- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Four statement types and conversions
Understand All, No, Some and Some-not statements with Venn diagrams, and know which conversions are always valid.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A syllogism gives you statements about groups and asks which conclusions definitely follow. You must ignore what you know about the real world and use only the statements. The best tool is a Venn diagram: a circle for each group.
The four statement types
| Statement | Venn picture | What it guarantees |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | Circle A inside circle B | Every A is a B |
| No A is B | Two separate circles | Nothing is both |
| Some A are B | Circles overlap | At least one A is a B |
| Some A are not B | Part of A lies outside B | At least one A is not a B |
Valid conversions
- All A are B gives Some B are A.
- Some A are B gives Some B are A.
- No A is B gives No B is A.
- Some A are not B has no valid conversion.
Worked example 1
Statement: All cats are animals. 'Some animals are cats' follows, because the cat circle sits inside the animal circle and is not empty. 'All animals are cats' does not follow, because the animal circle may be bigger.
Worked example 2
Statement: No pen is a book. 'No book is a pen' follows, because separate circles are separate in both directions. 'Some pens are books' contradicts the statement, so it does not follow.
A conclusion follows only if it is true in every possible Venn diagram.
Key takeaways: learn the four Venn pictures and the three valid conversions; the fourth type has none.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: Some pens are not blue. Which conclusion follows?
- Some blue things are not pens
- Some pens are blue
- No pen is blue
- None of these follows
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Some A are not B' has no valid conversion, so 'Some blue things are not pens' does not follow. 'Some pens are blue' and 'No pen is blue' are both possible but neither is certain. So none of them follows.
-
2. Statement: All engineers are graduates. Which conclusion follows?
- All graduates are engineers
- Some graduates are engineers
- Some engineers are not graduates
- No graduate is an engineer
Show answer
Answer: B. The engineer circle lies inside the graduate circle and is not empty, so some graduates are engineers. The graduate circle may be bigger, so 'All graduates are engineers' does not follow.
-
3. Which Venn picture shows 'All A are B'?
- Circle B inside circle A
- Circle A inside circle B
- Two separate circles
- Two circles that only partly overlap
Show answer
Answer: B. Every A is a B, so the whole of circle A sits inside circle B. Separate circles show 'No A is B', and a partial overlap shows 'Some A are B'.
-
4. Statement: No teacher is a student. Conclusions: I. No student is a teacher. II. Some teachers are not students.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: C. 'No A is B' converts to 'No B is A', so I follows. Since no teacher is a student and there are teachers, some teachers are certainly not students, so II follows too.
-
5. Statement: Some roses are red. Conclusions: I. Some red things are roses. II. Some roses are not red.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: A. 'Some A are B' converts to 'Some B are A', so I follows. II does not follow, because 'some' allows that all roses might be red.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.