• Practice
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Possibility conclusions

Decide whether a possibility conclusion is true by finding at least one valid Venn diagram in which it holds.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A definite conclusion must hold in every diagram. A possibility conclusion only has to hold in at least one diagram that fits the statements. So you look for one diagram, not all.

Method

  1. Draw the statements first, keeping them true.
  2. Try to redraw the circles so the possibility is true, without breaking any statement.
  3. If you can, the possibility is true; if every diagram breaks a statement, it is false.

Worked example 1

Statements: All A are B; some B are C. Is 'some A are C' a possibility? Yes. Draw the C-part of B overlapping A and the statements still hold. 'No A is C' is also possible, drawing C in the part of B outside A.

Worked example 2

Statement: No A is B. Is 'some A are B' a possibility? No. Every diagram has A and B separate, so the possibility is false.

Definite: true in every diagram. Possible: true in at least one diagram.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: for a possibility, one fitting diagram is enough; it fails only when every diagram contradicts it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statements: All A are B. Some B are C. Conclusions: I. Some A being C is a possibility. II. All C being A is a possibility.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: C. For a possibility one fitting diagram is enough. Draw C overlapping A inside B: I is possible. Draw C entirely inside A: every A is still B and some B are C, so II is possible too. Both follow.

  2. 2. Statement: No A is B. Conclusions: I. Some A being B is a possibility. II. All A being B is a possibility.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Every diagram of 'No A is B' keeps A and B separate, so neither some nor all A can be B. Neither possibility follows.

  3. 3. Statement: Some A are B. Conclusions: I. All A being B is a possibility. II. No A being B is a possibility.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A may lie wholly inside B and the statement stays true, so I is possible. 'No A is B' contradicts 'Some A are B' in every diagram, so II is not possible.

  4. 4. Statements: All A are B. No B is C. Conclusions: I. Some A being C is a possibility. II. Some B being not A is a possibility.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A is inside B and B is apart from C in every diagram, so A can never meet C: I fails. The B circle may be larger than A, so some B being not A is possible: II follows.

  5. 5. When does a possibility conclusion follow?

    1. Only when it is true in every diagram
    2. When it agrees with real-world knowledge
    3. When neither definite conclusion follows
    4. When it is true in at least one diagram that fits the statements
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A definite conclusion must hold in every diagram; a possibility needs only one diagram that keeps all the statements true and makes the possibility true.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Three statements and mixed practice

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery