• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mitigation plans, consultation, monitoring and the weak spots of EIA

Compute residual impacts after mitigation, link EIA stages to the precautionary and polluter-pays principles, and identify common weaknesses of EIA in practice.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The final lesson of this course covers what happens after impacts are predicted, and asks a harder question: why do EIAs sometimes fail? Practice questions use the mitigation hierarchy, simple residual-impact arithmetic, the links between EIA and environmental principles, and statements about weaknesses such as poor baselines or project splitting. All numbers are illustrative.

Residual impacts

Mitigation rarely removes an impact completely. What remains after mitigation is the residual impact, and it is the residual impact that the decision-maker must judge. When measures act one after another, each removing a share of what reaches it, the shares multiply rather than add. Two filters that each remove 50 per cent leave 0.5 × 0.5 = 25 per cent, not zero.

Worked example 1: residual dust

A crusher would release 200 units of dust a day. A water-spray system removes 60 per cent, and a bag filter then removes 80 per cent of what remains. After sprays: 200 × 0.4 = 80 units. After the filter: 80 × 0.2 = 16 units. Overall removal = (200 − 16) ÷ 200 = 92 per cent. The common wrong answer is 60 + 80 = 140 per cent, which is impossible. If the residual 16 units, added to a baseline, still crossed a standard, the next step in the hierarchy would be considered: avoid by relocating, or reduce the scale.

The environmental management plan and monitoring

The environmental management plan sets out each mitigation measure with its responsibility, timing, cost and monitoring indicator, for example 'dust at the boundary, measured monthly'. Approval conditions usually make the plan binding. Monitoring then checks compliance (are the measures in place?) and effects (are the predicted levels being met?). An environmental audit is a periodic, independent check of the same things. Without monitoring and enforcement, the most careful EIA has no effect on the ground.

Principles behind EIA

EIA puts the precautionary principle into practice: it studies a project before approval, and where serious or irreversible harm is possible but uncertain, it supports caution, such as refusing, redesigning or requiring safeguards. It also supports the polluter-pays principle: the proponent pays for the study, for mitigation and for monitoring, so these costs are built into the project rather than passed to the public. Public participation, also a principle of the Rio Declaration of 1992, is built into the consultation stage.

Weak spots in practice

  • Conflict of interest: the report is paid for by the proponent, which can bias it towards approval.
  • Thin baselines: data from a single season, or copied from other studies, hide real conditions.
  • Project splitting: dividing one large project into smaller parts so each falls below a screening threshold, which also hides cumulative effects.
  • Treating consultation as a formality, with documents that local people cannot read or understand.
  • Weak monitoring and enforcement after approval, so conditions are not followed.

Worked example 2: spot the weakness

A company plans a 120-hectare mine. Suppose, in an imaginary rule, mines above 100 hectares need full assessment. The company applies for two mines of 60 hectares each, on adjoining plots, under different subsidiary names. Each application alone falls below the threshold, so each would escape full assessment, and their combined effects on the same groundwater and village would never be studied together. This is project splitting. The remedy is to screen linked projects together and to look at cumulative effects.

Residual = initial × (1 − r1) × (1 − r2)… Removal efficiencies multiply, they do not add. EIA puts precaution, polluter pays and public participation into practice.

Key takeaways: judge the residual impact, not the gross one; sequential removal efficiencies multiply; the environmental management plan makes measures specific and monitorable; EIA is a practical tool for precaution, polluter pays and public participation; watch for conflict of interest, thin baselines, project splitting, token consultation and weak monitoring.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A source emits 500 units. A first device removes 70 per cent and a second removes 50 per cent of what remains. What is the residual emission?

    1. 0 units
    2. 150 units
    3. 75 units
    4. 100 units
    Show answer

    Answer: C. After the first device: 500 × 0.3 = 150. After the second: 150 × 0.5 = 75 units.

  2. 2. Dividing one large project into smaller parts so that each falls below a screening threshold is called:

    1. Scoping
    2. Offsetting
    3. Strategic assessment
    4. Project splitting
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Project splitting evades screening and hides cumulative effects.

  3. 3. Requiring the project proponent to pay for mitigation and monitoring reflects which principle?

    1. Precautionary principle only
    2. Common but differentiated responsibilities
    3. Polluter pays
    4. Intergenerational discounting
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Building environmental costs into the project's own costs is the polluter-pays principle.

  4. 4. Which is a commonly cited weakness of EIA in practice?

    1. EIA is done before approval
    2. EIA includes public consultation
    3. EIA considers alternatives
    4. The report is paid for by the proponent, creating a possible conflict of interest
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The other three are features of good EIA; dependence on the proponent's consultants is a recognised weakness.

  5. 5. A device is said to remove 60 per cent of dust and a second one 40 per cent of what remains. What is the overall removal?

    1. 76 per cent
    2. 100 per cent
    3. 24 per cent
    4. 50 per cent
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Remaining = 0.4 × 0.6 = 0.24, so overall removal = 1 − 0.24 = 76 per cent.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery