• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Cost-benefit and weighted-score problems: mixed numerical practice

Solve short net present value, benefit-cost ratio, payback and weighted-score problems, and test whether the ranking changes when the weights change.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Numerical questions on decision-making in EIA are short but easy to spoil by a slip in discounting or weights. This lesson gives the four calculations that appear most often, each with a worked example, and a check list for avoiding mistakes.

The four tools

  • Net present value (NPV): NPV = sum of benefit(t) ÷ (1 + r)^t, minus the sum of cost(t) ÷ (1 + r)^t. Choose a project when NPV > 0.
  • Benefit-cost ratio (BCR): present value of benefits ÷ present value of costs. Choose when BCR > 1.
  • Payback period: years until cumulative benefits equal the cost. It ignores later years and discounting, so use it only as a quick screen.
  • Weighted score: total = sum of (weight × score). The highest total (if higher is better) is preferred. Weights should add up to 1.

Worked example 1: a two-year project

An illustrative project costs 200 now and gives benefits of 120 at the end of year 1 and 120 at the end of year 2. The discount rate is 10 per cent. Present value of benefits = 120 ÷ 1.10 + 120 ÷ 1.21 = 109.09 + 99.17 = 208.26. NPV = 208.26 − 200 = +8.26, and BCR = 208.26 ÷ 200 = 1.04. The project just passes. Its undiscounted total benefit is 240, which looks 40 more than the cost, but discounting reduces the real gain to about 8. The simple payback is 200 ÷ 120 = 1.67 years of benefits, so it pays back within two years.

If the same project caused an environmental loss with a present value of 15, NPV would be 8.26 − 15 = −6.74, and BCR would fall below 1 (208.26 ÷ 215 = 0.97). The project would no longer pass.

Worked example 2: how weights decide the ranking

Three sites are scored from 0 to 10 (higher is better) on water protection, ecology and cost. X scores 8, 4 and 6; Y scores 6, 7 and 4; Z scores 5, 6 and 9. First set of weights (water 0.5, ecology 0.3, cost 0.2): X = 4.0 + 1.2 + 1.2 = 6.4; Y = 3.0 + 2.1 + 0.8 = 5.9; Z = 2.5 + 1.8 + 1.8 = 6.1. X ranks first. Second set (water 0.2, ecology 0.3, cost 0.5): X = 1.6 + 1.2 + 3.0 = 5.8; Y = 1.2 + 2.1 + 2.0 = 5.3; Z = 1.0 + 1.8 + 4.5 = 7.3. Now Z ranks first.

The ranking flips because the weights express values, not facts. A good report shows the result under more than one set of weights, and says who chose the weights and why.

Checklist for avoiding errors

  • Discount each year separately, and use the same year-end convention throughout.
  • Include environmental costs as negative benefits or costs.
  • Check that weights add to 1 and that every criterion uses the same direction (higher = better).
  • Answer in the form asked: a number, a ratio, or a ranking.

NPV > 0 and BCR > 1 mean a project passes. Payback ignores discounting. Weighted scores depend on weights: test the ranking under more than one set.

Key takeaways

  • Discount before comparing; undiscounted totals overstate gains.
  • Environmental losses can reverse a positive NPV.
  • Rankings by weighted score are sensitive to the weights.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A project costs 100 now and gives 55 at the end of each of two years. At 10 per cent the present value of benefits is 95.45. What is the NPV?

    1. −4.55
    2. +4.55
    3. +10.00
    4. −10.00
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Present value of benefits = 55 ÷ 1.1 + 55 ÷ 1.21 = 50.00 + 45.45 = 95.45. NPV = 95.45 − 100 = −4.55, so the project fails.

  2. 2. If PV of benefits is 260 and PV of costs is 200, the benefit-cost ratio is:

    1. 0.77
    2. 60
    3. 1.3
    4. 3.5
    Show answer

    Answer: C. BCR = 260 ÷ 200 = 1.3, which is above 1.

  3. 3. Weights are water 0.6 and cost 0.4. Option P scores 7 and 5; option Q scores 5 and 9 (higher is better). Which is preferred?

    1. P, with 6.2 against 6.6
    2. P, with 6.6 against 6.2
    3. They are tied at 6.4
    4. Q, with 6.6 against 6.2
    Show answer

    Answer: D. P = 0.6 × 7 + 0.4 × 5 = 4.2 + 2.0 = 6.2. Q = 0.6 × 5 + 0.4 × 9 = 3.0 + 3.6 = 6.6. Q is higher.

  4. 4. Why does the ranking of sites by weighted score sometimes change when the weights are altered?

    1. The scores themselves change automatically
    2. Different weights favour different sites
    3. Weights are not used in scoring methods
    4. Arithmetic errors always creep in
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The scores stay the same but the importance given to each criterion changes the totals.

  5. 5. The payback period is a weak decision tool mainly because:

    1. It includes every environmental cost
    2. It uses weights that add up to two
    3. It ignores discounting and later benefits
    4. It is only calculated for failing projects
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Payback counts only how fast the cost is recovered. It ignores the time value of money and later flows.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: EIA practice

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery