• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mixed practice: three and four statements, with either-or and possibility

Apply the whole toolkit to longer questions: chain statements in pairs, test several conclusions, decide when either-or applies, and judge 'possible' conclusions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Harder questions give three or four statements and up to four conclusions. They use the same rules as the two-statement questions, but you must apply them in a chain and keep track of what you have already derived. This final practice lesson gives a method and five fully worked problems.

The chain method

  1. Write the statements in order and look for the common groups that link neighbours.
  2. Combine two statements at a time with the rules table and write the result beside them.
  3. Combine that result with the next statement, and keep going until nothing more can be derived.
  4. Test each conclusion: is it on your list of derived results, or a reversal of one?
  5. For doubtful conclusions, ask whether a diagram could make them false.

Each step is a two-statement problem. Write down every result you derive; the conclusions will be on that list.

— Rule to remember

Worked problems

Problem 1. Statements: All sparrows are birds. All birds are animals. No animal is a plant. Some plants are green. Conclusions: I. No sparrow is a plant. II. Some green things are not animals. III. Some green things are not sparrows. IV. Some green things are sparrows. Chain: sparrows, birds and animals give All sparrows are animals. With No animal is a plant, this gives No sparrow is a plant (I). Some plants are green with No animal is a plant gives Some green things are not animals (II). Those same green things are not sparrows either (III), since sparrows are animals. IV contradicts this chain. I, II and III follow; IV does not.

Problem 2. Statements: Some doctors are tall. All tall people are strong. All strong people are healthy. Conclusions: I. Some doctors are healthy. II. Some healthy people are doctors. III. All doctors are healthy. IV. All tall people are healthy. Some doctors are tall and All tall are strong give Some doctors are strong; with the third statement this becomes Some doctors are healthy (I), and its reversal is II. All tall are strong and All strong are healthy give All tall are healthy (IV). III has no support. I, II and IV follow.

Problem 3. Statements: All kittens are cats. Some cats are brown. No brown thing is tall. Conclusions: I. Some cats are not tall. II. Some kittens are not tall. III. No kitten is tall. IV. Possibly some kittens are tall. The last two statements give Some cats are not tall (I). The kittens may all lie in the part of cats that is not brown, so II and III are not forced. A diagram with a kitten that is tall and not brown fits all the statements, so IV is a valid possibility. I follows, II and III do not, IV is possible.

Problem 4. Statements: All kittens are cats. Some cats are brown. All brown things are furry. Conclusions: I. Some kittens are furry. II. No kitten is furry. The chain gives Some cats are furry, but nothing about kittens in particular. Neither follows alone, and the pair is Some and No on the same terms, so either I or II follows.

Problem 5. Statements: No pen is a book. All books are papers. Some papers are files. Conclusions: I. Some papers are not pens. II. Some files are papers. III. Some files are not pens. No pen is a book with All books are papers gives Some papers are not pens (I). The third statement reverses to Some files are papers (II). III would need the files to be the same papers that are not pens, and that is not given. I and II follow; III does not.

Time management

  • Spend the first twenty seconds building the derived list.
  • Reject conclusions that name the wrong pair of groups or reverse an All statement.
  • Leave either-or and possibility for the end, after you have checked every conclusion alone.

Key takeaways

  • Combine in pairs, write down every derived result, then test the conclusions.
  • A conclusion that appears on your derived list, or as its reversal, follows.
  • Either-or and possibility are tested last.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statements: All A are B. All B are C. Some C are D. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some D are C
    2. Some A are D
    3. All D are C
    4. Some B are not D
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Reverse the third statement. The chain A, B, C gives All A are C, but All B are C with Some C are D gives no link from A or B to D, so only the reversal follows.

  2. 2. Statements: Some men are teachers. All teachers are wise. All wise people are old. Which conclusion follows?

    1. Some men are old
    2. All men are old
    3. All teachers are men
    4. No wise person is a man
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Some men are teachers and All teachers are wise give Some men are wise; with the third statement, Some men are old. The other conclusions are not forced.

  3. 3. Statements: All pens are tools. No tool is a toy. Some toys are red. Which conclusion follows?

    1. All red things are toys
    2. Some red things are not pens
    3. No red thing is a pen
    4. Some pens are red
    Show answer

    Answer: B. All pens are tools and No tool is a toy give No pen is a toy. The red toys are not pens, so Some red things are not pens follows. 'No red thing is a pen' is too strong.

  4. 4. Statements: All kittens are cats. Some cats are brown. All brown things are furry. Which pair of conclusions makes an either-or?

    1. All kittens are furry; no cat is furry
    2. Some cats are furry; no cat is furry
    3. Some kittens are furry; no kitten is furry
    4. Some brown things are kittens; all kittens are brown
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chain gives Some cats are furry, but nothing definite about kittens, so neither 'Some kittens are furry' nor 'No kitten is furry' follows alone. They are Some and No on the same terms: an either-or pair. In the other pairs, a member follows or the terms differ.

  5. 5. Statements: All A are B. Some B are C. No C is D. Which conclusion is only a possibility, not certain?

    1. Some B are not D
    2. Some B are C
    3. Some C are B
    4. Some A are D
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Some B are not D is certain, and the other two options are the statement and its reversal. A can sit inside B, and the part of B outside C may overlap D, so Some A are D is possible only.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Syllogism

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery