not tigers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. No A is B with Some B are C gives Some C are not A: Some white things are not tigers. The conclusion about tigers being not white does not follow.

  5. 5. Statements: No cup is a plate. No plate is a bowl. Which answer is correct for I. Some cups are bowls and II. No cup is a bowl?

    1. Either I or II follows
    2. Only conclusion I follows
    3. Only conclusion II follows
    4. Neither conclusion follows
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Two No statements give no conclusion, so neither follows alone. The conclusions are Some and No on the same terms, so exactly one is true: either I or II.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery