- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Problem set: two statements, two conclusions, four answer choices
Work through the standard exam layout with Only I, Only II, Both and Neither, using a three-check routine that settles each conclusion in under a minute.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The most common syllogism question gives two statements and two conclusions, and four answer choices: only I follows, only II follows, both follow, or neither follows. A sixth choice, 'either I or II', appears when the conclusions are a pair of opposites. The way to be fast and accurate is to test each conclusion separately with the same three checks, every time.
The three-check routine
- Reversal check. Is the conclusion a legal reversal of a statement? (No and Some reverse freely; All reverses only to Some.)
- Table check. Combine the two statements with the rules table. Does the conclusion, or a reversal of it, match the result?
- Opposite check. If neither works, see whether the two conclusions are a Some/No pair, or an All/Some-not pair, on the same terms, in the same order. If so, the answer is either I or II. Otherwise the answer for that conclusion is 'does not follow'.
| Result for I | Result for II | Answer to choose |
|---|---|---|
| Follows | Follows | Both follow |
| Follows | Does not | Only I follows |
| Does not | Follows | Only II follows |
| Does not | Does not, and not a pair | Neither follows |
| Does not | Does not, but a pair | Either I or II follows |
Test each conclusion on its own first. Look for either-or only if neither follows.
Worked problems
Problem 1. Statements: All books are papers. All papers are files. I. All books are files. II. Some files are books. Table check: All A are B and All B are C give All A are C, so I follows. Reversal check: All books are files reverses to Some files are books, so II follows. Both follow.
Problem 2. Statements: Some tables are chairs. All chairs are wooden. I. Some tables are wooden. II. All wooden things are chairs. Table check: Some A are B with All B are C gives Some A are C, so I follows. II reverses an All statement, so it does not follow. Only I follows.
Problem 3. Statements: All roads are paths. No path is a wall. I. No wall is a road. II. Some roads are not walls. The table gives No road is a wall, and its reversal is I, so I follows. Because roads exist, No road is a wall also gives Some roads are not walls, so II follows. Both follow.
Problem 4. Statements: Some cups are plates. Some plates are bowls. I. Some cups are bowls. II. Some bowls are cups. Two Some statements give nothing, so neither follows. The conclusions are not opposites (both are Some), so there is no either-or. Neither follows.
Problem 5. Statements: All men are mortal. Some mortals are wise. I. Some men are wise. II. No man is wise. The pair All A are B, Some B are C gives nothing, so neither follows alone. The conclusions are Some and No on the same terms, so either I or II follows.
Speed advice
- Write the statements in letters (A, B, C) and the conclusions in the same letters.
- Do not draw a diagram unless the table fails you; a table lookup takes seconds.
- Never let the real-world meaning of a word persuade you; the statements are all you have.
- When you reach Neither, ask once whether the two conclusions are a complementary pair before you commit.
Key takeaways
- Run the reversal, table and opposite checks on each conclusion in turn.
- Convert two results into one answer with the table above.
- Either-or is the last resort, not the first guess.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: All pens are tools. All tools are metal. I. All pens are metal. II. Some metal things are pens. Which answer is correct?
- Only conclusion I follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Both follow
- Neither conclusion follows
Show answer
Answer: C. All pens are tools and All tools are metal give All pens are metal (I). Its reversal, Some metal things are pens, follows too (II).
-
2. Statements: Some shirts are cotton. No cotton is silk. I. Some shirts are not silk. II. No shirt is silk. Which answer is correct?
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: A. Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C, so I follows. II is stronger than anything the statements give, so it does not follow.
-
3. Statements: Some cars are blue. Some blue things are old. I. Some cars are old. II. Some old things are cars. Which answer is correct?
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Two Some statements never give a conclusion. Neither conclusion follows, and since both are Some conclusions they are not an opposite pair.
-
4. Statements: All dogs are animals. Some animals are brown. I. Some dogs are brown. II. No dog is brown. Which answer is correct?
- Only conclusion I follows
- Either I or II follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Neither conclusion follows
Show answer
Answer: B. All A are B with Some B are C gives nothing, so neither follows alone. I and II are Some and No on the same terms, so one of them must be true: either I or II.
-
5. Statements: All kings are men. No man is immortal. I. No king is immortal. II. Some men are not kings. Which answer is correct?
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Only I follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: C. All A are B with No B is C gives No A is C, so I follows. II does not follow: it is possible that every man is a king, so no man need lie outside the kings.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.