• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Common traps in time and work problems

Spot the seven mistakes that cost most marks in work problems, and learn the quick check that avoids each one.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most wrong answers in time and work do not come from hard arithmetic. They come from a handful of recurring traps. This lesson names each trap, shows the wrong reasoning beside the right one, and gives a one-line check. Read it before you attempt a timed practice set.

Trap 1: adding times

A can finish a job in 10 days and B in 15 days. How long do they take together? A tempting answer is (10 + 15) ÷ 2 = 12.5 days, or even 25 days. Both are wrong. Add rates, not times: 1/10 + 1/15 = 1/6, so they take 6 days. The check: two workers together must be faster than the faster one alone, so the answer must be less than 10 days.

Trap 2: someone leaves before the end

A can finish a job in 20 days and B in 30 days. They work together, but A leaves 5 days before the work is finished. How long does the work take? Let the total time be t days. B works for all t days and A for t − 5 days. So (t − 5)/20 + t/30 = 1. Multiplying by 60: 3(t − 5) + 2t = 60, which gives 5t = 75 and t = 15 days. Check: A works 10 days and does 10/20 = 1/2; B works 15 days and does 15/30 = 1/2; the total is 1.

Trap 3: changing the hours per day

Ten men working 6 hours a day take 12 days. How long will they take if they work 8 hours a day? The work is 10 × 6 × 12 = 720 man-hours. Now they do 10 × 8 = 80 man-hours a day, so they take 720 ÷ 80 = 9 days. The trap is to forget the hours and say 12 days, or to reduce the days by 8 − 6 = 2.

Trap 4: the sign of a leak

A pipe fills a tank in 6 hours, but a leak can empty the full tank in 10 hours. With both working, what is the time to fill the empty tank? The leak works against the pipe, so subtract. Take 30 units: the pipe adds 5 units an hour, the leak takes away 3 units an hour, and the net is 2 units an hour. The tank fills in 30 ÷ 2 = 15 hours. Adding the rates (5 + 3 = 8) would wrongly give 3.75 hours.

Trap 5: the last partial cycle

A can finish a job in 12 days and B in 8 days. They work on alternate days, A first. Take 24 units: A does 2 and B does 3 per day, so each two-day cycle gives 5 units. After 4 cycles (8 days) there are 20 units. Day 9 belongs to A, who adds 2 units to make 22. On day 10, B needs only the last 2 units, which takes 2/3 of a day. The total is 9 2/3 days. The trap is to say 10 days, the whole of the last day.

Rates add, times do not. Opposing flows subtract. Count every hour. A job that ends part-way through a day takes part of a day.

— Four checks

Trap 6: wages by days only

Two workers with different speeds are paid according to the work they do, not the days. If A does 3 units a day and B does 2 units a day, a Rs 1,500 payment for a job done together is shared 3 : 2, giving Rs 900 and Rs 600. Sharing by days would give each Rs 750.

Trap 7: total time or extra time

A question may ask for the time 'still needed' or 'in all'. In trap 2 the answer for the 'still needed' after A leaves would be 5 days, not 15. Underline the words 'in all' and 'more' as you read.

A quick checklist

  • Is my answer sensible? Together must be faster than alone.
  • Did I use rates, not times?
  • Did I include every stage and every hour?
  • Did I answer what was asked: total, extra or per-person?

Key takeaways

  • Never average or add times; add rates.
  • Convert hours into man-hours.
  • Opposing flows subtract.
  • Handle the last day separately when the work ends in the middle of it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A takes 10 days and B takes 15 days. How long do they take together?

    1. 12.5 days
    2. 25 days
    3. 6 days
    4. 5 days
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 1/10 + 1/15 = 1/6, so they take 6 days.

  2. 2. A takes 20 days and B takes 30 days. They work together, but A leaves 5 days before the work is finished. How long does the work take in all?

    1. 15 days
    2. 12 days
    3. 20 days
    4. 18 days
    Show answer

    Answer: A. (t − 5)/20 + t/30 = 1 gives 5t = 75, so t = 15 days.

  3. 3. Ten men working 6 hours a day take 12 days. How long will they take working 8 hours a day?

    1. 9 days
    2. 10 days
    3. 12 days
    4. 16 days
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 10 × 6 × 12 = 720 man-hours; 720 ÷ (10 × 8) = 9 days.

  4. 4. A pipe fills a tank in 6 hours and a leak empties the full tank in 10 hours. How long to fill the empty tank?

    1. 4 hours
    2. 16 hours
    3. 15 hours
    4. 3.75 hours
    Show answer

    Answer: C. With 30 units: 5 − 3 = 2 per hour, so 30 ÷ 2 = 15 hours.

  5. 5. A takes 12 days and B takes 8 days. They work on alternate days, A first. How long do they take?

    1. 10 days
    2. 9 2/3 days
    3. 9 1/3 days
    4. 9 days
    Show answer

    Answer: B. With 24 units, each 2-day cycle gives 5 units. After 8 days there are 20; day 9 gives 22; B needs 2/3 of day 10. The total is 9 2/3 days.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery