- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Either-or conclusions
Identify when two conclusions form a complementary pair so that one of them must follow, even though neither follows alone.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Sometimes neither conclusion follows by itself, but together they cover every possibility. Then the answer is 'either I or II follows'.
Two complementary pairs
- Some A are B and No A is B: exactly one of them must be true.
- All A are B and Some A are not B: exactly one of them must be true.
Use this only when the statements do not already settle the matter, and when both conclusions have the same two terms in the same order.
Worked example 1
Statements: All flowers are plants; some plants are trees. Conclusions: I. Some flowers are trees. II. No flower is a tree. The flower circle sits inside plants and the tree circle overlaps plants. The two may or may not overlap, so neither I nor II follows alone. They are a complementary pair, so either I or II follows.
Worked example 2
Statement: Some pens are books. I. All pens are books. II. Some pens are not books. The statement does not say whether any pen lies outside books, so neither follows alone. But they form the pair 'All' and 'Some not', so either I or II follows.
Neither alone, but a complete pair together: either-or.
Key takeaways: either-or applies only when neither conclusion follows alone and the two are a complementary pair.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: All X are Y. Some Y are Z. Conclusions: I. Some X are Z. II. No X is Z.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: C. The Z part of Y may or may not overlap X, so neither follows alone. The two conclusions have the same terms (X, Z) and are the opposite pair Some / No, so either I or II follows.
-
2. Statement: No pen is a pencil. Conclusions: I. Some pens are pencils. II. Some pens are not pencils.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: B. I contradicts the statement. II follows: if no pen is a pencil, then some pens are not pencils. One conclusion follows on its own, so this is not an either-or case.
-
3. Which pair of conclusions is complementary, so that exactly one of them must be true?
- Some A are B and Some A are not B
- All A are B and No A is B
- Some A are B and No A is B
- All A are B and Some B are A
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Some A are B' and 'No A is B' cannot both be true and cannot both be false. 'Some' and 'Some not' can both be true; 'All' and 'No' can both be false; and 'All A are B' already gives 'Some B are A'.
-
4. Statement: Some doctors are tall. Conclusions: I. Some doctors are not tall. II. No doctor is tall.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: D. I does not follow, because all doctors could be tall. II contradicts the statement. 'Some not' and 'No' are not a complementary pair, so the answer is neither, not either-or.
-
5. Statements: Some pens are books. All books are red. Conclusions: I. Some pens are red. II. No pen is red.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: A. 'Some A are B' with 'All B are C' gives 'Some A are C', so I follows on its own and II is false. Either-or is used only when neither conclusion follows alone.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.